Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 April 2014

What happens if Aereo wins, or loses for that matter?

There’s not much point in second guessing the US Supreme Court over the Aereo case. The verdict will not be reached until June or July, but the opening arguments have been made this week. It is however perhaps worth pondering the potential outcomes.

There are three potential outcomes. A clarification of the law in favor of Aereo, a clarification against Aereo or a statement that there are enough laws in place to deal with the situation, leaving the lower courts to get on with it.

Most observers reckon that the Supreme Court will side in favor of the broadcasters and one poll put that at close to 80%. But if you had taken such a poll just prior to the previous key cases in content delivery ‘ the Betamax case, that allows private recording of TV programming and the Cablevision case that allows a private copy of a TV broadcast to be recorded on a server in the network ‘ we’d bet that most people just think the status quo will win, so we’re not sure that’s relevant.

What is interesting is that already the Supreme Court judges have made two clear comments, that the way the system was designed was just a way of getting around the law, and that they are uncomfortable making a large legal change in case it prejudices the future for internet systems like cloud computing.

That does little more than set the scene, and if the law is clearly on the side of Aereo, we think there will be no change to the law nor any major precedent set, merely a nuance of guidance. Most cases have been won by Aereo, and this would simply be a guidance that one of these courts, probably the court of appeal, has got it right and the Supreme Court agrees with it. That would be enough.

The outcome is binary. If Aereo does not have to pay to put TV channels on the internet, no matter how it goes about it, then cablecos can adopt the same approach, since they are already part of the internet.

Everyone right now is seeing that as a disaster, but we think not. Broadcast TV has become far more compelling over the past few years, because it has a new formula. It is partly because of what’s happened in the movie industry, which has become global in scope and theme, and which prefers international superstars over US stars, and which also prefers to simplify moral dilemmas to the point where many writers have abandoned the movie industry for TV. This is true of both cable network and broadcast networks, but the Broadcasters have more money to spend per channel and have done a great job ever since the emergence of super series like ’24’ and ‘Desperate Housewives,’ so right now the major TV channels remain ‘essential’ viewing for cable homes.

But outside of the US, all of that type of local content is available over the internet, either in real time, or as catch up within 24 hours, with the exceptions of some live sport, which can be delayed further. This is true in the UK, France and much of Europe, with some special laws preventing it only in one or two countries. The big difference is that many of the quality broadcasters in those countries are owned by the state, and their content is essentially paid for by a tax or annual license fee. So the people own it. These companies feel the need to show it how the people want it.

In the Far East content, like much of Europe, is often dominated by the US, mixed with local content and the root of all piracy is built into the delay between viewings in the US against viewings overseas. The more US broadcasting is placed online, complete with its advertising, the more money that the US channels will be able to charge for the advertising, and they might get a second bite at that revenue outside the US, either sent over the internet directly or via local distributors.

But there will be a period of disruption if the cable companies stop paying immediately, and that could take $billions from current revenues of the broadcasters. Their threat to take their content entirely onto a paid footing is perhaps an idle one, and any attempt to do so risks simply killing them off with an even more abrupt revenue decline. Although, as we can see below, there are hybrids of how this might happen, which might work ‘ combinations of paid and free.

Where contracts are already in place with cable operators, US broadcasters can hold them to the terms, and that might give them time to rebuild their revenues both overseas and inside the US.

But the simplest reaction to a win for Aereo is for the US broadcasters to offer their content paid when delivered to portable devices, over the internet for perhaps $5 per month per device. Overnight Aereo would be bust and so would its rivals and the broadcasters would be richer by a long way, while keeping content free on the TV. The thing that has stopped this is the existence of retransmission fees from cable and if they go, then they are free to do it.

The truth is that the broadcasters had this option two years ago when Aereo came on the scene, and it would be truly radical. There are many people in the US that would prefer not to pay their cable company for content, but cannot get the broadcast content any other way. If the cable retransmission payments go away, then many people would swap the $100 TV payment for cable or DTH, for a $5 or even $5 per broadcast provider (so say $20) delivered over the internet. Unlike the public broadcasters in Europe, they are not mandated to do it for free and Aereo has set the price floor. It would be even better if this was done as a low end reseller license, so that many new Aereos spring up to offer it all in different flavors. It would still have its obligations to reach everyone in the US via broadcasting, but there would be no economic room for an Aereo.

We have already seen CBS go to war with Time Warner Cable, a negotiation that will, one way or another, see the end of TWC through acquisition, because of the bad financial performance the broadcaster blackout caused it. So we know that without broadcaster channels, and local channels, pay TV ARPU will fall dramatically. So in conclusion, far from causing a problem for US broadcasters, allowing Aereo to continue would cause pay TV in the US to have a complete rethink ‘ TV everywhere strategies could be undermined by the removal of free TV from pay TV.

In fact this is really a form of hybrid pay TV, and so perhaps the threats of the broadcasters are not so idle after all. All that needs to happen is for the broadcasters to grasp this opportunity to embarrass the pay TV players, and go direct to portable devices at a price down at the Aereo level.

We accept that this is partly counter-intuitive and also completely against the nature of broadcasters, but it could be done, and it might be done if they are forced into it.

What happens if the Supreme Court simply slams the door in the face of Aereo? Well pretty much the opposite. Without the threat of Aereo it is business as usual. The only way you will be able to get free to air content over the internet on your phone or tablet will be through apps from the broadcasters, which offer incomplete content, as teasers rather than a replacement delivery route. Hulu would be better. The price of free content to pay TV will go at market value, and this will be reflected in the prices charged by pay TV ‘ they will go up, considerably over the next 5 years. The status quo will remain and companies like Netflix will be the rare exceptions which challenge the pay TV players, who will eventually license enough VoD content for their TV Everywhere strategies to slow Netflix down or even kill it.

What that means is the internet will have been made capable of carrying broadcast video by technology and no-one will get rich because of it, except the same companies that were already rich from prior forms of video delivery. At Faultline we view that as very reactionary and bad for competition.

If companies like Apple, Google and Microsoft failed completely to get into the content industry on the back of mobile content and wider internet delivery, then it’s too tough a nut to crack and essentially it is a loosely working oligopoly, close to illegal, and impossible to innovate. The consumer loses and so does the US, because outside of the US, other internet players will become strong on the back of internet content, and at some stage arrive in the US, armed to the teeth with the world’s content.