News that Apple is in discussion with Comcast over a deal for a streaming OTT service will come as little surprise in the wake of continuing failure by major CE and Internet players to break into the premium content market. The answer is that if you can’t beat the major rights holders you have either to partner with them, or become a significant content producer in your own right as Netflix is doing.
But even then you are left at the margins when it comes to sports and early release movies. Intel finally threw in the towel in January 2014 with the sale of its TV unit to Verizon for what was rumored to be only about $200 million, way below the $500 million it had been hoping for earlier. Meanwhile Microsoft decided to gamble everything on the Xbox by reshaping it as an all-round media box, with a low cost version coming that will function as a basic cable set top, while also getting into original content through its Los Angeles-based Xbox Interactive Studios, founded in February 2013. Around that time Microsoft sold its IPTV Mediaroom middleware platform to Ericsson to concentrate on its Xbox OTT strategy.
Apple’s impending deal with Comcast has yet to be confirmed but has not been denied, with sources merely noting that ‘everyone who is anybody is talking to everybody else at the moment over OTT streaming.’ But Apple and Comcast are not anybody. Comcast is already the largest US pay TV operator just ahead of DirecTV and will greatly increase its lead if its proposed $45 billion takeover of Time Warner Cable is cleared by regulators. It would then have 30% of the US pay TV market with about 35 million pay TV customers. Apple is talking to TWC as well, so the merger would reduce its negotiation load.
It is hard to tell what effect if any news of Comcast’s Apple talks will have on the regulatory decision over TWC. But it could indicate that a combined Comcast/TWC in league with Apple might present an even bigger threat to competitiveness within the overall US TV media and TV content sector, even though there is no immediate overlap between the two MSOs’ footprints. Comcast is after all in a particularly strong position as an owner of content rights through its subsidiary NBC Universal on top of various partnerships. Other pay TV operators are themselves in the position of having to reach content deals for their streaming strategies. For example both the main US DTH operators, Dish Network and DirecTV, have been negotiating with Disney over rights to content for an OTT service.
What all US pay TV operators, including Comcast, DirecTV and Dish, have in common is in looking towards OTT as a low cost alternative to their existing pay TV service, aimed at people who are either set on cord cutting or who previously have never paid for TV, but who would now consider a service for a relatively small monthly fee. This would be for a limited channel bundle but with the ability to access the service OTT on fixed and mobile connected devices. That after all is the Netflix model and pay TV operators are seeking to snuff out that advantage, which is why Netflix shares fell 7% when news of the Apple/Comcast talks broke.
Comcast as it happens has already struck a deal with Netflix to receive payments in return for providing a guaranteed path through its Hybrid Fiber Coax (HFC) infrastructure for its movie and TV show content. There was a hint of hypocrisy about that deal given that Netflix is also advocating stronger net neutrality rules in order to ensure that its content receives fair treatment from ISPs with which it has no such agreement. But now it is working with broadband providers such as Comcast to hook up its ever expanding CDN infrastructure directly to their access networks in order to enable guaranteed end to end QoS for premium content. It was therefore a bit rich for Netflix’ CEO Reed Hastings to suggest recently that he agreed the Comcast deal only “reluctantly” and that his preference was for a level playing field enforced by strong net neutrality rules.
There are no such tensions surrounding the putative Comcast/Apple deal since in that case it would be the broadband provider also delivering the content. The appeal for Comcast would lie in creating an entry level retail proposition around the Apple TV box, which is currently priced at $99 and competes with similar streaming devices from Roku and Google, among others. Association with the Apple brand would also make the Comcast offer competitive and perhaps even enable it to be charged at a small premium over competitors. On the other hand Apple’s street credibility rating has fallen off the heights of a few years ago when the iPhone was beating all comers, before being overtaken in sales by Samsung. Apple in its negotiations with pay TV operators has nothing like the strong position it had with the mobile phone networks, which it exploited to extract preferential deals that ultimately led to an ongoing investigation by the European Commission on fair competition grounds. Apple is accused of extracting heavy subsidies for mobile customers from operators on the price of iPhones as part of monthly contracts. In effect these subsidies were paid by those subscribers who opted for rival handsets from the likes of Samsung or Nokia. Such subscribers ended up paying higher tariffs or prices for the handsets as part of their plans, so the accusation goes.
Ironically Apple may have been saved from action from competition regulators by the rapid rise of Samsung. This had the effect of reducing Apple’s market share to around 20% in Europe, making it hard for competition authorities to argue that it had abused its position to achieve market dominance, although it was the runaway leader for a time. The European Commission might define smartphones alone as a market, or talk about total profit in a market, and then Apple may have a larger share, and remain susceptible.
Now Apple is in no such position to extract punitive terms from Comcast, given its dire need to have access to the content. Comcast is by far the most attractive pay TV partner in the US from Apple’s perspective, which has at least an equal incentive to see it through. Comcast stands to gain beyond having an iconic partner for its retail OTT venture. It also brings the prospect of Comcast offering its service over the top of competitors’ networks and therefore obtaining national coverage beyond its footprint. In some cases Comcast will be restricted by geographical limitations over rights, but of course that does not apply to its own content and increasingly pay TV operators in general have been seeking national distribution rights. So with both parties standing to gain substantially it looks like being a matter of negotiating the admittedly considerable business and technical obstacles to a final deal.