Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 April 2014

UHD is Sony’s last chance saloon for TV

The main Ultra HD TV story is that it is taking off faster than expected causing analysts to revise upwards projections for 2014 volumes, stimulated by a few economic green shoots that may admittedly be snuffed out by global political events. The most interesting sub plot concerns Sony, which is gambling heavily on UHD in a last ditch bid to rescue its long-ailing TV business, which has lost money for 10 years in a row.

The sub plot is connected to the main story in so far that all TV makers, and not just Sony, are looking to UHD displays to boost flagging revenues. The TV industry has experienced two successive years of decline since the 2011 peak of 255 million units shipped worldwide, slumping to 230 million in 2012 and then slipping further to 226 million in 2013, according to NPD DisplaySearch.

The difference is that Sony has nothing to lose by going for broke, since its legacy LCD business was already effectively broken. The only hope for Sony to regain and then maintain a leadership position, if not quite alongside the South Korean duo of Samsung and LG, then at least not far behind, resides in UHD. Meanwhile the other big players can afford to take a more nuanced approach, quite content to let Sony make the early running and break the market in, only to come piling in with lower priced models once consumer momentum has been established.

This is the danger for Sony, that having established a clear early lead in the fledgling UHD TV market it will lack the financial muscle to maintain it and resist what is already a strengthening surge from Samsung and LG. Sony got off to a flying start, commanding 42% of the UHD TV market almost a year ago at the end of Q2 2013, but only 18.2% by the year end. By then Samsung was breathing down its neck at 14.9%, having stood at just 3.8% at the half year mark. Samsung had gained ground on the strength of newly launched 55-inch and 65-inch UHD TVs in the USA and Europe during Q3 2013, roaring on from there to overtake Sony as the number one UHD TV maker in Europe by the end of the year and then catching up in North America early in 2014.

At the same time Sony has said it expects to report a loss of 110 billion yen ($1.1 billion) in the year ending March 31 2014, a huge downward revision on the October 2013 forecast of a 30 billion-yen profit. This provoked a further reorganization, with Chief Executive Officer Kazuo Hirai announcing in February 2014 that 5000 more jobs would be cut, along with a sale of the PC business and partitioning of the TV business into a separate unit. The latter was interpreted by some analysts as a prelude to a complete sell off, but that will only happen if the UHD gambit fails.

Although under pressure, there are a few signs of hope for Sony. One is that at least its Japanese insurance and banking business is profitable even if the Consumer Electronics sectors it is much better known for is not, with the result that investment across the UHD ecosystem can be sustained.

Sony can then draw some encouragement from the accelerating growth of the UHD TV market against the backdrop of declining overall TV sales. Note that surveys still refer to 4K TVs, but this is incorrect as 4K is actually the digital cinema standard, displaying images at native 4096 x 2160 resolution. The resolution adopted by the TV industry is instead 3840 x 2160 pixels. The Consumer Electronics Association announced in 2013 that the technology should be referred to as Ultra HD rather than 4K.

After indicating that 1.9 million UHD TVs were sold during 2013, NPD forecast that this would soar by more than a six fold margin to 12.7 million in 2014 and the signs are now that it could be more than this, perhaps 15 million. This is being driven largely by China, which accounted for 87% of UHD TV sales in 2013 and NPD expects China to still to take 78% of the much larger 2014 total, which could amount to almost 12 million on the basis of our upwardly revised total figure.

This also implies that the rest of the world will account for substantially more UHD TVs in 2014 ‘ around 3 million ‘ than China did in 2013, about 1.5 million. Even so China looks certain to continue being the main engine of the UHD TV market for a few years, still accounting for more than half of total global sales in 2016, according to NPD.

At least Sony made the right call two years ago with its decision to prioritize the BRIC markets for marketing, with some success promoting its brand in China, with the result that it is still taking about 10% of overall TV sales there, based on an average of various surveys, which is ahead of several of the principle indigenous competitors like TCL and only a whisker behind Samsung.

Sony looks like it will settle for ending up with 10% of the global UHD TV market when the dust has settled in a few years’ time, judging by its own recent projections. This included its recent assertion that Sony was on course to quadruple its sales of UHD TV sets this year, without giving numbers but enabling us to calculate them taking the NPD 2013 figures as a baseline. On that basis Sony would increase its UHD sales from 310,000 units at the end of 2013 to 1.24 million this year, which would actually equate to a significant decline in market share in line with current trends, from 18.2% to 9.7% taking NPD’s projections, or only about 8% if our higher figures are right. So that forecast is hardly bullish and seems a realistic assessment of prospects.

Sony’s hope of beating these estimates lies in large part on its latest UHD Bravia TVs, which although still more expensive than some of the Chinese competitors are now quite competitive with an entry price of $2,099 for a 49-inch model, scaling up through $3,000 for a 55-inch to $5,499 for a 70-inch set, and then at the top with upgraded audio and wall mounting, a 79-inch model costs $8,999.

The key may lie in Sony’s investment across the UHD ecosystem to generate content and make it readily available. Sony is alone in offering UHD video projectors, the high-end semiprofessional VPL-VW1100ES and the VPL-VW500ES aimed more at the home cinema. Sony is also due to release an updated version of its 4K media player, the FMP-X10, this summer, with 1TB of storage for downloaded movies from its Video Unlimited store and supporting 4K movies from Netflix across the whole Bravia range.

Sony prepared the ground here by launching the UHD version of Video Unlimited in September 2013, the world’s first video store for UHD movies. This was hardly bargain basement, with video prices typically around $30, although Sony argued this was on a par with Blu-ray titles when they first arrived in the early noughties, pioneered as it happened by Sony.

