When a security vendor buys the business of another it begs the question of what it was missing in the first place. Such was the case this week when France Telecom’s Viaccess-Orca announced its acquisition of the SecurePlayer from Discretix Technologies for an undisclosed fee.
SecurePlayer has been around a few years and has become established as one of the leading content protection systems incorporating DRM management for Android and iOS devices. We might have assumed Viaccess-Orca (VO) already had this licked to judge from its website page describing Connected Sentinel, its content protection package for IP-enabled content services. The blurb states, ‘The Player integrates seamlessly with any iOS or Android application and supports by default VO Connected Sentinel DRM, as well as Microsoft PlayReady DRM’.
PlayReady DRM is supported by virtually all such systems as it has been broadly approved by Hollywood studios, and this includes Discretix’ SecurePlayer. The difference lies in the depth and coverage of the Discretix technology. Both it and Connected Sentinel are aiming ultimately at the same problem, which is to make iOS and Android mobile services sufficiently secure to be trusted by premium rights holders as would ultimately be in the interest of all parties.
To date streaming of premium content to tablets has tended to be confined to low resolutions to ensure that illegal redistribution is not viable. Content redistribution from devices that may themselves have legitimate access to premium services is fast taking over from traditional piracy techniques, such as control word sharing, as the major source of content theft in the world of online IP distribution. It is therefore the major inhibitor of premium content distribution to IP connected devices, especially mobile ones.
Discretix entered this field early and has one of the most mature Android and iOS protection platforms that supports both software and hardware protection mechanisms on the device, incorporating most of the proven techniques. The software version is a downloadable, white label, application that has been adopted by some operators and device makers for video services.
MediaTek is one of the device makers to have incorporated Secure Player at a hardware level for its smartphones, following a deal struck in July 2013. Discretix provided support for a secure content path from MediaTek’s Secure OS embedded in ARM based SoCs. MediaTek incidentally has just followed up on this in February 2014 by announcing one of the first 4G LTE phones supporting the H.265 HEVC codec, aiming to deliver premium HD content via the Discretix security later this year.
Other partners of Discretix include Telecom Italia, Singtel, Vodafone, Digiturk, and D-Smart.
Our contacts tell us that Discretix has been doing fine (but we think it is likely under $20 million) and that although Secure Player is one of its key businesses, it suffers from being a small player and it has to be remembered that although it provides a key element in a security system, it’s not the whole system.
Viaccess-Orca is fond of talking about a holistic approach in security, a concept shared by many of the long term players (Irdeto comes to mind as one that uses that term too), and we may see a number of moves where established pay TV security plays will look to augment their position in mobile ‘ which this gives to Viaccess-Orca.
The Discretix strategy could be summed up as enabling a far higher level of content protection than software only protection, which means it is more likely to pass Hollywood robustness rules over premium content. The primary objective now is to prevent content in the clear from being tapped at the device for redistribution over the Internet, whether it is streamed online or downloaded for storage on the client. There are various content related components that need protecting, including the encrypted payload, content encryption keys and DRM licence files that specify rules for that particular device, for example restrictions over how many times it can be played. Clearly keys and the DRM licence file must be permanently stored in the device, whether content itself is streamed or stored, so they need protecting.
Then the content itself must be decrypted at some stage in order for it to be first decompressed and then played back, whether it is streamed or stored. If it is stored the content must be held in as secure a storage database as possible, which itself must be only accessible using keys that are difficult to obtain from outside the DRM-protected security system as a whole. This of course is a matter of degree, which is where Discretix claims leadership.
Essentially this DRM system must be resistant against both software and hardware attacks. Under the software category are all those attacks that entail use of code, usually mounted by hackers who already have root privileges in the system. Hardware attacks include those made by monitoring the device’s ports, but may also include probing inter-chip signals on the device circuit board, which crucially can be done externally by monitoring the electromagnetic radiation emitted, without tampering with the device itself.
These threats can be countered by software or hardware techniques, or a combination of both. The principle software ones, all supported by Discretix, are obfuscation, variability and renewability.
Obfuscation involves making the software’s logic tortuous and unnecessarily complex to make it as hard to reverse engineer as possible, which as cynics might say happens naturally in a lot of cases. But the software should still produce the desired result consistently, making it vulnerable to reverse engineering that simply aims to achieve repeatable output. Variability counters that by producing output that is at least somewhat unpredictable to an external observer, making it yet harder to reverse engineer. Renewability simply enables a particular decryption procedure in the device to be completely swapped in the event that it has been hacked, so that an attacker has to start all over again in order to continue to access clear content.
However no software protection mechanism can prevent hardware attacks aimed at reading cryptographic keys as they are transmitted within or between the device’s chips. Some such attacks may require access to the device, but that will often be available, given that content can be redistributed by legitimate users. However one of the principle methods of attack, differential power analysis (DPA), can be carried out by just detecting a machine’s electromagnetic emissions, which can be done from a distance, even sometimes outside the building. This can be carried out using oscilloscopes that can be purchased for less than $500 and unlike some forms of attack, leave no trace of their occurrence.
DPA can overcome even cardless security embedded in SoCs because it can divine clear content when it is inside the chip. This enables control words to be extracted through statistical analysis of multiple power consumption measurements.
However DPA can be countered by generating additional power signals to render the statistical analysis practically impossible. In effect DPA attacks are addressed by generating noise from which the required keys can only be extracted via the cryptographic core incorporated in the SoC. Cryptography Research is one of the few vendors with a product for countering DPA, as a result of which most chip makers now license it. Some content security vendors have done so as well, such as Verimatrix and also Discretix, which entered an agreement with Cryptography Research in July 2012 enabling it to develop products incorporating DPA countermeasures.
It looks then like Viaccess-Orca has made a good move acquiring the Discretix SecurePlayer business, even if it’s an admission it had failed to tick some of the important boxes for mobile device security itself. It now has most of the angles covered and key alliances in place.