Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 March 2014

Let there be LiFi

LiFi is a technology that is slowly stepping out of the shadows to emerge as a possible alternative to WiFi, and UK-based pureLiFi’s Li-1st system is riding the crest of a wave. In an age where talk of radio congestion and bandwidth capacity strains is a constant background chatter, LiFi stands to bring some light to the doom and gloom ‘ quite literally as it happens.

Reminiscent of the Infrared Data Association (IrDA) technology that was popular in the 1990s, and defined by the IEEE 802.15.7 protocol, pureLiFi (Light Fidelity or Visible Light Communication/VLC) is a brand name for a project spun out of the University of Edinburgh, based on the Ultra Parallel Visible Light research carried out by the universities of Edinburgh, St. Andrews, Strathclyde, Oxford and Cambridge.

Scientists and engineers at the institutes developed a wireless communication network that uses the visible light spectrum, instead of the traditional radio waves that are used in WiFi. Professor Harald Haas is considered to be the drive behind the project, which received £4.6 million in government funding from the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council.

While still part of the electromagnetic spectrum, the visible light spectrum has a much higher frequency than radio waves, and consequently a much shorter wavelength. The wavelength of visible light can be blocked by a sheet of paper, whereas all but the shortest radio waves would still pass through it.

Radio waves need a longer wavelength to penetrate objects and maintain their signal clarity. The current cellular radio access network would grind to a halt if radio waves could not pass through objects ‘ that’s exactly why cellular spectrum in the lower frequencies is so hotly contested by MNOs, as the radio waves can pass through walls, forests, even buildings.

So initially you would be forgiven for thinking that LiFi is crippled by its incredibly short wavelength and non-existent material penetration. But the technology’s proponents embrace this factor and believe that it is a wonderfully inherent security measure, as signals can’t pass through walls and the maximum range of the communication is around 5 meters.

Direct line of sight is not needed for communications, as the signals can reflect off of surfaces to reach their destination, just like WiFi. It is likely that LiFi could bring wireless connectivity to areas where radio waves can’t be used safely or conveniently and wired connections aren’t an option ‘ something of a niche we must concede.

The technology works by modulating LED light sources at a speed measured in nanoseconds. The light itself is visible to the human eye, but because of the immense speed at which the light alternates between binary states, the communication itself is not perceptible by humans. This means that it can be installed without affecting people’s wellbeing in the slightest.

As it stands, a person could look at a LiFi unit and see the bulb turned on. It would look like any ordinary LED and can operate as regular room lighting. But the viewer could not tell if it was transmitting a signal. The bulbs can also be dimmed to the point where they no longer appear to be on and still be entirely operational, but the resulting impact on the transmission rates is unclear.

The researchers behind LiFi have demonstrated a transfer speed of 3.5Gbps in laboratory conditions using one micro-LED. Speeds of 10Gbps are possible when a bulb for each of the primary colors is used in parallel (red, blue, green) as the three colors together make up visible white light.

Edinburgh’s lead researcher Professor Harald Haas likened it to ‘a shower head separating water out into parallel streams; that’s how we can make light behave.’ The system uses OFDM to handle the millions of binary changes in the bulbs that transmit data each second.

Researcher’s at Germany’s Fraunhofer Heinrich Hertz Institute claimed that data rates of up to 1Gbit/s per light frequency were possible in laboratory conditions, and Chinese scientists have reportedly developed a LED bulb with integrated chip that serves up to four computers at 150Mbps ‘ a speed that eclipses the 5Mbps Li-1st capacity and a claim we are somewhat suspicious of.

Consumer products have already been demonstrated. PureLiFi demonstrated the first commercially available Li-Fi system at Mobile World Congress this year. In 2011, Haas used pureLiFi to stream a HD video to a laptop and now the Li-Flame prototype on display in Barcelona was used to stream from a ceiling mounted LED unit to a TV.

The Li-Flame is an evolution of the company’s Li-1st and Li-Fire technology, which uses much the same system to transmit data to and from PCs via a roof light and a receiver on a desk. The laptop plugs into the receiver via USB and the receiver acts as the gateway for two-way communication between the Ethernet-backhauled LED access point on the ceiling ‘ at minimum speeds of 5Mbps downlink and uplink, with a range of 3 meters.

Chips inside the receiver and the access point decode the light signal into electrical signals that both the end user device and the Ethernet backhaul can use. The desktop receiver uplinks via an infra-red emitter.

