Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 February 2014

Google and Cisco in latest pact to curb the patent trolls

The new year has brought a definite hardening of resistance to the worrying trend for vendors to wield mobile patents as assault weapons. That trend has seen vendors seeking far more than legitimate licensing revenues, instead aiming to disrupt a rival’s whole business (Apple and Microsoft). Others have started behaving like trolls, amassing and brandishing patents which they do not implement in products and hiding behind shell IPR firms (Nokia stands accused of both these practices). And the trolls themselves are gaining unprecedented prominence, initiating more patent lawsuits than the vendors themselves for the first time during 2012.

Google, always a reluctant fighter in the patents wars, has seen attacks on the Android community on many fronts and from all the types of companies listed above ‘ despite having spent billions of dollars acquiring its own protective cloak of IPR, notably with Motorola Mobility. Now the search giant wants to call time on the arms escalation and has announced a series of pacts with major vendors, designed to do just that.

Last month came a major patents alliance with Samsung, which has also been seeking to take the high ground against trolls, partly to appease the European antitrust regulators ‘ which are investigating how it exploits standards-essential IPR ‘ and partly to defuse some of Apple’s barrage of legal attacks. Now Google has announced a cross-licensing pact with Cisco, and with similar language to its comments about the Samsung agreement.

The overall theme is that such deals can enable vendors to extract value from their IPR and innovations without behaving like trolls. Google and Cisco were specific that the motive for their cross-licensing was to protect themselves from litigation and discourage the whole industry from going down that path.

The pact covers ‘a broad range of products and technologies’ and will reduce the risk of what they describe as ‘privateering’ ‘ the practice, adopted by Microsoft, Apple and others, of transferring old patents to shell companies which can then take them to court aggressively. Cisco has been particularly active against trolls and has engaged in several legal battles with shell companies. In 2011, it filed federal racketeering charges against a troll which was demanding fees from hospitality outlets providing Wi-Fi.

Its VP of intellectual property, Dan Lang, commented: ‘In today’s overly litigious environment, cross-licensing is an effective way for technology companies to work together and help prevent unnecessary patent lawsuits.’

Importantly, the two giants’ contract ‘encumbers’ the patents ‘ they cannot be used against either signatory in future, even if they are sold on to a third party. Allen Lo, Google’s general counsel for patents, said Google was open to similar deals with any firm. He said in a recent interview: ‘Given the explosion of patent lawsuits, a strong portfolio helps us enter into cross-licenses and defend our inventions. We’d much rather innovate than litigate.’

Similar sentiments accompanied the announcement of the Samsung-Google IPR deal in January. The companies were sending out strong signals that they want the current cycle of litigation, which has centered on a string of Apple/Samsung spats, to end. “Samsung and Google are showing the rest of the industry that there is more to gain from cooperating than engaging in unnecessary patent disputes,” said Seungho Ahn, the head of Samsung’s Intellectual Property Center.

And in a pointed swipe at Apple, Lo added: ‘By working together on agreements like this, companies can reduce the potential for litigation and focus instead on innovation.’

This echoes the search giant’s contention that the aggressiveness of Apple (and Microsoft) has dragged the Android community into litigation which Google and its partners would not have initiated. Of course, it is also true that Google, which for a long time claimed patent protection was unnecessary in its open world, was wrong-footed by Apple, and forced to spend large sums on building its own IPR defenses, notably with the acquisition of Motorola Mobility.

Despite Samsung’s heavy use of Android, it has not had such a broad formal patents deal with Google until now, though it signed one with Microsoft two years ago. These pacts, a recent settlement of its IPR battles with Ericsson, and an extended cross-licensing arrangement signed with Nokia in November, show the firm seeking to defend itself from legal attacks and with its huge influence on the handset ecosystem, that will affect the balance of power significantly ‘ though of course, the Korean’s high profile court battles with Apple are still dragging on.

A test of whether the iPhone maker’s appetite for hostilities has weakened will be the next round of its Silicon Valley fight with Samsung. The judge, Lucy Koh, has urged both companies to come to a settlement out of court, and has mandated CEO-level mediation talks. If she gets her way, we really may be looking at the end of the current round of smartphone patent wars.