Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 March 2014

Battle of the CTOs holds clues about just how cable is getting along

Cable Congress is not a normal event. It has personalities galore and some of them clash, it is presided over by professional broadcast presenters, some of whom also clash, who mostly provide smiles and easy questions for glittering marketing executives to bat out of the park. There are few worthwhile moments for technology lovers, but one special moment came when three CTOs (Chief Technology Officers) held a good natured ‘agreement’ session on stage on the first day.

It was presided over by Babita Sharma, a presenter for BBC World News in her day job, and was made to look like a piece of fun, but it was the best microcosm of the cable industry, both politically and technically, that you might wish for.

First question tossed up by Sharma was ‘Headed?’ a nice touch as that Headed versus Headless gateways distinction was only really introduced last year. The three answerers included the ever present Balan Nair, the man who’s job swung in the balance for four years over the creation of the Liberty Global Horizon set top, during which time he was grim to the point of bad temperedness, but can be seen at Cable Congress genial and smiling these days. You would expect that CTO of the largest cable company in Europe (if not the world) to be present.

The second contender was Paul Hendriks, CTO of Ziggo, the largest cable operator in the Netherlands, and everyone at the show (except us) would have you believe that Nair was soon to be his boss, as Liberty Global has successfully bid for Ziggo, and ONLY has the highly unlikely approval of the Netherlands competition Authority and the European Commission to be granted to make the deal come true.

In the past the third speaker would have been someone like a supplier, maybe NDS or TiVo, but in this instance it was Lorenz Glatz, CTO of Kabel Deutschland, days away from final ownership by Vodafone, and suddenly politically pushed to the fore where once they would perhaps be less interesting for the cable community operating as they do in what many in the Netherlands once regarded as a backwater of an installation, despite it being the single largest cable operator in Europe. Liberty Global is only larger because it is spread throughout so many more markets.

So did they think headed was best. It was 2 out of three in favor of headless, with Glatz demurring and suggesting that a little further down the road he would agree with the other two.

What Sharma had them play was a version of wheel of fortune, originally a US game, but in this version the type of question and the source of the question, Sharma, the audience, each other, and about the past, present, future, etc’

What’s your biggest ever mistake? Nair was the only one that answered this seriously and said that three years ago he took on 150 projects and only completed 15, as we remember it the Horizon project must have been one of the projects from several years earlier that was completed that year.

‘What about RDK?’ asked Sharma, ‘Oh yes,’ each CTO muttered, nodding their heads like Nodding dogs and agreeing aggressively.

But after a slow start, and made up jokey answers, you can rely on a techie to come back to his natural bent, and to talk technical. They are all in love with the cloud, and Nair boasted that ‘the second generation Horizon is due soon and all of the UI will be in the cloud,’ then he thought for a moment and added, ‘the 3rd version will have the UI and the middleware in the cloud, and the next would probably have VoD in the cloud before finally taking on linear.’ We presume that all of this was music to ActiveVideo’s ears, assuming that its technology is partly responsible for this plan.

We techies could have all closed up shop at that point and gone home ‘ singing that old tune ‘no more set tops any more,’ to the tune of the stranglers hits, ‘No more heroes any more.’ But it appears that it will take a while and anyway, not everyone agrees.

Glatz said it would all end up in the cloud, but was a bit more vague. ‘Our next generation is headed and with storage at the TV. Then there would be more cloud, but for us it is more like 2 generations of device before we get there,’ and his tone suggested that it was perhaps several more generations beyond that.

But they all agreed on smart TVs. No – they are not invited to the party and all three had an anecdote which began ‘We tried that once,’ and in each case it was a trial that was closed down, or where the partner (LG in at least one of the cases) changed the entire browser and failed to mention it to them, for its next generation TV. LG recently changed its entire OS on its smart TVs and has been in and out of the Smart TV Alliance, well mostly in, but sort of out, if you know what we mean.

Nair summed it up best when he said, ‘they make a TV and sell it and then they don’t care anymore, they want to build something else and go off and look for the next revenues, but we have to stick around and collect money every month. It’s bad enough that we have 10 legacy set tops, what would it be like if we have 30 legacy smart TVs as well.’ This was delivered to sage nodding from the other two, all on the same page there.

Homespots, one of our favorite topics came up and this year everyone knew what they were talking about. ‘We have 1 million Homespots,’ declared Nair, but not to be outdone, Glatz spoke up on behalf of the fairly backwards Kabel Deutschland, and said ‘We installed 100,000 last month.’ Straight over the audience’s head, except that no-one (except Faultline) has suggested that Kabel Deutschalnd would go down that route. Later we found out that the figure was closer to 300,000 which are so far installed, in a combination of Hotspots and Homespots, but all used for the same purpose, mobile offload, specifically for Kabel Deutschland customers and we suppose soon, for Vodafone mobile customers.

