Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 March 2014

Bouygues sweetens SFR deal ‘ looks irresistible, good for everyone

Bouygues has turned out to be the more dynamic in the fight for French operator SFR, and appears to have beaten off cable operator Numericable, by this week adding a cool €1 billion, much of it in cash, to the chips already on the table.

That brings the Bouygues bid for SFR up to €11.3 billion in cash, up €800 million, as well as 43% of continued ownership in the combined entity. Bouygues says that the total valuation of SFR is now at €15.5 billion before synergies are taken into account and nearly €20 billion is you factor in all the synergies. Bouygues’ interest in the new entity following the merger would be 52% versus 49% in the previous offer.

The tone across most French news coverage is that this is a deal that must be done and that Numericable’s shareholders will be unable or unwilling to match this offer. There are potentially large obstacles to overcome in regulatory terms, but the balance in French mobile coverage was wildly upset by issuing a 4th license to Iliad’s Free in the first place, and now that it has taken 8 million customers in about 2 years, mostly from SFR and Bouygues. So if any regulator says that it wants to keep four mobile operators in France, then there will be even more of a bloodbath than Free created, and no investors will emerge willing to fund that, so we guess they will wave this through.

The question is what kind of future Numericable has in a three mobile player world in France and the answer is that unless one of the independents ‘ Iliad’s Free or Bouygues SFR ‘ opts to buy it, it has no future. Given the new trend to value fixed line assets higher and higher across Europe, we figure that Numericable will end up being acquired by Bouygues at some point, despite the personalities saying ‘over my dead body’ right now.

The cause of all this disruption is clearly the WiFi Offload that Free had captive among its 5 million WiFi homes, using Homespot software. This soaked up 70% of mobile data requests on the Free network, and kept its build out requirement for mobile at a low ebb and enabled it to go to market, discounting each mobile sign up to as low as €2 a month. It has paid a fortune to Orange in roaming fees and there was clearly going to be a major build out of its network at some stage, as it had a ‘requirement’ built into its license.

The offer made earlier this week by Bouygues that it would sell off its existing base station network and tower assets to Free if it is allowed to buy SFR, is merely Bouygues swapping third place in the market for second place, and in the process saving Free from that major build out cost ahead of it. Everyone is happy except Numericable.

Another fear has been set aside in that Vivendi, which had always wanted to wrest the minority interest that Vodafone had in SFR from the multinational, had immediately regretted the move and post the Free launch, had offered it back to Vodafone. This deal gets the French market back to a three operator market (something that is happening right the way across Europe) and at the same time ensures there are no easy targets for Vodafone so that it can get back into the market.

The other option of an SFR IPO would flop, because the threat of Free remains and the number of subscribers that SFR ends up on once the rate of adoption of Free slows down, is unknown ‘ investors do not like the unknown.

However an IPO after Bouygues has bought into it is perhaps a lot more secure, and in the process offers Vivendi an immediate opportunity to monetize its interest in SFR.

For anyone in the competition authorities it leads to three balanced players in mobile in France, and one of these, SFR, has less fixed lines and so may end up with a requirement to merge with Numericable in the future. Failing that there is a possibility that a cable operator, such as Liberty Global, buys back into Numericable and takes an MVNO and once again upsets the French mobile apple cart. Certainly Liberty is a really good financial investor, but it has owned Numericable once before and it did not enjoy the experience. However it is a more mature player these days, and so this might tempt Liberty, so it would be best for Bouygues to take that temptation off the table at some point.