Part 3 of our series on High Dynamic Range
Dolby’s HDR technology could provide a significantly improved picture quality on LCD screens and is poised to be disruptive, thanks to 4K’s problems with reaching consumers over their last mile internet connections. But Dolby is not the only player in the HDR market. Technicolor is working on a rival system, and Sony also has a consumer product that alters a signal to boost the contrast ratio of the image.
Technicolor’s HDR technology currently lacks a brand name but it was on show at CES this year. Using a prototype SIM2 panel rated at 4,000 nits, the demonstration showed 4K HDR footage captured by Sony F65 cameras. Technicolor director of research Christina Comila said that Technicolor was working on a HDR postproduction system, but would not go into detail.
The tight-lipped French approach doesn’t make clear how mature the technology is but Dolby seems to have the lead in the field, as it is already bragging about relationships with Hollywood studios and silicon vendors that have backed the Dolby Vision technology ‘ although it too is not providing names.
Technicolor was a founding member of the NEVex Project, which was launched in October 2011 and due to run for 30 months. Its objective was to research the HDR market, and in particular study the distribution chain from image capture to on-screen display. This is where Technicolor’s interest in the technology has stemmed from.
Technicolor engineer and project coordinator Catherine Serr’ said that the venture would consider three HDR implementations. ‘The first is a solution which pre-processes HDR content on input to use the broadcast and restoration infrastructures. The second is a complete chain that uses two views, where the HDR content is output to a HDR screen and exists alongside non-HDR content. The third scenario is based on a long term view of a native HDR chain where the HDR content is broadcast end-to-end in a single flow.’
Technicolor uses a proprietary system that encodes a vanilla version of the signal and then adds the extra HDR data to be read alongside it. It also has a system that will alter a vanilla signal to turn it into a HDR picture using a series of algorithms.
The company is also working on persuading the ITU-R to include its system in Rec. 2020, which is something that we feel is vital for both Dolby Vision and Technicolor to achieve if they want to succeed. If either company was successful in winning over the ITU-R, it would find itself with default compatibility with all HEVC products and systems that complied with the Rec. 2020 standard.
The NEVex project is also studying algorithms which would enable HDR images to be displayed on a non-HDR screen and vice versa. Sony has attempted a similar process independently of NEVex, called X-tended Dynamic Range.
Found in its Bravia range, the feature is a chip in the TV that boosts the contrast of the source signal to improve the contrast ratio. It differs from the source implementations of Dolby and Technicolor by being applied after the content has been delivered to the studio. This means that there is no increased bandwidth consumption, at the expense of trusting the X-tended Range system to determine the contrast ratio rather than the colorists at the studio. It is not an end-to-end system; it’s a consumer-end system that acts independently of the content houses.
Sony says that the technique ‘keeps energy consumption low by precisely dimming the backlight for dark areas of a scene and allowing three times the electric current to be applied to bright areas when necessary.’ Sony claims the TVs are three times as bright as normal TVs, which puts the X-tended Range technology somewhere around 300 nits ‘ not as bright as other dedicated HDR TVs that have been seen in the wild. The 4K Bravias can also upscale a 1080p picture to 4K resolution while applying the HDR improvement. That process is powered by the X-Reality Pro processing engine, which is housed on the same chip. The Bravias will also support HEVC.
Samsung also has an as yet unnamed X-tended range equivalent that was demonstrated at CES on a modified 85S9 TV that went up to 300 nits ‘ perhaps hedging its bets against the significant investment it has made in OLED TVs. It was also the first official partner that uses Technicolor’s algorithmic technology to upscale content from 1080p to 4K for the M-Go streaming service. M-Go is a US OTT joint venture between Dream Works and Technicolor that offers native 4K as well as upscaled 4K content from Hollywood studios.
Although the M-Go deal is not an HDR implementation, it could provide the basis of a future deal that could place Technicolor ahead of Dolby, which has not yet announced any solid commitments from content creators regarding Dolby Vision.
But Dolby is slowly establishing itself in the video ecosystem. Dolby’s Senior Director of Broadcast Imaging, Roland Vlaicu said that Dolby is ‘using a dual-layer codec concept that takes in the Dolby Vision 12-bit (or more) signal and separates it into the base layer (defined as today’s 8-bit H.264 for HD or 10-bit HEVC for UHD/4K) and into an enhancement layer that contains both metadata and the additional HDR information needed, which requires around 20-25% of incremental bandwidth on top of the base layer.’
He added that the company had ‘developed Dolby Vision into chipsets with silicon vendors, focused on leveraging as much of the existing hardware blocks available on a chip as possible.’ This strategy should allow Dolby Vision to enter the market at the same pace as UHDTV compatible hardware, which is supported by HEVC.
If Dolby can shift the ecosystem to support its HDR format, through the industry standard and the OEMs, then it hopes to license Dolby Vision in much the same manner as it licenses its audio products. Vlaicu said that for ‘the professional part of the ecosystem, there are elements we have developed that are currently going through industry standardization.’ This hints that Dolby is having some success with the ITU-R in persuading it to adjust the Rec. 2020 provision, but we will believe it when we see it.