At this show there was a distinction made between telco and cable Homespots, Nair provided, ‘this is a one time ever log on, not like FON that makes you log on every time you use it,’ and the other distinction made by an unnamed cable guy was that when these Homespots use DOCSIS delivery, so they can leave the consumer with his entire 100 Mbps or whatever he has signed up for, and deliver the second Homespot SSID over extra DOCSIS channels, over and above the bandwidth that the consumer signed up for.

Can telcos do this? Mostly people think not, but if you think that the old FON style telco Homespot is immutable, you’re in for a surprise. Deutsche Telekom only signed for FON a few months ago, and once it has convinced enough of its customers to sign up for sharing their home broadband device, it could conceivable offer bandwidth over its contracted amount, but when your maximum is 100 Mbps, then there is not quite so much to play with, and cable clearly has a wider margin here to win the Homespot war given that DOCSIS modems can reach 30 0MBPS quite easily, if you can backhaul it.

Ziggo is actually ahead on Homespots and is already putting them to use alongside its Vodafone MVNO which has already launched in the Netherlands. If the two companies merge, you might expect this to be a single offering, but we already know, merged or not, that their mobile effort, with shared spectrum holdings and citing a combined 2 million homespots between them, this offering was always going to be a combined effort, even if the companies end up being prevented from full merger.

Nair had the final say on Homespots, ‘We will have 4 million this year.’

When we had asked earlier at the press conference how many cable homes had WiFi, we were greeted with incredulity, ‘Well all of them?’ But the answer had a question mark against it. There was a slow moment when no-one thought to confirm the number to the press conference panel, led by Cable Europe president Manuel Kohnstamm. We could see that the soon to be anointed CEO of Kabel Deutschland, Manuel Cubero, was adding up numbers in his head and when we caught up with him after the press conference, and he said that he knew the number of homes at his company that had WiFi, and clearly it wasn’t all of them, but he wasn’t going to tell us. We both acknowledged that what we meant to ask was how many of the installed based had WiFi that could be upgraded to a Homespot. Kohnstamm was more confident here, ‘all the devices that began shipping two years ago,’ and suggested that this was below 50%. Cubero would not commit himself. But we can see from the installations in the Netherlands and Belgium, where just over 50% of home gateway devices are being turned into Homespots, and these are advanced markets. It will be less elsewhere.

But when we looked on the Kabel Deutschland site for an announcement all we found was a reference to 300,000 Hotspots going up rapidly, some as Homespots, and a set of FAQs that took in how safe it was, how your data cap was separate and how your encryption keys were different, and a step further that if the second SSID was used for anything illegal, the home owner was not responsible.

There was some other subjects discussed by the CTOs, including the benefits of RFOG over GPON, and more lighthearted comments which suggested they were all pals. ‘We see a lot of each other,’ Nair said,’ being in cable you don’t compete with each other so it gives you a real sense of working on the same team.’

Well that may end up being true for Nair and Hendriks, but it definitely won’t be true for Glatz, not any time soon, he will be working out how to get the best out of a cable company for a mobile group, while the other two will be working out how to unseat a mobile group using cable assets. Not quite the same thing.

It was only at the Cable Congress last year that we first began being aware of Homespots, and here at Faultline we seem to have been the only service talking about them ever since, with Homespots featuring strongly in our recent Faultine Revisited and WiFi Revisited white papers, and it was partly the confidence we felt in WiFi offload that made us champion the common sense behind the Vodafone Kabel Deutschland merger.

Last year there was a quip from Liberty Global CEO Mike Fries about cable companies always calling him, wanting Liberty Global to acquire them and how perhaps in the future that would be mobile companies. This year there was a tweet which denied that Vodafone had yet made a bid for Liberty Global. There was also a discussion among the CEOs of European cable companies about convergence with mobile, where all the CEOs agreed (a sentiment echoed by their respective CTOs) that being just a mobile company is just nowhere, and that from here on in the holy grail is to become a converged operator, where the consumer experience is the same no matter what network you are on. Good luck with that.

There was one last important moment for us at Cable Congress, and that we straight after the CTO debate, when Rene Obermann, the erstwhile CEO of Deutsche Telekom, who has since left and gone to join Ziggo, only to arrive to find it is in the process of being bought by Liberty Global. When asked if he was staying after the merger, he said, ‘If and when it goes through, I will not be staying on.’ And then asked what he would do instead, he said once more ‘No I have not yet looked for another job, I will do that if and when the merger goes through.’ Somehow Sharma sensed that he was being coy, but could not fathom out why. ‘Why won’t he tell us where he is going?’ she may have complained, and if she had done that in our earshot we would have pointed out that he is going nowhere, if the merger with Liberty Global is blocked by the competition regulator, as it will almost certainly be, then Obermann will have a proper company to run.