Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2014

FCC to go for round two in Net Neutrality rulemaking

The FCC has decided, very carefully by the looks of it, that it should not escalate the Net Neutrality decision by the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, and should instead try to tread more lightly in making its rules.

Essentially the FCC realizes that it won some ground in the case, with the court backing its rights to insist of transparency, and if it had the decision reviewed by a higher authority, it might lose that.

What it now proposes is another attempt at a rulemaking, one that it hopes will build on the parts of its last rule that the court allowed to stand, and somehow make ISPs compelled to behave properly over the internet.

New FCC chairman, Tom Wheeler said this week that he intends to propose rules that will meet the court’s test for preventing improper blocking of and discrimination among Internet traffic, ensuring genuine transparency in how Internet Service Providers manage traffic. And this will then, ‘preserve the Internet as an open platform ”

One of the key wins for the FCC was the court backing its right to improve transparency in how ISPs treat internet traffic ‘ whether they slow it down or not. Wheeler said this was ‘more significant than many people may realize.’ Now he plans to see if there are ways to make that more effective, for instance ensuring that technical APLs are provided for companies selling services over the internet are properly described.

The core aim of the previous rule-making was to prevent blocking and Wheeler thinks he might be able to find a way to achieve that goal, but hasn’t said as yet how that might be achieved. Wheeler said ‘We will carefully consider how, consistent with the court opinion, we can ensure that edge providers (who provide OTT services) are not unfairly blocked, explicitly or implicitly, from reaching consumers, as well as ensuring that consumers can continue to access any lawful
content and services they choose.

The court accepted was that under Section 706 of the 1996 Telecommunications Act the FCC is to encourage broadband deployment by, among other things, removing barriers to infrastructure deployment, encouraging innovation, and promoting competition. And Wheeler thinks that as long as that’s all it does, it has the legal right to prevent blocking of internet traffic.

But just in case Wheeler intends to ‘keep Title II on the table’ the idea that the FCC would have to reclassify Internet access service as a telecommunications service ‘ which the court accepted remained part of its rights under the Communications Act

In the meantime the FCC will also solicit public comment and look for opportunities to enhance Internet access competition. One way of doing that is to remove legal restrictions on the ability of cities and towns to offer broadband services to consumers in their communities. This caused outrage among telcos when municipalities looked like they might go into competition with ISPs.

However there are already two predictable dissenting opinions on the FCC web site from the two Republican Commissioners, one bemoaning the fact that the FCC was regulating the internet at all, from Commissioner O’Rielly, worrying that eventually it would lead to regulating internet services and the other from Commissioner Pai saying it was a bit like Groundhog day, saying that it would end in the same way.