Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 March 2014

All singing and dancing TV Connect live with OTT, mobile, dongles, RDK

TV Connect in London is one of those shows where people just love to announce things, and we came away from it this week with as much to think about as when we go to larger shows like CES, IBC or NAB. The changes in the video industry were all reflected there and we are beyond the point where one common theme pulls all of the announcements together, although there were a considerable number 4K based demos and announcements.

If we had to pick out themes, we might go for the continued rise of pure OTT services, or companies helping mobile to cope with video, or who will win out in an all IP world. RDK and other ways of making life easier and a bit cheaper was also something of another trend, as were the emergence of new Chromecast alternatives, oh and did we mention, 4K?

Some OTT takes from the show were Edgeware supporting Com Hem’s IP delivered VoD with its CDN or rather VDN flash memory based IP delivery, using its Unified server, and plugging it into the Seachange International Adrenalin back office suite. Another was seeing how the Octoshape software brought 1080p content faultlessly across the internet using cheap cloud servers rather than a dedicated CDN to an AirTies hybrid set top. One of the best OTT displays was kept to our last meeting, not that it has the best visual clarity by any judgement, but the way in which the Israeli specialist Vidmind has created a business out of open source components and cloud servers, written in Ruby (on Rails) and sold into its second account at TVZor in Russia ‘ proof that pure OTT services are emerging albeit somewhat slowly.

It’s funny how the entire pay TV community, in fear that a million Netflix’ would emerge overnight, all took to OTT delivery first, starting around 5 years ago. After all they already had some content rights, usually the wrong ones, and we have all spent 5 years writing about the same companies in OTT as we did in previous technology visions, often with the same suppliers. But this show that the industry is starting to reach a point where a new company can download an X264 encoder and the Apache Mahout recommendation system and the Hadoop MapReduce big data engine and create a viable OTT service with a single programming whizz kid and a little hard work. This is what Vidmind has done and thrown in its own UI and suddenly new companies are springing up that have never been in the TV business, crashing the cost of entry into pay TV.

But a story that has been bubbling under in OTT delivery is Tvinci, who when we first met, we felt that since it had no pure intellectual property it was a less interesting company. But sometimes it is good execution that wins a market, not originality and Tvinci now has some prestigious clients in Kabel Kiosk, the Eutelsat OTT subsidiary in Germany which reaches some 3.5 million homes there, some 10% of the market. Tvinci is another Israeli company that has been showing product these last three years or so at these shows, winning the odd award and adding to the number of integrations it has with DRMs and encoders and building up media customers in Singapore, the Philippines and Latin America. One of its latest wins came courtesy of Ericsson at Singapore’s Mediacorp, one of the larger broadcasters there. Ericsson reportedly spent 18 months on the project and made insufficient headway, was bundled into touch and Tvinci put a system together for a deadline in 3 months, to launch Toggle, its new multiscreen system. Part of the issue here is thinking about OTT from scratch, rather than with a legacy of products to support, which can sometimes make the vision clearer.

To be fair, Tvinci is a hybrid product, so perhaps comes at this problem more from the direction of broadcasters rather than a pay TV operator or a brand new entrant. But it may also be the pricing, a set-up fee and then pay for each additional registered viewer ‘ not Ericsson’s style. The system offers catch up, pay per view, freemium delivery, subscriber payments and live linear TV. Funnily enough the Vidmind system featured the type of payment methods that Russian’s favour, who hate to be tied down to a monthly payment, and allows for eCommerce on the TV screen, but mostly through pay as you go payments.

Netgem, the set top maker for SFR that has tried to completely change its business model over the past four years was also thinking OTT, and has just signed up Virgin Mobile in France, a totally separate company from the UK’s Virgin Media.

