It was an uncomfortable feeling when we heard this week that Vivendi had gone and preferred the offer for its SFR mobile unit from Vivendi, because only a few days earlier we had been saying that we thought the bid on the table from Bouygues was best for all concerned.
The reason it was uncomfortable is that while we felt it was best in terms of total enterprise value and the French telecommunications environment as a whole and the economy as a whole, we should have put in a proviso, that if past dislikes with the rival Bouygues group and the desire to simply have as much cash and as little continuing involvement in the business, was the motive, then it could still go the other way. We didn’t say that because we thought it was unlikely ‘ but in the event we think it is the last issue, of getting as much cash now, and having as little to do with it as possible, that won the day.
That way the telecommunications market, which probably has more surprises in store for it in hyper competitive France, will not shake the Vivendi share price, as it will only hold 32% in the SFR business and cash of €11.75 billion.
The Bouygues bid offered €11.3 billion in cash, and 43% of continued ownership in the combined entity. But it also neatly took one of the mobile operators out of the market in that Bouygues had promised to sell its smaller existing mobile network to Free, cutting the antagonists to 3, from 4.
But Vivendi’s Supervisory Board has decided to enter exclusive negotiations with Numericable shareholder Altice for a period of three weeks. It gets far more fixed lines into the business in this way, and puts it in a great position for further small cell backhaul and WiFi Offload opportunities.
Exclusive negotiations allow each side to open up their respective books and ask more detailed questions, and is usually followed by a deal completion. There are absolutely NO regulator issues in this deal, and last week we addressed the regulator concerns in the other deal, arguing that France has had a really tough time for all mobile operators since the fourth license was issued, and that going back to three ought to be considered by the regulator.
At the end of the three weeks, the Supervisory Board will meet again to examine the next steps and to decide if it has enough of a deal that it can shut down the other negotiations.