However the consumer hardware is on the way. Sharp, TCL and Vizio displayed prototype models of the Dolby Vision system at this year’s CES, and all three expect to have consumer models available by the 2014 holiday period.
Vizio, the number one seller of TVs in the US, will offer HDR on its P series Reference range ‘ the cinephile edition of the P-series that emits a brightness measured at 800 nits which is more than twice the brightness of the Sony and Samsung panels. No prices have been released for the model, but Vizio’s first consumer-grade 4K TVs will measure between 50-70 inches, with an LED backlight with 64 active dimming zones. Vizio has also dropped 3D from its entire range. The Reference model will support 4K at 60fps, if the viewer is able to secure content for their 4K panel at that frame rate.
Blu-ray can support the HDR format in theory, but it is much more likely that the Dolby Vision format will reach consumers via OTT services. So far, Netflix, Amazon Instant Video, Xbox Video and Vudu have agreed to provide HDR content, as well as movies from the larger Hollywood studios scheduled to be available in 2015 at the earliest.
However, the supply of content will be the key issue to the success of HDR as a product. If it is to become a driving factor in the purchase of new LCD TVs, it needs enough HDR content to influence their purchasing decision. As such, Dolby Vision will only succeed if it can successfully create an end-to-end ecosystem that produces and supplies content in HDR. We were initially skeptical of Dolby’s potential for success, but a conversation with Dolby senior sales manager Ian Lowe revealed that Dolby was further along this path than its announcements have suggested.
Lowe is responsible for the EMEA region and answered questions that had been puzzling us regarding the time frame of Dolby Vision deployment. As the above discussion has suggested, we envisioned the Dolby Vision TVs from Vizio, Sharp and TCL launching around Christmas 2014 with no content to show on the new screens. We thought it might have been something of a damp squib, but Dolby is not focused on short term deployments. Lowe gave us some insight into Dolby’s long-game.
It boils down to this. Dolby is building an ecosystem, not a product to be sold directly to consumers. Starting at the production studios, Dolby hopes that the picture quality will speak for itself and persuade directors and decision makers to choose the Dolby Vision codec. Improved picture quality is a selling point that the studios can exploit for years to come, as content is sold in markets around the world and in different formats such as physical media, SVoD and OTT. The fact that the strain on last mile connections and bandwidths is much lower than 4K is another selling point of Dolby Vision that studios and operators will wish to consider.
Lowe explained that Dolby Vision will likely begin appearing in cinema releases of movies around 2015/16. By this time, the consumer HDR TVs from Vizio, Sharp and TCL will have been released and we anticipate other manufacturers to have launched HDR products by that time too.
A theatrical release of a Dolby Vision mastered film in 2015/16, if it follows the traditional model, will ensure that the PPV and SVoD services can show the movie 3 months after it has finished its 4-6 week run in the theaters. Physical media versions are also released at the 3 month mark, as well as through some download services like iTunes, but at the 6 month mark the movie will transition from iTunes to premium services. This is where the movie will be exclusively seen or the next 6 years or so until it begins airing on broadcast television.
At every stage of that distribution process, Dolby Vision can be used as a selling point for the content, which studios will most likely gravitate towards as a value-add product. Blu-ray will be able to support Dolby Vision formats but won’t be able to handle 4K file sizes. As such, physical media platforms would remain relevant in the market place and a source of sales and revenue until such a time that the OTT internet connections are capable of pushing 4K to the masses. Broadband internet was heralded by some as the death-knell of physical media, but that axe has yet to fall thanks to last-mile bottlenecks.
However, this gradual process means that Dolby Vision will not be as disruptive to OLED and 4K as we initially thought it would. We were anticipating the arrival of Dolby Vision in the Christmas holiday season, perhaps aided by a back room deal to supply ‘newly re-mastered’ versions of film and TV to entice consumers with. But Dolby’s focus on playing the long game means that we will most likely not see this technology disrupt sales of 4K as we had first thought.
Instead HDR will enter the market and living room at about the same pace as 4K, as the technologies are complimentary. However, in the showroom environment, consumers will have difficulty spotting the improvement that the extra resolution provides, while being able to see the benefits of a HDR image. But if both a Full HD and an Ultra HD TV support HDR, that argument is null. For the consumers not looking to spend 4K prices on their new TV, HDR will provide a discernible picture quality improvement that is not hamstrung by the last mile connection to the home.
We expect to begin hearing much more about the HDR ecosystem as Dolby integrates itself further into the supply chain. We also expect direct rivals such as Technicolor to give Dolby a solid run for its money, as well as the proliferation of third party alternatives like the Sony system. In summary, HDR can provide significant increases in picture quality that are disruptive to 4K sales ‘ if 4K ever takes off significantly due to the aforementioned problems with 4K content distribution.