It’s tiny box offers HTML 5.0 and HbbTV delivered alongside one another, and this is its third generation of OTT device. It hopes to pick up business in the highly competitive French market, partly using its Videofutur content subsidiary, and the fact that some of the 4 telco broadband players (Orange, Bouygues, Free and SFR) are starting finally to offer broadband without the TV offering, in a double play with VoIP, which opens up the possibility there of offering paid OTT at last. Netflix will be pleased to hear this too of course. The company sees a big gap in the €10 to €20 market for a TV service, above Free to Air and below the current pay TV offerings of CanalSat and Numericable. Netgem says it will still maintain its OTT offerings around the world with Telstra in Australia, at Viasat and Elisa in the Nordics and Telecable in Mexico, all offering hybrid OTT delivery. At the show it was showing off its latest box design (they all call them boxes in France) the Netbox 360 (not to be confused with the Microsoft Xbox 360) and adding start over options for any broadcast program, a bit like US cable introduced a few years back.

French IPTV software goup SoftAtHome was one of the handful of companies that were pushing a new HDMI stick, one that it says is better than Chromecast, because it can work with Android, Airplay, Miracast and with encrypted premium content. We have to say that we really like this idea the more we try it on, and SoftAtHome will have some takers here. In the past it has offered set tops that are not based on Android, but which can run Android Apps, so that their operator customers are not enslaved to the Google vision, and we also see that as very pro-operator.

So instead of using a Marvel chip, like most of the anticipated Chromecast copycats, this has to use a Broadcom set top chip (the 7225), that’s because this has all of the hardware roots of trust for each of the major DRMs ‘ so that’s NDS, Nagra, Verimatrix, Playready Irdeto, and Viaccess Orca. It still uses a version of Dial developed for Broadcom chips (Dial is the discovery and launch protocol designed by Netflix, YouTube and Sony) made famous in Chromecast, but it does this not on an ARM based chip. SoftAtHome calls this simply CAST, and it can take streams from an RTSP source, from any Adaptive streaming service or even support progressive download.

It seems a no brainer for its captive operators to use this, and hand them out like sweets, but no price can be talked about since SoftAtHome only offers these ideas to its operator base and they set pricing. We would have through that a $50 range was likely.

Cast uses SoftAtHome’s SOP software platform and the Broadcom chip is HEVC enabled and designed with help from Siligence, another French company put together by refugees from Philips, Pace, Thomson and Alcatel. Of course this will not emerge with tons of applications as Chromecast will, so that ability to support Android apps will likely also come in handy down the road.

There were a number of other stands either promising or showing an un-priced, un-launched dongle, but CAST was really the most impressive.

Chromecast this week was finally launched in 11 new markets including Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Spain, Sweden and the UK, so mostly Europe and has added retailers Amazon, Currys PC World, Elkj’p, FNAC, Saturn and Media Markt and since it issued a new SDK last month, it says it has had 3,000 sign ups.

Some of these apps were launched at the show, one from Israeli TV middleware firm Comigo, but Google said that there would be Chromecast versions of the BBC iPlayer, France TV Pluzz and SFR TV and Canalplay coming soon, along with one from Maxdome in Germany. So it looks like most of SoftAtHome’s clients are already on this bandwagon, one way or another.

But we really like the idea of the TV not really being in the TV anymore and perhaps being inside a portable device that is then thrown to the TV. For some reason we always end up, when we talk to Arris, in a philosophical debate about the future of set tops, and this week was no different. We immediately abandoned the press releases about Arris getting a piece of Liberty Global in Germany at Unity Media, where it has landed yet another CCAP installation, through what it calls its Converged Edge Router, which makes the entire cable IP based, and delivers TV and broadband over the same interchangeable channels, stopping only to note that Cornel Ciocirlan, the Europe CTO says that Arris will have shipped 3 million of these by the end of this quarter.

