While jaws dropped at the news of Facebook’s $19 billion purchase of WhatsApp, with many wondering how on earth Facebook hoped to see a return on its investment, the news that Facebook is buying a drone company has suddenly shed a whole lot of light on the long-term plan for Zuckerberg and co.
Founded in 2012, Titan Aerospace makes a series of solar powered autonomous planes that fly around six miles higher than airliners and are designed to stay airborne for up to five years ‘ although the current record for Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) endurance is held by QinetiQ’s Zephyr, which flew for only two weeks.
In a near earth orbit, the UAVs could offer the functionality of a satellite at a fraction of the cost. The company is reportedly manufacturing 11,000 of the Solara 60 UAVs for Facebook.
Titan has identified what it calls a sweet spot in the Earth’s atmosphere between 60,000 and 70,000 feet, which is above all weather systems and has an average wind speed of only 5 knots. This is the zone that the Solara 60 will operate in, cruising on its 164 foot wingspan.
The Solara 50 can carry a payload of 70 pounds, but its big brother can carry a 250 pound payload. The Solara 60 will use batteries charged by solar panels to fly at night, using a very lightweight construction and driven by a propeller, the UAV could provide communications coverage to an area with an 18 mile radius ‘ enough to cater for New York’s five boroughs.
Titan’s figures suggest that to photograph a geographic area, a satellite would cost $35 per square mile of land imaged and a Titan system would cost closer to $5 ‘ largely due to not having to launch a very expensive satellite into orbit.
The privately held New Mexico company is worth $60 million to Facebook, as the social network tries to push the Internet.org project and provide communication services to remote and unconnected areas of the world.
The Internet.org project is an initiative to provide internet access to the entire world population, with partners that include Facebook, Ericsson, MediaTek, Nokia, Opera, Qualcomm and Samsung. It wants to connect ‘the next five billion people.’
The group claims that only 2.7 billion people, around one third of the population, have internet access, with internet adoption only growing at 9% each year. Notably, Facebook has 1.2 billion users, nearly half of all the people online. Internet.org wants to focus on three key areas, which it identifies as making access more affordable, using data more efficiently and helping business drive access.
The group asserts that devices and service plans are too expensive. Lack of mobile networks to connect to and the lack of content in the local language are another major problem, as well as the lack of awareness of the benefits of the internet to these unconnected populations. More basic issues that must be resolved include the lack of electricity infrastructure in many locations.
Mobile internet users in the developing world account for upwards of 1.2 billion subscriptions ‘ a 3:1 outnumbering of fixed line subscribers in the region. The installation of fixed line infrastructure is prohibitively expensive, and a project that uses satellite connectivity for internet users without installing a mobile or fiber network would bring the developing world online much quicker than the slow creep of laid cable.
This is where Facebook’s interest lies, as it earns its living via internet traffic. More internet users means more potential revenue, so bringing the next five billion people online will add to the number of potential users ‘ especially as Facebook’s market growth is slowing down and approaching stagnation.
WhatsApp is very popular in the developing world as an alternative to SMS and MMS messaging. With 450 million monthly users, sending some 19 billion messages a day and 400 million photos, Zuckerberg identified it as the only network that rivals Facebook in terms of users and engagement.
If Facebook uses the app as a platform to promote the Facebook brand, then its long-term strategy will likely be to persuade the next five billion to use Facebook services as they come online. Tapping that market before it takes off with a purchase such as WhatsApp may ensure that Facebook is one of the first places that these new users turn to for leisure or entertainment.
WhatsApp and Facebook could be run on very weak data connections, such as those sent to users from a Titan UAV. Facebook bought Onavo to work on data compression technologies that will prove integral to a WhatsApp or Facebook Lite service. With Firefox’s new $25 smartphone, it’s evidently not the devices that are prohibitively expensive but the data.
So while Facebook is a member or the altruistic Internet.org team, its strategy can be seen in this recent acquisition. Getting its foot through the door before the competition is a benefit that $19 billion may well provide. Buying a potential lifetime user before they have an internet connection could be a very savvy investment for the company.
Google’s Project Loon is another scheme designed to provide internet connections to places not yet catered for, using balloons instead of UAVs.
Google launched the first balloon test program in June 2013, flying 30 helium-filled balloons over New Zealand that carried a 10kg (22 pound) payload. Google is now looking to expand the pilot program to establishing a ring of uninterrupted connectivity along the 40th southern parallel. 14 of the test balloons were lost at sea ‘ something Google doesn’t draw much attention to.
The balloons use solar panels to keep their equipment charged. Four hours of sunlight will power them for a day. The balloons act as a mesh network of satellites that exchange data between ground stations that will backhaul the balloon data to the core network. Users will need a Google-made antenna to connect to the balloons that is mounted on their home.
Floating in the stratosphere, Google says the balloons can change direction by ascending or descending into the different layers of wind that will guide the balloon to its designated position. Google thinks that a global network of balloons that navigate on the stratospheric winds is possible, floating between 18km (59,000 feet) and 27km (88,500 feet) above the users on the ground.
These altitudes will provide an environment that can reach -80˚C, 1% of the air pressure found at sea level and dramatically lower UV protection for the polyethylene balloon envelope. The balloons are expected to last for 100 days in the stratosphere before needing servicing and a replacement envelope.
This lifetime is much shorter than the Titan UAV, but Google says that this allows them to have the most up to date technology in the air ‘ a situation that might ruin Facebook’s strategy of a 5 year lifecycle, although admittedly not much of a problem for conventional satellites. 100 days is also the time it will take for 3 laps of the Earth.
Measuring 15 meters wide by 12 meters tall (49 x 39 feet), the balloon is able to release its gas in a controlled descent when it reaches the end of its service. There’s also a back up parachute. Google claims to be able to land them in specific recycling locations, where they can be reprocessed and launched again.
The solar panels will generate 100W of electricity for the electronics to use. The communications equipment is suspended below the balloon in a box, and can provide coverage for an area around 40km (24 miles) in diameter ‘ a smaller area than Facebook’s reported UAV. The speeds Google claims are equivalent to 3G.
The polarized patch antenna will rotate with the balloon, so Google has tried to counter the cross-polarization issue with a dual-polarized antenna for both the balloons and the ground-units. The dual antenna also provides a boost in throughput capacity.
Google’s Project Loon is much cheaper per unit, measured in hundreds not millions of dollars but both projects are far from finished products and both will likely face political complications associated with setting up a new network of stratospheric satellites above sovereign territory ‘ even though the systems are very similar to current satellite operations, vocal opponents repeatedly latch on to the drone buzzword and its connotations when criticizing Facebook’s latest acquisition.
Facebook has also come in for criticism in using Internet.org as an altruistic veil for its commercial interests. The same criticism has not been leveled at Google, as Project Loon is just something of an extension to its Google Fiber internet offering.
There are those who criticize Google for choosing to fill its balloons with helium, a finite resource that is getting increasingly scarce as it escapes gravity into space. A global network would require thousands of balloons and the impact on the world’s helium reserves could be harmful and uneconomical. Hydrogen could be a suitable alternative, but autonomous mini-Hindenburgs may be a hard sell for some.
Both initiatives would hopefully bring the internet to those users who need an affordable connection. Both companies want to benefit from the revenues that new internet users will generate, although hoping for page views and click-through kick-backs is not as philanthropic a goal as Google and Facebook are initially presenting.