A while ago we made the mistake of signing up for Apple on the Seeking Alpha investors information site, and as an afterthought added Qualcomm. Signing up for Apple is a bit like telling spammers that you ‘want Viagra,’ basically it’s a magnet for a huge amount of useless information, enough to fill your in-box and make your life unlivable.
But after we switched off the Apple feed, the Qualcomm investors data kept coming through, perhaps a single item each day, and for us, its adventures at the sharp end of video processing cores and in WiFi, through its Atheros subsidiary or its in-house designs, made it worth keeping.
Qualcomm was always less likely to be as well understood as Apple (by investors) and its global lead in mobile silicon is barely perceived by the US markets. This lack of understanding makes the stock volatile, but basically it’s really simple.
Qualcomm makes the most mobile modems, and is well placed in ARM based App processing. Atheros used to be number two in WiFi, and as video encroaches on the things that phones do well, it needs to sharpen its act in video processing with H.265 and VP9 video processing capabilities. It has said it wants to take its chips into Home gateways, which in turn means it has to attack other territories.
So while Qualcomm has more than 50% of mobile silicon, and often gets to landmark designs, like LTE modems first, by some margin, which is why it holds about a 90% market share there right now, Broadcom is in its sights as is MediaTek, the Taiwanese mobile chip maker that has also acquired M-Star.
So the dominant mobile maker has found it has to go up against the dominant WiFi chip supplier, which also happens to be the best at video processing on set top SoCs, with a 45% global market share, as well as fight the number two mobile modem maker, who is also dominant in Smart TV chips, which feature plenty of video processing.
Everyone wants to move to SoCs implementations that have ALL of these elements ‘ modems, app processors, tuners in the form of DSPs, GPUs for video processing, Bluetooth and WiFi for connectivity ‘ and as they all move this way, their devices look more and more like one another. The only thing that changes from time to time is that one of them gains a design win with an equipment manufacturer.
It’s not a fair battle, because Qualcomm is that much larger. Broadcom and MediaTek have stock market capitalizations of $17 billion and $22.5 billion respectively, and throw off net incomes of just a few hundred million apiece, on revenues of $8.3 billion for Broadcom and just $4.5 billion for MediaTek.
Qualcomm weighs in with a massive $128 billion market capitalization, it has revenues just under $25 billion and income of $6.85 billion. As such in financial terms it towers above both rivals.
But in technological terms, strangely they all rely on large patent hoards and for the most part ARM chip licenses, as well as a list of off the shelf components and core designs from the likes of Imagination Technologies and even tiny MIPs.
In effect they fight with the same weapons, and increasingly this is being done in the same markets. It is in this context that we have to view two MediaTek events this week, including the arrival of MediaTek’s second Octa-core (8 core) smartphone SoC, the MT6595, this one geared to the mid-range sub $300 to $400 Android smartphone market. This shows MediaTek getting a tight grip of the mid-range smartphone SoCs. It has to do this, to keep its high market share in China, but in the US, where it has very few design wins, it has just opened offices in the same home town of Qualcomm, in San Diego, where it plans to steal (whoops, we meant hire) 150 chip engineers.
For many executives, leaving Qualcomm has meant leaving their home town of San Diego, now there is a choice, while Broadcom remains just over an hours’ drive away in Irvine, and that company too has a new mid-range smartphone SoC
The new Broadcom chip is only a dual-core, the M320 LTE SoC, offering 150Mbps when attached to FDD-LTE or TD-LTE networks, plus 42Mbps when attached to an HSPA+ network. It is already validated on 40 networks in 20 countries and is designed to help OEMs rapidly develop a portfolio of affordable 4G LTE mobile devices, the growing sub $300 LTE smartphone market.
It is the similarity of the underlying market that leads to the press releases of both companies sounding word perfect (except for 2 cores versus 8 cores) ‘ support for Android, including 5G WiFi (802.11ac), low energy Bluetooth, GPS (another two chip areas where Broadcom dominates).
One of the key areas of dominance, that you would think would sit with Broadcom is the arrival of H.265 codec support in the video acceleration, but Qualcomm announced this first in its Snapdragon 600 processors which it got out for Mobile World Congress last year and has since followed up with a whole range of SoCs from Snapdragon 200 to 800.
Executives at Qualcomm made it clear all such chips would have hardware assists built in for both encoding and decoding HEVC video, and this is cut in 28 nm geometry, the same as both of these rival chips are now.
Qualcomm said its Snapdragon chips can drive a UHD 4K screen and in future the potential is there to add 7.1 surround sound, implying they would be going after M-Star in TVs and Broadcom in set tops.
Well it’s been a year and there are no design wins on a TV that we’ve heard of and that doesn’t surprise us. Eco-systems are hard to break into. MediaTek is really strong in China on smartphone chips, holding Qualcomm at bay and given that much of the smart phone growth will come from China, MediaTek is now laboring under a 12 month launch gap with the Qualcomm devices ‘ you’d expect Qualcomm chips to be in more devices, especially high end devices there, before MediaTek can get back its market share.
Broadcom said at its launch that it is projecting that the LTE baseband market will grow 64% in 2014 to over 500 million units. So there is room for all three of these players to grow, and much of that will come out of this lower mid-range market of the sub $300 phones.
The real problem as we see it is that Qualcomm is defending the larger territory. Followers of the Japanese game of Go will recognize how, tricky it is on an incumbent, even with a head start, to keep a disproportionate amount of land. Both MediaTek and Broadcom and other players like Nvidia and Intel, are all trying to take a small parcel of the smartphone business away from Qualcomm, while Samsung also competes across the board. So if you were Qualcomm where would you spend your money ‘ on defending the massive market of cellular SoCs or invading pure WiFi, or the set top or Smart TV territories?
This new MediaTek processor shows something of the way the eco-system works. The older 8 core device it came out with in November was pitched at the higher end, and it used an ARM Mali GPU, not its traditional graphics partner of Imagination Technologies. People try things out. But in this new device, the 8 way core has been partnered with Imagination Technologies PowerVR Series6 GPUs.
Instead of the immensely powerful A57 core partnered in a Big Little combination with an A53 core (4 powerful cores and 4 smaller cores, for a variety of combinations). This new SoC uses the ARM Cortex-A17 with the Cortex-A7 CPUs.
To date Qualcomm has protected its US market as if it was impregnable, but with Broadcom slowly picking up close to the pace of Qualcomm and its core technologies ‘ video, Bluetooth, and WiFi becoming more vital on the SoC, there’s every reason to think that it can get some precious design wins, while MediaTek has come to its home town to recruit engineers, but also has Lenovo as one of its design wins, which through its recent acquisition of Motorola’s mobile business, could give it a huge foothold in the US.
It’s not only chip design wins at handset makers that matter, but handset wins especially across borders at operators or among consumers, and especially during times of global consolidation. What would you bet on, more US handsets being sold in China or more Chinese handsets being sold in the US?
For instance under Microsoft, what chips will Nokia devices favor going forwards? Nokia has already decided this week that it will embrace Android in time for Mobile World Congress, although initially at least that will actually strengthen Qualcomm’s grip on the account, because it is expected to use a Snapdragon 200.
Qualcomm is clearly in front in both development timeframes and on any financial measure, but while it uses mostly the same tools, and intends to tread directly on the feet of both of these two mid-range rivals, as well as a host of others, they cannot help but take the fight to the enemy.