So that acknowledged, including what it means for the IP-ization of cable, we went onto the fate of the set top. Ciocirlan shrugs and says the user experience is key, and that while the set top is increasingly becoming a software based set of functions, which might be implemented anywhere, partly in the cloud, he thinks that for the next few generations the big issue is latency. And that means that rendering is best done on the device, not in the cloud. Which perhaps puts only the UI into the cloud. Certainly nPVR, in various guises due to different legal environments throughout Europe, is a shift to cloud delivery.

And whatever form factor the set top takes, be it Chromecast HDMI dongle shaped or built into a home gateway, or built into a rather bulky electrical plug, it would still be under the operator’s control. It will still suck between half an amp to a full 1 amp of power out of said plug. So does that mean an ARM chip then? Probably says Ciocirlan, eventually. Does that mean Android? Probably not says Ciocirlan, more likely Linux. So once again that best of both worlds capability which we mentioned from SoftAtHome and others, to run Android Apps, on Linux, could be a feature.

‘We use the mantra, MY content, wherever I am’ which pushes the company into competition with a whole host of companies and shoves them down the CDN route, as much as anything else. ‘We have built CDNs and we have partnered for them,’ says Ciocirlan, confirming this. It’s obvious really, if you are a set top and some of that function is moving to the cloud, then you have to focus on cloud delivery as much as the CPE.

‘We have been held captive to the network equivalent of Moores law for a long time, we need to add 100% more bandwidth to the devices we offer every 18 months,’ said Ciocirlan, ‘And we have to do that for the same capex.’ In effect we are back at the other end of the network, the CMTS or now the CCAP device. But if that’s what goes in at one end, the devices on the other end have to cope with it. ‘Moores law says that we have to bring 1GHz out of a single port,’ he said, and that’s more or less what the Arris range now offers.

But now back to the set top. ‘And we have to offer the managed part of the network using multicast, and the unmanaged part using ABR.’ Mobile operators hate ABR and want to kill it, and it seems inefficient, and we say so. ‘ABR is too well ensconced now for it to be replaced,’ he says. We take a diversion down the path of what this means for mobile video and the video optimization business, and he shrugs, acknowledging it is a problem and it has to be solved, but that this route seems to work.

Arris also launched a Broadcom based set top using the 7252 and offering 4K and using RDK at the show. In fact everyone mentioned a Broadcom 4K product and nearly everyone was showing them for the first time and almost all of them thought they were first, but it seems to us a dead heat for many of the usual suspects.

But Ciocirlan reminded us that technology moves a lot slower than we suspect. Comcast has already awarded contracts for its new XG5 headless gateway, but none of that is public and none of that is shipping. Instead it is really only ramping the prior generation XG1 up to speed, with first shipments two quarters ago, with shipments mixed between Arris and Pace and consumers focused heavily on this device. He is of the opinion that there will be existing headed set tops still in the network in 7 or 8 years, even if Comcast and others continue to feel compelled by the headless variety on the near horizon.

Verimatrix (see separate story) was another case in point. If networks are increasingly part managed and part unmanaged IP, then you need a single DRM that will deal with both, at the same time on the same equipment, but this also points to one strikingly obvious statistic, which VP marketing Steve Christian intimated with a smile, ‘that the legacy conditional access companies are all but irrelevant now, as cable goes CCAP.’

Faultline listed all the changes that Cable needs to go through to shift to full IP interworking in the Summer and we will shortly issue that as a white paper, but the implications do reach far and wide. NDS had perhaps $1 billion in revenues when it was acquired by Cisco, and probably 55% was in conditional access and that will be supported for some time to come, and given that not much of it is associated with cable or IPTV, but mostly with DTH broadcast, then it may well continue longer than the business of say Motorola Home inside Arris, and other players such as the Scientific Atlanta arm of Cisco, which it acquired some 9 years prior to NDS. So Cisco also has a need to either develop or acquire an IP DRM capability, as does Arris perhaps, in order to replace that revenue, but also the market control it gave them both.

