Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 February 2014

Aereo to launch in Austin despite legal setbacks

US streaming company Aereo appeared to be sweeping away the established US broadcasting order after fending off legal challenges from all directions but has now had its first major setback in the state of Utah. A district court judge there has ruled the Internet TV service, through which subscribers get local TV signals streamed to their computer or mobile devices, violates copyright law and must cease operation in Utah. And while he originally wanted the service switched off, he has now agreed to a 14 day stay of the switch off, until an appeal can be lodged and heard with the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals.

The same judge also ruled that a lawsuit currently outstanding against Aereo from local broadcasters KTVX Channel 4, KUCW Channel 30, KSTU Channel 13 and KUTV Channel 2, will be placed on hold pending the outcome of a broader case that will be argued before the US Supreme Court in April.

A decision on that case is not expected until around the end of the second quarter, leaving Aereo to some extent in limbo until that time. It means Aereo may have to shut down operations in the states covered by that court decision unless the appeal court says otherwise, including Utah, Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Wyoming and Oklahoma. However of those states Aereo has only launched in Utah and Colorado so far, out of 10 markets in total where it operates across the US.

Aereo’s success in seeing off other legal challenges so far was founded on its claim that it circumvents existing copyright law through a technicality. Based in New York where it launched first in February 2012, Aereo has deployed an array of antennas the size of small coins that pick up the over-the-air TV broadcasts. Each antenna is dedicated to a single customer and the TV signals are then sent from that to the subscriber’s computer or mobile device via the Internet. The service, which launched in Utah August 2013, costs either $8 or $12 per month, including a DVR function for recording in the network.

Aereo’s setback has not deterred it from going ahead with the next launch in Austin Texas. On March 3, as that area is not covered by that court ruling in Utah.