Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 February 2014

Rovi washes its hands of one acquisition, spends $69 million on another

What do you do if you are a globally known brand name, but a major part of your business has gone sour, and your revenues, profits and share price have gone into a nosedive, but you have plenty of cash? Do you buy something?

Look at Rovi over the past year if you want to know. It’s share price is back at a healthy $25, barely changed from its peak in June, when it first hit trouble. It has chopped three businesses, none of them deemed central to what it is doing today, in the form of DivX and MainConcept, primarily a codec business both downloaded and embedded into devices, and its RoVi Entertainment Store, and although it still owns them it has taken a write down of the assets and now shows these businesses as ‘discontinued operations.’

The company has critically gone in a year from cash assets of $968 million to $641 million and also thought it should acquire another business (after the Sonic Solutions business that it acquired made such a mess of its books). It has however opted for Veveo, a Knowledge Graph based business, that can support Rovi’s own efforts in video recommendation.

We said that recommendation assets would suddenly be in short supply when TiVo bought into DigitalSmiths in January. We met Veveo at last year’s TV Connect, where it told us that its system can use either the phrasing or context of a question to bring you the right search outcome in its ‘Knowledge Graph,’ a term created by Google.

We have previously given the example of the Taj Mahal, which most people understand to be a building that almost, but not quite, qualifies to be one of the wonders of the world, in India. But a search engine will look at all documents with Taj in it and cross reference them with all documents with the word Mahal in. Sure, most of the time you get the right outcome, but sometimes it can go disastrously wrong.

The same thing happens when you search for football. Do you want rugby football, soccer or American football. Do you mean the ball or the ground where it is played. Did you want video of a game or the scandal involving one of the celebrities the game has thrown up? A Knowledge Graph will add all of these things and try to get you the right one, based on the context or exact wording of the question.

Veveo told us that it was part way to turning this semantic engine to the task of finding people programs that they definitively want to watch on TV.

In its last quarter’s figures Rovi seemed to be able to show that its continuing businesses were more or less stable and growing slightly, and making a contribution. It was the first time it has broken out where its revenues come from for some years, but with an impairment for the write down of DivX and Mainconcept assets, added to a further impairment charge for its Rovi Entertainment Store business, plus its usual quarterly write down of goodwill, the company closed out on a 172 million loss.

We have to go back to January 2011 when it acquired these assets when it looked like a series of disjointed, but related application areas had been acquired in the form of Sonic Solutions ‘ a white label online movie store, two codec businesses, one which recently boasted its 1 billionth download, and well entrenched with licenses in DVD player hardware, as well as the DVD pressing business of Sonic, all for $720 million.

BestBuy and Kmart both use different parts of the online movie business, so you would have thought that someone would have put in an offer for that, but as far as we can tell, it remains unsold, and looks to be a rapidly wasting asset. It looks like revenues for that store have gone into free fall, perhaps due to the polarization of video purchase, rental and sell through from a handful of extremely popular sources ‘ iTunes, Netflix, Amazon, Hulu Plus, and all the TV Everywhere services of US cable ‘ and that rental schemes that were designed originally almost a decade ago are just unworkable. This week Disney is launching yet another App version of its own movie store and there are many other free video apps for tablets from broadcasters.

Blockbuster is technically also an owner of an online movie store, but it sits on top of this same Sonic inherited platform, so perhaps Dish may emerge as a bidder.

The purchase of Sonic led Faultline to write a piece on Rovi describing it as a Russian doll, not only highlighting the merger of Gemstar, with its EPG patents and Macrovision (with its content protection) to create Rovi in the first place, but going back further to some of the companies they had acquired, such as Starsite Telecast, which made chips to harmonize video recorders that went into TVs back in the 90s. At Macrovision’s height Wall Street valued it at 7 times its revenues, which is how it came to acquire Gemstar in the first place.