One player we met at the show, that we have long thought was safely, if somewhat boringly, ensconced in fixed line IPTV networks has been chasing the solution to the OTT video problem at mobile operators and that’s Ineoquest. It came to light along with a handful of other specialists in keeping tracking of problems in a pure telco IP networks, often IPTV

A very enthusiastic Stuart Newton, VP corporate strategy, who used to run EMEA back when we last met him in 2007, told us that the company had gone from the single dimension of operational analytics, to embrace both that and behavioural analytics using what he called ‘Big Data.’ The truth is that this has been a simple journey from the middle out to the edge of the network, and as you get further and further out towards the edge, you can find out more and more about individual sessions, even out on the cellular network.

Back in 2007 he told us, ‘If you have a multicasting network you have no way of knowing that a packet hasn’t arrived or has been damaged unless you monitor the network at every stage,’ and that, more or less was what its operational analytics solution was all about.

That solution was all about specialized deep packet inspection boxes of different sizes, using parallelism within FPGA chips, so that it could manage speeds up to 10 Gbps and as slow as individual DSL line speeds. The idea back then was to find damaged MPEG data and isolate at which stage in the network it was damaged.

But on the back of Intel’s incursion into base station design, with its Smart Cell technology, and a few experiments in virtualizing its own probes into software running on an multipurpose Intel processor right out at the edge, the company is able to sneak a peek at the condition of Adaptive Bit Rate content going over the top to a mobile device.

‘We did an experiment with BT and a standard HP blade and virtualized our probes across a Verivue CDN cache.’ Suddenly the company is no longer selling network tools to the network manager, but meeting a variety of CXOs and talking about assuring QoE to the mobile user, as well as clawing back bandwidth. Its next range of products are monitoring video as it plays out of a CDN Cache, and its next product will sit on a phone, checking that it all arrived. It plans to take this further to advertising delivery on a phone as well. ‘It’s a lot better for an operator to take his own look at CDN video quality than asking a CDN provider to report back on video quality as it leaves the CDN. The CDN provider is not motivated to report faults,’ pointed out Newton.

Like many video optimization companies, Newton seems to think seeing the session leave the cache is enough. If phone OTT video stalls or calls for a different stream, it is recorded there, but he says IneoQuest will still go the extra mile to offer software on the handset too.

There is a lot of leverage when you have 500 fixed line network owners using your tools as IneoQuest has, and some of them want to take it the last mile, through the air to handsets, especially during a period when a Tsunami of OTT video is expected to deluge mobile networks over the next five years. And where a fixed line operator has relied on a provider for operational network support, the temptation to extend that to mobile must be compelling.

Another player that talked up this video monitoring and optimization came in the surprising form of Opera software, itself in this same segment, along with lots of point providers like Allot Communications, Saguna and Quickfire Networks.

Opera entered it by buying Skyfire almost precisely a year ago and its tactic is to take any unencrypted video and re-encode it, said Frode Hernes, VP products, TV and connected devices. ‘Did you know that Snapchat doesn’t use ABR encoding for its video and suddenly it’s really popular on phones. Our Skyfire products look for video that is not in ABR format and re-compresses it. It also looks into the headers of ABR packets and tricks the client into requesting only SD video when the ABR service might want to push HD content on the cellular network.’

Opera has now acquired a group of online advertising networks and makes money from a global ad sales force, is dominant in browsers for the consumer electronics industry, with pretty much a full house of design wins, with the exception of LG and Samsung who support their own Webkit based browsers on TV, although Opera supports the Samsung Blu-ray players and its TV business shipped 27 million units in 2013. It’s Opera mini browsers sits on 350 million handsets, and this kicked off in 2006, which is when it began the process of working out how to compress HTML pages.

Most spin about Opera’s chopping and changing its code base, first dropping its own, to free up 130 internal engineers, and ostensibly working towards Webkit, and then joining the Google fork to Blink, suggested that Opera was now at a disadvantage and no longer controlled its own destiny.

