Dolby’s new High Dynamic Range (HDR) technology could have a much greater effect on consumer picture quality than 4K, especially in the short term. CES in January and NAB this week were both ablaze with 4K demonstrations, but that omnipresent buzzword may be disrupted by the Dolby Vision High Dynamic Range technology over the course of the next few years.
At Faultline we have all been skeptical of 4K’s impact and short term viability. There is a detailed discussion of the inherent problems that 4K brings to the market available in the February 6th edition.
To quickly recap those problems, 4K file sizes and streaming bandwidths are too high for the majority of last mile consumer connections. Netflix currently struggles to push 1080p content at peak times, so 4K will be incredibly problematic for the majority of consumers. If viewers can’t watch 4K content, why would they buy a more expensive 4K panel?
Data caps on consumer broadband lines are another issue, separate from the speed of their connection, but the most prominent issue that besets 4K is that the higher resolution is very hard to spot for most consumers on screens smaller than 60 inches. Try as they might, physics can’t be brushed aside by marketers.
1080p content on a 120 inch TV suffers from visible pixels. 4K provides the extra necessary pixels to address that issue on a 120 inch TV, but the issue of visible pixels is much harder to spot on any TV under 60 inches. As such, only the very large TVs actually need 4K resolutions to improve the quality of the picture, which is problematic for sales as larger LCD TVs are much more expensive ‘ although not as expensive as OLED TVs.
However HDR lighting could provide an immediate and obvious boost to picture quality on LCD panels of all sizes. Put simply, HDR stands to make every LCD panel look a lot better. On smaller panels, sub 60 inches for example, LED backlighting and HDR images will make a much more obvious improvement to quality than 4K. Dolby stresses the need for better pixels, rather than simply more pixels.
Essentially, Dolby wants to increase the amount of the visible light spectrum that makes it into the final image displayed on screen. In a presentation that it gave at CES in January, Dolby showed that the current compression standards mean that less than half of the visible light is incorporated into the image. The Dolby HDR system would use upwards of 80% of the light to capture more detail in the image.
The dynamic range of an image is the term used to describe the range between the darkest and lightest color captured, also known as contrast ratio. LCD TVs typically have contrast ratios of between 2000:1 and 4000:1.Plasma TVs, which have now died an ignominious death, could display around 2-3 times the ratio of an LCD panel. OLED panels have much higher (near infinite) contrast ratios than both, thanks to the improved way they display blacks, as the black in an OLED panel is a complete absence of light. Unfortunately for OLED, the superior image quality is dwarfed by its current price tag, dictated by low panel yields.
HDR combines multiple digital images into a composite that captures a better range of highs and lows in the details of the image. The camera or post-processing software will combine a number of images that have been exposed at different settings. One shot at a dark exposure will be taken, another at a high exposure, and usually one at a neutral exposure ‘ these are then combined to produce a HDR image, which has a much broader tonal range.
Traditional celluloid film works in a very similar manner, as the different layers of the film react to light at different speeds. This meant that a single exposure captured the detail from the nearly the full spectrum of visible light.
Image sensors have been specially designed to capture HDR images. The Oversampled Binary Image sensor uses a binary measurement of light for each pixel, so that each pixel gives a reading that is either light or dark. The image sensor then logarithmically measures groups of pixels, rather than single pixels, which helps ensure that single pixels do not oversaturate the image. Consequently, the dynamic range is not defined by single pixels and therefore is not washed out in bright light or devoid of detail in dark lighting.
New high-end cameras on the market are increasingly capable of HDR imaging. Some capture the plural composite images and then allow a user to manually create the HDR composition, but others have on-board software that handles the process. HDR is a feature on some smartphone cameras, but there are many apps available that can capture HDR images through cameras that don’t have it built in.
To look now at the other end of the distribution chain, you’ll find that most LCD panels use edge-lighting, which consists of lights behind the edges of the panel to provide the backlight needed to see the image. Those lights have historically been cold cathode fluorescent lamps, but edge-lighting has issues of uniformity on large panels where gaps in the lighting can compromise picture quality.
As LEDs have become thinner and cheaper, backlighting that puts LEDs behind the entire screen is becoming more common. Full LED backlighting will allow for local dimming of the panel, which will help HDR viewing immensely. This technique should help tackle the issue of haloing or blooming that has hampered HDR on edge-lit panels. Increased brightness and accuracy also allows a greater range of colors to be displayed on the screen with better accuracy. All the TVs on the market now tend to have LED lighting, though not the majority yet of the installed based.