Then it bought Sonic Solutions, and Sonic owned Roxio, a consumer brand, built around DVD copying software which had been effectively stopped from operating by the courts. And inside DivX was a rock solid DRM system, home built that today is obsoleted by the drift to Apps and content protection from the likes of Arxan and Inside Secure underpinning DRM, and of course Microsoft’s Playready and Intertrust’s Marlin.

Main Concept was one of the best known H.264 codecs, but with Google pushing VP9 as an HEVC compatible version of its codec and the whole world wanting to go straight to HEVC, and players like Qualcomm and Broadcom putting HEVC codecs on their chips, that revenue stream may too have been predictable in drying up. Back in November Rovi said it was determined and announced a suite of solutions using HEVC compression ‘ but clearly there is no queue of partners signing up for it.

Rovi’s DivX software is a codec technology that handles compression and decompression of a video, streaming that video, and playback on multiple devices. Rovi announced this fall it had reached the 1 billionth DivX software download.
The latest iteration, DivX 10, uses HEVC. The goal here was to get consumers to use HEVC for their personal media, but that doesn’t seem to have happened yet.

So as much as the new purchase of Veveo seems far more in keeping with what the new Rovi has come to be about – of late it has been pushing its TotalGuide, an online content engine for offering content discovery and vital search metadata, along with advertising techniques ‘ the merger will need managing ‘ and the Russian doll elements need to become a single whole, and that clearly did not happen with the previous acquisitions, which have gone bad in just two years.

The TotalGuide software from Rovi has already turned up on the Google TV set top box and it has recently signed a deal with Facebook for an integration of Rovi Video, a database of in-depth information about movies, TV shows, and celebrities, which gave Facebook developers a standardized base of entertainment data for creating meaningful consumer and second screen apps.

So this core part of what Rovi is doing clearly still has appeal, and despite there being some high level failures of its EPG patents ‘ with Ziggo in the Netherlands, TiVo in the US and Virgin Media in the UK ‘ there is still robust IPR revenue, including a recent renewed deal from Sony.

Now Rovi can offer the Veveo technology as part of these types of deals and that seems to be playing to its strength. Under the terms of the agreement, Rovi will pay $62 million in cash and up to $7 million more on performance milestones.

We have said in the past that Rovi needs to buy in something to strengthen its recommendation engine, as we also did with TiVo, which went straight out bought the US market leader DigitalSmiths. Other players such as ThinkAnalytics will be on many people’s lists, although it says it doesn’t want to be acquired, and Jinni and one or two smaller players will also be looked at, as there is a scrabble for in-house recommendation know how. Perhaps Cisco will step forward for one.

TV recommendations only really work when they are truly trusted, and we might expect that someone like Google will take a look at this type of software, before recharging the batteries on its Google TV product line, or augmenting Chromecast Apps.

Rovi certainly had its own search and recommendation engine and all the metadata you could shake a stick at, but no TV service had relied on it in the way that ThinkAnalytics or DigitalSmiths are frequently relied upon, so we had to suspect that it was fairly basic and it needs this shot in the arm. So far Veveo claims that its software has been adopted by leading device manufacturers and Tier-1 service providers, but few releases have been put out on design wins, although its web site says that it has customers inside Comcast, AT&T, DirecTV, Cablevision, Nokia Rogers and Verizon ‘ but there are few specifics except that in March 2012 the company came out of stealth on the back of a Verizon win as part of the FiOS system to provide new personalized search across a TV, phone and tablet. We suspect that in every case Veveo is used more as a front end for query than a fully featured recommendation engine. The company claims more than 80 patent applications filed and 50 patents granted.

‘The Veveo acquisition will deepen Rovi’s cloud-based search and recommendation capabilities, enhance our entertainment metadata and guide solutions with next-generation semantic capabilities, and help us grow our advertising and analytics offerings,’ said Tom Carson, President and CEO of Rovi. ‘Veveo has developed a great set of technologies and is a clear strategic fit for where we are going as a company,’ he said.