Equally, Sony Pictures Entertainment has been shooting in UHD format for some time and has been encouraging other film studios and content producers to do the same. The biggest scalp here came by persuading Netflix to produce UHD content and make it available via its streaming service. One of the highlights at the Consumer Electronics show 2014 in Las Vegas this January was the sight of Sony Entertainment president Mike Fasulo welcoming Netflix CEO Reed Hastings on stage to discuss making sure UHD content would be available OTT and assure delegates that bandwidth would not be an issue.

Hastings insisted that Netflix would be able to deliver UHD content reliably with a broadband connection running at 15 Mbps, presumably with the aid of HEVC compression. Lab tests now indicate that this should come down to 11 Mbps with growing experience at optimizing HEVC for UHD content, which will soon be the average downstream bit rate actually achieved across developed nations, as opposed to the much higher advertised headline rates that are really peak levels.

Sony’s main hope then of growth restoring TV profitability lies in these market generation moves in turn driving consumer sales, which so far this year looks like happening to an extent. This reflects overall success by the TV and broadcasting industry as a whole promoting UHD as the next big thing in television and in distancing it from 3D, which failed to gain the traction in the living room that it has in the cinema.

The cause has been aided by impressive displays at exhibitions backed up by plenty of eulogies from a largely compliant media and analyst community. Mileage has even been gained by equating UHD with digital photography and pointing out that the format with 8 million megapixel display is what the majority of cameras are now producing. It is certainly true that TVs, as the largest digital displays in most households, have become widely used for displaying photographs, and these do look much sharper in UHD given the resolution of current digital cameras. Sony has been making use of this in its own marketing, while also promoting its own range of digital cameras, along with its FDR-AX1E UHD camcorder for home movie production, recording in the new XAVC S home format, which is a derivation of the broadcast UHD video XAVC acquisition format.

This comes to the crux of the UHD case, which is about more than just higher resolution. If UHD only delivered 8 megapixels, without any other technical or process improvements at all, it would not succeed and would certainly not be worth the effort of upgrading the whole ecosystem. But UHD is actually a whole package of new technologies, including higher frame rates, greater contrast and a wider color spectrum. The industry is still working out exactly what else to include under the UHD or 4K banner, with results of consumer panels and studies still being evaluated. In one such study the BBC found that higher frame rates, up to 100 fps, had a greater impact on perceived picture quality than the increased resolution of UHD (See elsewhere in this issue our final part of our report on High Dynamic Range TV).

Similarly improved color contrast has been found to have at least as great an impact on overall picture quality as higher resolution. TV makers such as Sony can also point to the improved upscaling technology that will render existing TV content more effectively, so that even normal HD will look better on a UHD screen. This will apply particularly to full HD content at 1080p, which will most likely become more widely available before UHD material does. The improved processing capability of UHD chip sets allows UHD TVs to guestimate detail more accurately when upscaling and this works best of all when the source resolution is still reasonably high, as with full HD at 1920 x 1080 pixels.

We have not even mentioned yet what could be the most significant new technology associated with UHD, which is OLED (Organic Light Emitting Diode). This improves picture quality enormously at a given resolution or number of bits used to represent colors, largely because it is self-emissive rather than relying on backlighting as LCD displays do. This enables OLED to render true blacks and provide great color contrast, with indications that it will deliver such good pictures at full HD resolution that there may be no need even to go to UHD, except for very large screens.

Sony has come slightly late to the OLED party, with Samsung and LG making the early running, but it did succeed in making a splash with a prototype UHD OLED 56-inch TV at CES 2014. Samsung has taken most of the plaudits so far with its KE55S9C curved OLED TV, which was widely hailed as the best direct-view display so far produced, largely because of the ability to render absolute blacks.

But OLED is currently shackled by low yields and resulting high manufacturing costs, with only LG so far succeeding in making panels at any volume. Ironically for LG this has a come at a time when the company is striving to shake off its image as a bargain basement CE company, leading to its 55EA980W OLED TV exhibiting build quality, at least superficially, reminiscent of Apple and premium packaging to match, even though the product is the cheapest OLED TV so far produced, at least outside China.

Forecasts of OLED shipments are highly speculative because they rely in turn on assessments of how quickly the current manufacturing problems can be overcome. Given that low yields also dogged other TV display technologies early on and are still an issue for large screens, it is likely that the problems will be overcome sufficiently and we think sales will rise much faster than typical estimates, which put shipments at 50,000 this year, rising to say 750,000 in 2015, 2 million 2016 and onto 5 million in 2017.

Many sectors would die for such a growth curve, but in the case of OLED it is probably a gross underestimate. For one thing there are signs now that the yield problems will be mitigated if not totally resolved this year, as Chinese makers TCL, Haier and Changhong accelerate their production alongside LG. Such conservative figures also ignore the likely growing impact of composite panel displays, driven precisely by the problems of low yield that are amplified for large screens. Put simply the rejection rate is roughly proportional to the display’s surface area, so that four times as many units are rejected when the screen size as measured by the length of its diagonal, doubles.

The result will be that smaller OLED panels will be used to construct larger displays, in turn reducing the manufacturing cost further, enabling the dramatic increase in quality to shine through. This may even dampen the rate of UHD deployment, even though we can see that for this year it is increasing fast.

That may not be such good news for Sony, having bet its shirt on UHD rather than OLED specifically. Even if Sony does manage to garner 10% of a greatly enlarged UHD market, this may still not be enough to persuade the board to hold on to its increasingly isolated TV division, to concentrate on gaming and smart phones, as well as its financial subsidiary, as a valuable cash cow.

If Sony does sell up and assuming the buyer is not Japanese, that would be the final nail in the coffin of that country’s once all-conquering TV industry.