‘It was our engineers who drove that decision,’ said Hernes, ‘they argued that we were employing 130 people just to offer the same product and wanted to work on innovation.’ So the engineers were bored. ‘Our product was better but people like Banks used proprietary extensions in IE, so we were better but not used.’

Now as Blink takes shape with a huge code clean up led by Google, everyone is wary that Google will call all the shots on what happens if you want to use a Chromium browser, based on Blink. Pretty soon Samsung and LG are going to be in that position regarding Blink and their TV sets. ‘Customers know that if Google applies any unwanted pressure they may need to fork their code base again. That’s why they want to use the Opera version and why we need to be in Blink,’ Hernes explained. And that’s a great selling point, as a counterpoint to Google all en-compassing power.

And that brings us onto RDK, which Hernes points out, ‘still uses the webkit browser, so we are going to have to port Link onto RDK,’ and anyway Comcast doesn’t even use a browser on its Xfinity range, but native code. ‘So while companies like Pace hold out against the Opera browser on its set tops, companies such as Cisco, Arris, Sagem, AirTies and Humax all put Opera on at least some of their set tops. And if operators want to continue to keep control of their operations from companies like Google, more and more will turn to Opera,’ which pretty sums up the pivotal role that Opera continues to find itself in, in TV.

Opera now also has its own App Store and was launching an instantaneous app system which auto-generates video apps in the store, using skeleton Javascript routines, which it launched at the show, which it called TV Snap (see separate piece).

The recommendation theme that we have pushed for the past two years at Faultline as the critical technology to replace EPG, also had a few adherents on show. Viaccess-Orca was there but not showing anything particularly new, as was the recently acquired Veveo, bought for $69 million last month by Rovi.

Veveo is now being pronounced ‘Viveo’ these days and was demonstrated by Rovi integrated into a fully-fledged app on a tablet. The demonstration has its awkward moments like when you have to raise the tablet to your lips in order for it not to get a voice command wrong, but some of the features show that the arms race in TV recommendation and search is not over.

If you say City to it and you are a football supporter, and it knows you like Norwich City, then ‘How is City doing,’ might bring up the soccer results. If you ask it about the Sox, it brings you both White Sox in Chicago and the Red Sox Boston, unless it knows you, in which case it brings up the one you support.

The link to Facebook is not na’ve, instead of finding you things that your friends have watched, it finds bands on TV that you have ‘liked’ through Facebook, even on TV programs that you don’t normally watch. That feature is neat. We have to look at the guests on the Graham Norton show before we ever watch it, because Norton is not the draw, the guests are (to us).

It does the same in Twitter and Netflix, and you can put these rankings where you find them useful. It focuses on time of data, day of week, like many other recommendation services and there is no feigning, as there was at TiVo, when we met them last week, that its own recommendation was perfectly good, and it really bought the company (in TiVo’s case DigitalSmiths) for its customer base. At Rovi it knows that it used to be highly ranked in content discovery and that now it has gone back to its roots, in that technology by buying a serious piece of technology. It claims that Veveo has 100 billion nodes of information stored out in the cloud, making these connections and learning about its audience all the time.

The predictive search is even nicer, not that many people like search on a TV yet. It is predictive not auto-fill, it recommends answers in the right order, as it goes.
Instead of How I met Your Mother, it responds to the initials HIMYM and has the right answer after a few keystrokes. Veveo was made up of 60 people, 45 of which were engineers, and what they showed really was a work in progress on a corporate integration. ThinkAnalytics was also at the same show where I first saw it almost ten years ago, and it is claiming one of its biggest ever wins in recommendation. BSkyB in the UK has been a customer for a long time, and we always suspected that it was going to roll out the platform beyond Sky Go and Sky+, where it is today. It is now already on the new Now TV OTT service and will shortly go onto live HD TV in the Summer, so while it’s not a new customer, it is reaching further into the core service and the UI, which will mean it serves far more recommendations.