LED backlit TV market penetration rates reached 95% in 2013, according to LEDinside, a branch of research institute TrendForce. It predicts the complete demise of Cold Cathode Fluorescent Lamps (CCFL) as backlights in TVs by 2014, but a 17% fall in market value for LED TVs despite a 3% growth by numbers. TVs that use LEDs to edge-light the display will be overtaken by TVs that use full array LED backlighting, but the latter use around half the amount of LEDs as the former ‘ hence the fall in value. The newer LED technology is expected to achieve 60% market penetration in 2014, due to their greater efficiency, slimmer design and thinner bezels.
So while the full array lighting is certainly on the way to becoming the main viewing medium for consumers, the edge-lit screens will not display the HDR pictures well due to their inherent issues with precision. But once the full array back-lit panels penetrate the market, HDR will be poised to usurp 4K’s marketing shine.
In summary, Plasma is dead, OLED is too expensive and 4K is impractical for content delivery. Back-lit LCD panels are much cheaper than their rivals. 4K also needs a very big screen to make a notable difference to picture quality over Full HD, but Dolby Vision’s HDR technology can make a dramatic difference on LCD panels that will be more noticeable (and valuable) to many consumers than cramming four times the pixels into the same screen real estate as their old TV. Better lighting is the key to HDR.
As Bryan Bishop at The Verge put it, ‘the problem is that the human eye is used to seeing a much wider range of light in real life. The sun at noon is about 1.6 billion nits (a unit of measurement for luminance), for example, while starlight comes in at a mere .0001 nits; the highlights of sun reflecting off a car can be hundreds of times brighter than the vehicle’s hood. The human eye can see it all, but when using contemporary technology that same range of brightness can’t be accurately reproduced. You can have rich details in the blacks or the highlights, but not both.’
As the brightness levels of displays haven’t changed radically since CRT displays settled on 100 nits. TV has kept the 100 nit level as a reference, but modern TVs have to stretch the 100 nit signal to match their higher brightness of around 400-500 nits. Stretching the signal too far will degrade picture quality. The human eye can see so much more than a TV panel can convey, and so any increase in brightness and contrast is very noticeable.
Dolby Vision claims to encode an image with a dynamic range of 0 to 10,000 nits. To demonstrate the technology, Dolby built a 21 inch 1080p panel with a liquid-cooled LED backlight that was made up of 18,000 RGB LEDs. Most standard monitors have around 4000-5000 LEDs in a backlight, and this allows the panel to provide very focused local brightness and dimming on the picture that is much more precise than current panels.
The Dolby Vision panel had a peak brightness of 4,000 nits. Dolby has also shown the improved quality of image to manufacturers using the new format but on their existing products.
Consequently, the Dolby Vision HDR signal carries more information than a standard video signal, as it has a lot of lighting information to convey. This of course means that the content will have to be re-encoded in the correct format.
Dolby Vision uses a signal that is compatible with existing 4K and HD systems. The base signal can provide the data needed, but Dolby has programmed an ‘enhancement layer’ that will be ignored by panels not able to display the extra signal. The enhancement layer adds an additional 20% in size to the signal, but contains all of the extra data needed to display the HDR images on screen.
And so it looks like the Dolby system could upend the 4K bandwagon. If two 40 inch LCD panels were displayed side by side, one non-HDR 4K and one Full HD Dolby Vision, and both TVs displayed a Dolby Vision encoded demo reel, we would bet that consumers would prefer the look of the HDR system because of the extra lighting detail in the signal. For Dolby, it’s simply a matter of better pixels rather than more pixels.
If the comparison’s screens were 96 inches, the 1080p screen would suffer from visible pixels. But most consumers are not buying a TV that is big enough for 4K to stretch its legs, and there MUST be an argument that in the world of tablet delivered video that the direction of screen size may actually change.
The current lack of 4K content only worsens that purchasing dilemma. If Dolby Vision encodes currently available content, as Dolby hints it is poised to, then the cheaper LCD panel may well stave off 4K and OLED for quite a few more years, thanks to its cheaper price, undercutting the benefits of the superior panels.
This is of course ignoring the fact that a 4K LCD panel will be perfectly capable of displaying Dolby Vision ‘ it will just cost more to buy upfront and that might be the deciding factor in favor of the Full HD LCD + HDR for the consumer in the showroom. It’s all a matter of price for the consumer.
We visited a major retailer’s website to check the prices of a 55 inch TV from LG. All three were smart TVs, with 3D built in, with the same aesthetics, and the differences in price prove our argument ‘ the OLED cost roughly $7,500, the fully backlit 4K about $3,900, and the 1080p TV with 3 months of a movie and sports package thrown, in cost $1,500.
Clearly, if HDR adoption requires as small a change to hardware as Dolby claims, then it is clear that the improved picture quality on the Full HD panel could prevent consumers opting to spend twice as much to get the 4K version.
But Dolby Vision needs to engrain itself in the content distribution ecosystem if it is going to take off at all. Next week we’ll explore the pros and cons of the HDR technology, before examining the impact on the market the week after that.