The results out this week of Netherlands incumbent telco and cellco KPN show the potential ‘basket case,’ problems that European telcos will have as their cellular arms weaken in the face of over the top propositions.
KPN revenues fell 14% on the quarter and 10% on the year, and only last year’s higher depreciation applied to the quarter made the loss smaller this time. Our usual measures of KPN are all about the gain of its video proposition against the two major cable operators in the Netherlands, Ziggo and Liberty Global’s UPC.
On that basis you might say that it was doing well, with IPTV adds of 80,000 on the quarter and broadband internet adds of 13,000 taking it to 2 million pay TV customers, with broadband at 2.7 million, a figure that has only inched along over the past two years. It has more fiber attached homes and more quad play customers and a small rise in fixed line ARPU, but there all the good news ends. Broadband ARPU has been flat for years, and IPTV ARPU is only moving because the €10 a month digital terrestrial Digitenne proposition is going away, down this month to 591,000 homes from a 633,000 last quarter, a fall of 42,000, while IPTV has more than absorbed those losses. It looks like KPN is shifting as many Digitenne customers as it can to IPTV, and is gaining a few cable TV customers in the bargain.
And it is in this context that financial regulators will view the bid of Liberty Global to merge with Ziggo in the Netherlands, creating a single operator with a larger market share in broadband and pay TV, and with a similar network reach.
There are also two other highly relevant issues, with cellular growth in the Netherlands at a premium because it is one of the markets in Europe that is already saturated (everyone over 12 has at least one or more cell phones), and this has led to falling mobile base, down 228,000 over the past year, with ARPU in mobile down €2 on a year ago. It is because of this that KPN will shed another 1,500 to 2,000 Full Time Employees, having already gone through one similar reduction program.
The other issue is that in Belgium, where the Liberty Global affiliate Telenet has launched a strong mobile operation and dropped pricing by using its powerful WiFi offload network, and is on track to gain something close to 1 million customers during 2013 when it reports in a week or so. In the Netherlands UPC and Ziggo are already using each other’s WiFi Homespots and Hotspots for mobile offload on an MVNO that Ziggo has launched on the Vodafone network. If that manages to attract a similar percentage of Netherlands customers over the next year, it will see KPN mobile numbers fall substantially.
Meanwhile KPN says it is close to full 4G coverage in the Netherlands (80%), and its Belgium subsidiary Base will have nationwide 4G coverage there by the end of 2014.
KPN has been weakened by its own broadband being used in conjunction with smartphone Apps to replace its SMS services with IM service, and even IP based voice services. It was recently the target of a takeover by America Movile which was subsequently withdrawn, and it could end up turning to Deutsche Telekom, as other telcos in Europe have already done, and ask to be taken over and offered financial stability and protection from such offers.
The Netherlands is one of the most saturated European markets and this makes KPN an early example of what is likely to happen to incumbent telcos across Europe if they are not careful.