There is, in the agreement between Disney and Dish, widely reported this week, a feeling that the Dish Hopper, in its current form, was never going to survive the eventual legal actions brought by US broadcast networks NBC, Fox and CBS.
What it has survived since its May 2012 introduction of the device, are the injunctions that would have immediately closed down the device or rather forced dramatic changes to two specific features ‘ the ability to block record the four main US broadcast channels in their prime time period and the ability to pre-set the automatic skipping of commercials. The box is just a whole home DVR, but one that drew a wide splash of coverage at two successive CES’, mostly focused on these two aspects. A year later it launched a version with place shifting too, which has meant that these features can lead to laptops, tablets and phones enjoying advertising free prime time TV.
The respective judges and appeal judges who have dealt with these cases, insisted on the status quo being continued ‘ that is the product continuing to be delivered, rather than issuing a blanket injunction on the device or the specific features before it even got off the ground. The reason widely attributed to this is that it was ‘not obvious’ that the case would go the way of the broadcasters. Disney’s ABC was dragged into the dispute when Dish tried to get a declaratory judgment that its device was not breaching copyright laws.
But just because the outcome is not obvious and therefore it is not a trivial decision, does not mean that Dish was on the way to winning these disputes, only that its service was allowed to continue unabated for the time being, in the lead up to the cases coming to court. This case, like the Aereo case, is, or rather was, destined to go all the way to the supreme court, because it threatens a very old industry, though not necessarily one treasured by consumers.
Aereo does NOT pay these companies retransmission fees, and yet sends their signal across the internet, simply because it uses separate aerials for each signal and the consumer requests the service using the internet, which acts as an extension to these aerials. Dish on the other hand pays its full dues in terms of retransmission agreements, and as such it is part and parcel of the existing revenue base of these national US broadcast networks. This buys it more rights, and yet this ad skipping aspect is even more threatening than Aereo.
Afterall Aereo delivers the content, along with the advertising that’s on it, so it does not interfere with the process of consuming adverts.
But the Hopper product makes it easy to prevent the delivery of advertising, which in turn pays for the programming. If that does not reach the customer, then the core proposition of free to air TV could end up broken (in the US), and whether you want that to happen or not, a Judge is going to consider long and hard whether the existing laws were supposed to allow that to happen.
The US is one of the most densely rich video advertising markets in the world, by some way. If total global advertising will be around $490 billion this year, about $196 billion is TV advertising. The US in 2014 will be around $168 billion in total advertising and TV advertising is 40% of that, some $65 billion, and broadcast networks probably these days gets closer to 32% of that, so maybe $21 billion. It’s that money that keeps them buying programming.
As late as 1990 the main three broadcast networks ABC, CBS and NBC had a 71.6% share of TV advertising revenues, so this is now sliding badly whatever the merits of this or similar cases. But even though Fox has grown to join these three them there has been a major drift towards cable which is reflected these days by the Upfront negotiations and the amounts of money they each now draw. The upfronts are the annual season discount periods, when much of the advertising is pre-sold over a period of weeks. When we first began writing about it, Broadcasting took $9 billion and cable took $6 billion. This year broadcast collected just over $9 billion while pay TV got closer to $10 billion.
However you calculate it, if you block advertising, as the Hopper seems to allow and promote, and if enough customers go along with it, then these already bedraggled national broadcasters, far less influential that in their former years, may expire altogether ‘ and rather like a referee in the last few minutes of a tied game not wanting to dictate the outcome of a match by calling a foul, the courts were unlikely to let this ‘nail in the coffin,’ go unchallenged.
In a way everyone was looking for the kind of outcome that Disney and Dish reached this week, and it could form the blueprint for other deals that could be done with the more litigious Fox, CBS and NBC, once they weigh their options.
So what is the deal that Dish has done with Disney’s ABC? One key element preserves much of its ABC subsidiary’s advertising revenues, by Dish agreeing to switch off advertising skipping for three days after a program is aired. TV audience measurement juggernaut Nielsen has for many years agreed with broadcasters that any viewing of content that happens within 3 days of its being recorded, counts towards advertising impressions, and that is now built into the eco-system. There is a possibility that all this deal will do is force a change of consumer behavior to watching more and more DVR content on day four, but so far this rule that a very high percentage of viewings on DVR held content are within three days of its broadcast, has held for some years. So ABC kills that banana skin immediately.
