Ericsson has at last brought its extensive encoding product portfolio together inside a single coherent offering seven years after becoming a major player in the field through its acquisition of Tandberg TV in 2007. But apart from serving to unify the portfolio, EVE (Ericsson Virtualized Encoding) looks like it will help operators deploy new services faster, while also providing a means to tap overflow encoding capacity at peak times.
EVE itself is just a software front end to a range of video encoding solutions that can be deployed by operators, or as part of a cloud service that would enable encoding scalability. The software is meant to take away the pain from operators and broadcasters of deploying encoding. Our takes is that most other encoding manufacturers have a cloud offering and that failure to embrace this was killed deals at Ericsson. The problem with any strategy around ASICs is that they are not ready for HEVC and 4K yet, or they cannot run on an unmodified cloud server, not one including the new Ericsson encoding chip.
Ericsson needed a cloud strategy that plays to its strengths and we presume that its own A6 broadcaster encoder chip cannot be used in the cloud versions.
EVE can automatically select the right encoding method for a particular service or individual piece of content and then find the most suitable platform upon which to execute it, based on the operator’s priorities for deployment speed, video quality and cost. It is also supposed to achieve efficient utilization both of hardware and network bandwidth management, serving as a bridge between broadcast and IT infrastructures.
EVE supports compressed off-air or mezzanine and uncompressed inputs, as well as traditional linear broadcast on cable, IPTV, DTH satellite and DTT, along with multiscreen ABR (Adaptive Bit Rate) delivery over IP. Naturally given Ericsson’s resources MPEG-2, MPEG-4 AVC and HEVC codecs are all supported.
For those who thought that software encoding as advocated by Envivio and Elemental Technologies had convincingly won the argument over dedicated hardware, Ericsson has a surprise. ‘We believe compression performance is still key to the operator,’ said Ericsson’s head of TV compression, Giles Wilson. This statement would not alarm Envivio or Elemental, for they agree with that sentiment, but argue that software based approaches have at least caught up for performance. But Wilson then contended that hardware still had the edge for encoding large amounts of live premium content. On the other hand the software approach scored at lower scales and for on demand content, Wilson conceded.
The point is that EVE can support both hardware and software encoding in whatever combination is desired for a given service. This could be a cloud based encoding service shared between a number of broadcasters or operators. It can be implemented on processing platforms comprising a combination of dedicated programmable hardware such as Ericsson’s video processing chip and software or GPU (Graphical Processing Unit) based servers. Does that put it into pole position to acquire one of the two software only encoder makers and integrate them at a stroke?
Elemental pioneered the use of large numbers of commodity GPUs and CPUs in combination to enable massively parallel processing of multiple streams. Elemental, together with Envivio with an approach based largely on Intel CPUs, have collared the multiscreen encoding market, but Ericsson’s argument is that dedicated hardware will figure again as multiscreen services start delivering large amounts of live and linear content.
Such debates are starting to become academic, as the distinction between hardware and software encoding begins to fade. Intel’s Quick Sync Video is a case in point, as this comprises a dedicated transcoding core incorporated on Intel’s SandyBridge and IvyBridge chips as well as the more recently developed Haswell processors. It is effectively a hardware approach but does not require dedicated silicon since the logic is likely to appear in off the shelf cloud servers. So in one sense it conforms with the software approach, which relies on the existence of logic within off the shelf chips that can be utilized readily for encoding.
This leads to the one concession that Elemental and Envivio are prepared to make to the hardware camp, which is that dedicated silicon does reduce power consumption. This is because generic chips will have more extensive circuitry, which dissipates more energy as heat because the electrons have further to travel. Dedicated chips can be optimized, with all the circuitry as compact as possible for a given task. Ericsson is equivocal here since its portfolio covers most of the bases and EVE will work with all of them.
Like most majors, providing an operating system for a particular function, like Cisco did with routers, is perhaps the best way to corner or control a market, and create clients that have to use one make of encoder, and perhaps deployment of EVE is aimed at this.