Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 March 2014

ActiveVideo claims pole position in race to interactive advertising scale

When one VP of product marketing nails you down for the second time since a product introduction, you just have to ante up and think about the technology, no matter how reluctant you are and this has happened with one of the companies of 2013, ActiveVideo, and Sachin Sathaye its VP Product Marketing

Sathaye wants us to believe that his organization has the means to solve the ‘interactive advertising’ conundrum.

Now for some reason at Faultline our minds go blank when we think about Interactive Advertising. It is a combination of knowing that most of the world’s TVs are not interactive, and that there is no real way of interacting with your TV set except for a remote control, and that Interactive Advertising already exists on the internet, so why not just leave it there? It’s too tough, too many people are trying shortcuts to it, and we tend to think it won’t reach enough people or even if it does, it would break, i.e. the system might not scale.

But the truth is that cable is accelerating its move to full IP, what with CCAP products and HEVC, cutting costs and bandwidth requirements, so at some point someone will win in this market and win big. It’s just that for the past ten years we have been listening to dreamers who ended up going bust in interactive TV or moving onto something else.

Also as adverts move unerringly towards being created in HTML 5.0 that looks alarmingly like the main business of ActiveVideo, in fact Chief marketing officer Murali Nemani, has gone on record saying that the new ActiveVideo system called CloudTV AdCast, is just a specialist version of video delivery system which renders interactive UIs and HTML 5.0 in the cloud.

We are only too aware of just how many installed set tops are ancient and don’t seem to have the processing power or the connectivity to allow for advertising to be a two way conversation. But if you deliver content from the cloud instead of from a QAM channel, to that device, it must be connected to the DOCSIS channel, and if so it must have a return path. In the past the difficulty was that advertising on QAM could not be coordinated with an IP return path. So this really is something that ActiveVideo is doing already.

For beleaguered marketing executives everywhere among major brands, getting live leads that lead to sales NOW, has become the Holy Grail, because we all know intuitively that the internet scales and can pull people in, as long as you control what is being seen out there, by who and as long as they live in the right territory and buy in the right currency. Those last bits are not always easy, but it is do-able.

ActiveVideo has been demonstrating this system since CES in January and Sathaye would have us believe that when you deliver interactivity to a TV channel, whether that is viewed on a TV or on a tablet, the engagement of actually being able to interact with the TV makes for really high advertising performance.

In an ActiveVideo Blog it was recently pointed out that in second screen interactive advertising the majority of users ignored adverts which appeared on the second screen tablet app, resulting in a click-through rate of 1.2% when ads were not related to the commercials on the TV set. However when the ad messaging on the tablet was synced with the TV commercial, it registered a 39% click-through rate on the synchronized ad unit. If that is true, then there is a reason for it being a Holy advertising Grail. If it works that way on a difficult to co-ordinate second screen app, using Shazam or something similar for syncing, then when it appears directly within the viewing experience on the first screen, it seems likely to have the same kind of uplift.

Sathaye told us, ‘Ziggo and KPN are already using the system and we can use it with all of our existing installations.’ That is taken to mean service providers including Liberty Global, Charter, Cablevision, Time Warner Cable, Deutsche Telecom, J:COM in Japan, Ziggo and Comcast. It can also be used with specific platforms like Roku boxes and LG TVs. ActiveVideo cites 10 million devices, but of course these are widely spread around the world in a variety of territories.

‘There is an opportunity to work out lots of places to put the advertisements, for instance on the TV guide, and shortly we will have this as an overlay, and it definitely leads to great brand engagement.’

We reply that we are worried about scale and remind him of this thin spread of his client devices. He comes back with, ‘In 3 months the American Express advert has had 110,000 clicks, and the average engagement with the advertising is 14 minutes, and the maximum is between 18 and 20 minutes. On the internet there is only 2 minutes on average engagement with interactive adverts.’ It’s an impressive statistic.

Sathaye reminds us that Loreal wants to go to 20 million devices, so second screen adverts just aren’t going to cut it, but we cannot see audiences of that size in a single advertising territory either, even using Cloud TV, not for some years, and we say so.

‘Among most cable operators as they are today there are only a few hundred thousand devices capable of interactivity. Without our Cloud TV they have too many legacy devices, whereas we can run this as an interactive adverts on any type of device, so we could put this right across an entire cable footprint .’

Well we expect that not all of cable devices can be made to work with ActiveVideo and we have seen no installations which have scaled to the full population of devices at an operator. But that doesn’t mean that it won’t happen over the next two to three years.

Sathaye continues, ‘The problem is how to bring OTT content to every set top box
Take for example the Virgin Netflix App. It took a lot of developers to get that onto every device. If it was done on ActiveVideo we could do that with existing technology.

This issue of speed to market with an interactive campaign is critical. Sometimes these campaigns only run for six to eight weeks and if it takes three to four months to create an application for each device, it’s just a mismatch.

You can tell he very much wants a Netflix involvement, because he feels ActiveVideo and Netflix could do cloud interactive DVR with interactive advertising at scale.

We question just how much of a lead ActiveVideo really has. We are aware of the company’s IPR but not exactly its secret sauce. ‘We use what are called MPEG stitch-able fragments,’ he said, and goes on to explain how one part of a video frame can come from another source and be automatically stitched to another on a cloud server, to create a single video out of multiple separate videos and graphics. It seems an obvious step, but Sathaye insists that no-one else can do this right now. It then renders it, and sends it a form of IP video that the local device already knows how to play.

The key step that ActiveVideo has taken is to partner with a specialist interactive player called Brightline that brings all the tools that advertising agencies need, as it has been doing interactive advertising for a decade. Brightline brings tools to create, deploy and measure interactive advertising campaigns on the TV.

At the moment AdCast is positioned as a Software as a Service (SaaS) but later a fully internally hosted version will be available. While we do not disagree with Sathaye that the right kind of managed interactive campaigns are very promising for OTT delivered TV programming, we would say the jury is still out over whether or not the ActiveVideo approach will scale to sufficiently large audience sizes in a single given territory, before someone else also solves the problem.