Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 March 2014

EU investigates Liberty Global merger, as it plans Europe wide MVNO

The European Union’s antitrust authority has decided to review Liberty Global’s planned $9.3 billion acquisition of Dutch cable operator Ziggo, which by giving the operator access to 90% of the country’s households, exceeds a threshold for such action. The EU has until April 23 to decide finally whether to approve it or launch a more detailed investigation and there have been suggestions it will delegate the process to the national Dutch regulator, which has requested this on the grounds that only domestic interests are at stake.

Certainly taking the broader competitive perspective there seems no reason for blocking the deal at a European level. After all the Virgin Media acquisition in the UK represented a larger jump in Europe wide subscribers for Liberty Global. In the past cable companies have pushed the idea that even if they all merge in one country, they are not reducing competition, because they have no footprint cross-over. But once a cluster of them represent the majority of a single country’s pay TV, then they begin to have dangerous purchasing dominance in content.

The EU decision will therefore be watched closely for evidence of whether there is going to be a change of policy in the light of accelerating convergence across Europe in the overall communications sector. The EU may be concerned over the pace or extent of this consolidation, which if it goes too far or too quickly could result in power being concentrated among too few providers. Alongside Liberty Global the only real contenders to become major pan European converged communication powers are Vodafone and possibly Deutsche Telekom along with France Telecom Orange. Telefonica’s prospects are diminishing as a result of lackluster performance both domestically and in its overseas markets, having failed to capitalize fully on Latin America’s rapid growth in broadband and pay TV over the last five years.

While Liberty Global’s advance in fixed broadband may be stalled slightly by the EU review, its plans on the mobile front are falling into place. Just as Vodafone had to get into TV and fixed broadband, Liberty Global needed a mobile offering to compete fully on Europe’s converged communication stage and rather than acquire spectrum and infrastructure itself has decided to take the faster and less costly path of becoming a MVNO (Mobile Virtual Network Operator).

Liberty Global is already well established as an MVNO in some markets, such as the UK where its subsidiary Virgin Media now has 3 million customers for its Virgin Mobile service, most of them also subscribing to broadband and TV. This is through an exclusive partnership with mobile operator EE as cellular infrastructure provider, dating back to 1999, now extended to include 4G.

Liberty Global now plans to replicate this arrangement with other mobile operators across other European markets, starting with Austria, Belgium and Switzerland, but with the difference now that it is building a Europe-wide back end platform to support the operation and integrate with its existing back-office and billing system. By having a common backend the MVNO service will be highly competitive against Vodafone, according to Senior Vice President Manuel Kohnstamm, indicating that it will be pitched strongly as a standalone service and not just as part of multiplay packages.

We’re not really buying that right now. We acknowledge that Liberty Global and Vodafone are two rival networks across Europe, but that they will both co-operate and interoperate, to shut out rivals. In the Netherlands, given that the two cable companies there compete head on with KPN, the only partner is Vodafone and Ziggo already works with them in an MVNO.

In Germany the cable companies align against Deutsche Telekom and will no doubt share small cell backhaul with Vodafone, and WiFi with each other, against T-Mobile. The only other partner there in is EPlus but Vodafone looks best. So it is likely that these two will try to carve up Europe between them, rather than go to town on one another.