Since subsequent viewings of the advertising after that point do not count towards the measurement of the audience, ABC loses zero advertising revenue. There are moves afoot to try to do advertising insertion after day 3 if content IS subsequently viewed, but this is in its infancy and requires new measurement methods.
In essence the Hopper is a 2Terabyte, 2,000 hour monster DVR, it uses MoCA to connect to up to 4 smaller client set tops called Joeys. And it allows one touch recording of all 3 prime time hours from each of the four major broadcast networks. The system has two tuners plus this ability to do these four at once, which suggests that it is using some kind of Full Band Capture technology plus two further conventional tuners.
It turns out that most DVR recordings, some 57%, are made up of these prime time programs, and the device records these channels in HD and keeps them for up to eight days after they have aired. This creates a constantly updating on-demand library of around 100 hours of primetime TV. This is not much different from the designs of other DVRs, except that usually the decisions of what is stored on them either comes directly from the consumer, or is extracted using recommendation rules from viewing habits, as is the case with TiVo. And yet no-one is suing TiVo because it does not offer ad skipping to go with it (although many year ago it played with this feature).
One thing that makes this the type of feature that would only take off in the US, is that outside of the US, most broadcast TV channels allow their full suite of programs to be available over the internet minus advertising. In the US only a fraction of the content is online, on their web sites and on systems like Hulu, which often require further payments.
But whether or not Dish thought it would win its legal action, it looks like it has extracted plenty of recompense for killing its ad skipping software for ABC.
The agreement also gives Dish streaming rights as well as on-demand access to a long list of Disney channels including ESPN and specialist new colleges sports networks. Most newspapers were talking about this deal as the very first which allows out of home consumption of content on tablets and smartphones. Our understanding is that a lot of Xfinitiy content, including over 30 linear channels, have been negotiated for this use by Comcast, so while it may not genuinely be a first, it may well be the first time Dish has been allowed to do this.
The only legal proceedings that are now cancelled, as far as we can see, with the signing of this deal, is the counter suit by Dish to ask for a declaratory judgment (which already failed), but the deal says that all legal actions between the two are now called off.
The lame quote that accompanied the statement, ‘This paves the way for more customer choice and control over the viewing experience,’ is of course hypocritical, in that there is less chance a customer can chose to skip the advertising, although it looks to us that any customer can still manually fast forward through the Disney adverts, we don’t think it is fast forward blocked, just not automatic.
Dish talked about the deal providing a structure for other advertising models as the market evolves, including dynamic ad insertion, advertising on mobile devices and extended advertising measurement periods. So this content will head for mobile devices with the ads in place, but since no revenue is accruing for these ads for Disney, perhaps adverts can be inserted later and the revenue shared. We understand that Dish is already working on this capability, including an auction system for advertisers to bid for this spare capacity.
Anne Sweeney, Co-Chairman, Disney Media Networks, and President, Disney/ABC Television Group, said, ‘We knew early on we had a responsibility with this deal to not only do what was best for our business, but to also position our industry for future growth. After months of hard work and out-of-the box thinking on both sides, led by Bob Iger and Charlie Ergen, this agreement, one of the most complex and comprehensive we’ve ever undertaken, achieves just that. Not only were innovative business solutions reached on complicated current issues, we also planned for the evolution of our industry.’
This conciliatory tone continued throughout the announcement, when this was really a deal about avoiding suing one another.
The deal allowed for a renewed carriage agreement for ABC’s eight owned local stations, including WABC-TV in New York City, KABC-TV in Los Angeles, WLS-TV in Chicago, WPVI-TV in Philadelphia, KGO-TV in San Francisco, WTVD-TV in Raleigh-Durham, KTRK-TV in Houston, and KFSN-TV in Fresno.
We’re not sure that the other broadcast networks will be all that keen to settle, but one of two of them may reach similar deals in a short space of time, now that the ice has been broken.