Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 March 2014

Vodafone has plenty of money in the kitty after Ono deal

Raising a pile of cash from a massive sell off can take a company in one of two directions, either financing consolidation and expansion, or being acquired itself. Vodafone became one of the biggest ever examples of this phenomenon after selling its stake in Verizon Wireless for $130 billion, arming itself with oodles of cash but also in the process halving its market capitalization to around $100 billion. This brought it within the compass of a few big Telcos with expansionist plans, notably AT&T capitalized at $170 billion, although it had slipped from $200 billion in mid-2013. Japan’s Softbank, the country’s third biggest mobile operator as well as being a fixed line ISP, was also cited as a candidate, having embarked on serious international expansion with the acquisition of 80% of Sprint for around $21 billion, approved mid-2013.

But it would require substantial help from outside investors to acquire a company as large as Vodafone and it does not look like that will be forthcoming, even given Japan’s recent return to slow growth over the last two years. The Japanese government recently earmarked about $3 billion to help fund Softbank’s ongoing international expansion, backed by private finance houses, but it will have to be a lot more to make a bid for Vodafone feasible in a combined cash/share offer.

No one else seems in the running at present, with Verizon itself concentrating more on the enterprise market with its relatively modest international expansion plans, focusing more on increasingly intense domestic competition in the wake of Comcast’s $45 billion acquisition of Time Warner Cable (if that ever happens).

This leaves AT&T as the only realistic contender given the noises it has been making lately about European expansion, although the window of opportunity in this case is closing fast. Vodafone’s $10 acquisition of Ono makes the company that much harder to swallow, so we can largely forget the idea of Vodafone being acquired and instead plot its course to expand across Europe as a multiplay operator, having decided to concentrate its resources at that level for now.

Firstly it is worth considering that the $10 billion paid for Ono does represent value for money, unlike some analysts who were guilty of assuming that just because Vodafone had a $50 billion pot of money left after paying about $80 billion of the Verizon windfall back to shareholders, it would be taken for a ride. The analogy was made with wealthy football clubs held to ransom when bidding for players, since there is too much money chasing a limited pot of talent.

In fact the Ono price was just under 10.5 times its earnings before the usual deductions of interest, tax depreciation and amortization under the collective acronym of ebitda. This is less than the 11.3 ratio for Ziggo agreed by Liberty Global or the 12.4 Vodafone itself paid for Kabel Deutschland recently. Of course these differences reflect a range of factors such as prospects for growth in a given market, but then Vodafone can point out that when its proposed $4 billion cost savings within Ono are taken into account, ebitda would be only 7.5. Vodafone was acutely aware of the risk of overpaying given that Ono had been contemplating an IPO, partly with a view to maximizing the price. We do not think it achieved this, and as Spain’s largest MSO with around 1.4 million broadband subscribers, Ono strengthens Vodafone’s position there, dovetailing with its FTTH roll out programme through its joint $1.3 billion program with Orange in Spain to reach 6 million homes by 2017.

Vodafone became the force it is purely as a mobile operator, which went well while that sector was enjoying seemingly exponential and everlasting growth over a 20 year period, but hit the buffers as it became clear that future converged media and communications, call it quad play, would actually revolve around broadband.

We now hear analysts erroneously claiming this idea that the Internet is becoming mobile is bogus, because nearly all data will still end up on the fixed broadband infrastructure. But an increasing amount will go over the air at the access level, with Wi-Fi taking the bulk, which is why offload and HetNets have become such hot areas. For Vodafone this has meant a headlong rush into fixed line assets, selling its stake in Verizon Wireless and now aiming to establish itself as one of Europe’s big converged players, which it will surely succeed in doing.

The question will be who will line up beside Vodafone after the inevitable consolidations and mergers over the next two years. Content strategy has a role to play here, with Vodafone setting its stall out like Liberty Global as an aggregator ready to deal with whichever broadcasters and rights holders are willing to provide the premium material in each given market.

The European Union’s moves to end individual country negotiations for rights will if anything stoke the fires of consolidation and raise the stakes for the big players. The intention is to stimulate competition, for example by bringing Sky, which has dominated rights in Germany and the UK into contention with Canal +, which has a near monopoly over them in France. But ultimately it could end up requiring further antitrust-like measures if we end up with just one or two pan European unified communications giants.