The Li-Flame TV implementation uses an LED light in the ceiling and a receiver that plugs into the TV. CNet filmed a short video that shows the technology in action in which their reporter interrupts the stream by placing his hand over the receiver, cutting the data off. This was a repeat of Haas’ TED unveil in 2011.
But while this article may sound very warm to the LiFi technology, we are nonetheless quite skeptical that it can catch on as a replacement for WiFi networking for a number of reasons. Visible Light Communication has a few niche implementations where it is a suitable alternative to the radio waves used in WiFi. Hospitals and aircraft are environments sensitive to radio and armed forces around the world will no doubt be interested too (if not already conducting their own research).

Ultra-localized communication systems could also make use of the technology, an example being a traffic light communicating to an automated car at the front of a queue of stationary traffic to tell it when to begin moving. Its limited range may constitute a security feature, but it simultaneously makes LiFi extremely costly for use in the home or a small building.

As such, LiFi’s biggest hurdle to clear is the cost of installation, as each room would need at least one LiFi ceiling fixture and desktop receiver. This means that if a home were to replace its WiFi network with a LiFi system, currently it would have to fit those two units into every room of the house, complete with Ethernet backhaul. Until those units are miniaturized and made very much cheap, there is no way that a LiFi system can come in at the $35 or so that a WiFi router costs – despite Haas claiming that LiFi is cheaper than WiFi by ‘a factor of ten.’

So while LiFi will be invaluable to places that can’t use WiFi and where a wired alternative is not possible or severely impractical, widespread LiFi is presently prohibitively priced ‘ not that there are prices available for the pureLiFi prototypes currently.

Later evolutions of the system will undoubtedly address the issue of cost, but as it stands LiFi is not on track to usurp WiFi. In general use, the positives are outweighed by the negatives, as the supposed security with the signal not being able to pass through a wall is the precise reason many will avoid the technology altogether.

With WiFi, it’s quite simple for most applications to add security to the system once the transmission has passed through the wall, or the kid’s room, or people standing by the water cooler etc. There is not as simple a workaround to be found in LiFi.

But if the cost of the system is brought down sufficiently then it may find its way into commercial deployment, in offices and showrooms, where LiFi units could be built into light fixtures and miniaturized into PCs, interactive displays, digital signage and so on.

As the bandwidth of the visible light spectrum is some 10,000 times greater than the entire radio frequency spectrum, the technology seems to have a natural home in environments where the radio network is heavily congested.

Should the technology can be incorporated into the light bulbs themselves, drawing power from the light fitting and perhaps backhauling as a mesh network or via power line, then LiFi could be sold as an out-of-the-box product. LED and smart LED bulbs are on the rise, and given the 10-year lifetimes of some of these bulbs, miniaturized LiFi could find its way into homes and businesses that way.

Z-Wave, Zigbee and Bluetooth Low Energy are already used to co-ordinate smart lighting systems in home automation, and new builds or installations could feasibly push the internet connectivity up into the light bulb itself.

OLEDCOMM has another LiFi implementation, which it showed off at CES. A lamp was connected to a Netgear router, which was transmitting via 4 LEDs to a sensor hooked up to a MacBook. Each LED had a bandwidth of 2.5Mbps, for a total of 10Mbps two-way communication.

OLEDCOMM also had a dongle for smartphones and tablets, which provided a light sensor connected through the 3.5mm audio jack. That sensor was also incorporated into the front facing camera on a number of demo smartphones at CES, which shows that the technology can be readily integrated into existing hardware.

These smartphones were used to demonstrate how LiFi could be used in retail stores to push coupons to shoppers, as well as switch between videos being played on screen or in app for advertising and product engagement. As Endgadget’s Jamie Rigg put it, the LiFi acted as a ‘light-based QR code. The company currently sells a fairly broad range of LiFi LED bulbs, spotlights, projectors and panel lamps, which would provide those one-way capabilities to businesses today, if the consumer devices were capable of receiving LiFi signals.

LiFi has not appeared on any consumer handsets or computers and the technology won’t take off until it does, although the demo devices and connectors show that LiFi can work on existing hardware. The Internet of Things (IoT) could use LiFi as a very powerful communication platform and the IoT might be the force that drives LiFi out to market ‘ as a potentially cheap and high capacity way of connecting devices to each other and the web.