Meanwhile Vodafone has another string to its content bow that has been encouraged by this trend towards rights centralization in Europe. As we reported last month, Vodafone itself is now conducting a trial using LTE Broadcast at the Borussia M’nchengladbach football stadium in Germany. This involves the usual suppliers, Ericsson for software as well DAS antennas, Samsung handsets with Qualcomm Snapdragon chips inside, for decoding the evolved MBMS signal. The significant point was Vodafone’s statement that ‘LTE Broadcast could soon be available in further German stadia,’ revealing the trial as part of its German network modernization program and its ‘Project Spring’, which is driving towards LTE in all of its major markets at an investment of about $11 billion.

Vodafone is now using sports rights as a carrot to entice subscribers to upgrade to LTE, for example with Sky Sports Mobile for $8 a month in the UK.

Vodafone is busy accumulating rights deals for TV shows, movies and music as well as sports to feed this overall strategy that still has mobile at the head but converging around broadband. This new focus on arenas fits in well as a service that can be offered to individual sports clubs, perhaps on the basis that mobile coverage is only available when all seats in the stadium have been sold, so that it creates incremental revenue. Away from the locality of the stadium, the mobile version of the service could in turn complement, rather than compete with, the TV version for the operator such as Vodafone, providing access for people when they are away from their TV.

Vodafone’s UK Sky deal for mobile sports is in step with its general content strategy of collaborating with existing broadcasters or operators rather than investing in original content production. In Spain for example Vodafone recently launched an OTT service called Yomvi in partnership with Canal Plus, which will of course be available to Ono subscribers, possibly in future with additional QoS by exploiting Vodafone’s control over the Ono infrastructure. This will be one area where operators attempt to exploit their fixed line assets to provide broadcast quality content OTT, blurring the distinction with IPTV.

However Vodafone has indicated that in its home market of the UK, it might eventually break from its traditional practice of avoiding direct content involvement by bidding for English Premier League football rights in the next round of bidding in 2015, after noting BT’s success in exploiting its holding to boost broadband subs.

It may be that Vodafone obtains such rights by acquisition, given that the UK is now among its main targets for broadband expansion. Of the potential targets, TalkTalk as the number four provider looks least attractive, while surely Liberty Global would only let Virgin Media go so soon after acquiring it, if the price was way over the odds. BT has been mooted as a target, but capitalized at almost $50 billion may be out of reach, or at least would leave Vodafone struggling to expand in other key target markets such as Italy, where there is also no obvious broadband target.

In the UK Vodafone already has a large fiber network following its $1.6 billion acquisition of the Cable & Wireless UK business in 2012. Although this was largely focused on the enterprise sector, it did bring substantial broadband infrastructure, which would overlap with BT’s in the event of a merger. So perhaps BSkyB might be a target, being smaller with a capitalization around $24 million and remembering that it is only minority owned by 21st Century Fox with 39.14%.

Furthermore Vodafone and BSkyB have been ganging up against BT as a common enemy and by merging they would present a formidable force, despite nearly all of Vodafone’s backhaul coming from BT. BSkyB may feel it is in danger of losing the broadband battle against BT on its own, so such a move could be recommended to shareholders. For Vodafone it would mean becoming the UK’s dominant converged player, number one in pay TV with 11 million subs and in number two or three spot for both mobile and fixed broadband, depending on which data we look at.

Vodafone’s other target market is Italy, where it has just under a third of the mobile market a whisker behind Telecom Italia, still the clear leader at just over 50%, although that has been falling.

For broadband coverage then Telecom Italia would be the obvious target, but Telefonica is its largest shareholder and more significantly its debt now has junk status after being downgraded by Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s credit rating services after posting losses of almost $1 billion last year. It looks like Wind, operating under the Infostrada brand, is a more likely takeover target. Wind Italy has 24% of the mobile market with 22.4 million customers and is number two in broadband with a 17% share. But could Vodafone get at those fixed line assets, without ending up buying a monopoly in cellular, that might trigger anti-trust. Buying Fastweb from Swisscom might represent more value for money, but with far fewer broadband lines.

Vodafone’s Italian job may come next, but any UK move will be the one that will show whether it is able to flex the muscle to get right to the top of Europe’s converged communications market.