Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 April 2014

Dutch question future of DTT as KPN gives muted support

The Netherlands is the latest European country to debate the future of DTT and while Telco KPN has insisted that its Digitenne DTT service, complementing its IPTV offering, will continue after 2017, it admitted that it was being used increasingly just for second TVs in homes without a network to connect to the primary service. Post 2017 the Netherlands is likely to lose what was once one of the most successful paid DTT services in the world.

All of this has its roots in the World Radio Spectrum Conference in 2012.
The future of DTT in Europe looked bright until the surprise decision taken at that conference to allocate a second digital dividend to mobile in the 700 MHz band after 2015. Until then the second generation DVB-T2 standard had been enjoying widespread adoption, not just in Europe, but also in other countries, including the whole of Russia, India and Singapore. The standard was widely applauded for its innovation, improving indoor coverage and boosting capacity by around 65%.

But then at WRC 2012 a group of African and Middle Eastern countries conspired to open up the 700 MHz band to mobile services in the spectrum region that includes Africa, Europe and parts of Asia as of 2015. It had been expected that such discussions would take place only after the next WRC in 2015. But instead mobile telecom services will be given at least co-primary status alongside broadcasting in the 694 – 790 MHz band after WRC 2015.

This came as a shock to the EBU (European Broadcasting Union), which has consistently lobbied to avoid any further spectrum concessions following the first digital dividend already agreed in the 800 MHz band. The EBU has more recently had to fight a rearguard action as several countries have started to question the future of DTT. This has been especially the case in Germany, Europe’s largest TV market, where DTT has never really caught on and is only used as a primary service by around 11% of the population. Enthusiasm in the country was knocked by the WRC 12 decision and waned further after commercial broadcaster RTL announced in January 2013 that it would exit the current DTT platform altogether. This was followed by a prediction from Ulrich Reimers, a broadcasting consultant from the Technical University in Braunschweig, that other broadcasters in the country would follow RTL by deserting DTT.

France then decided to launched a joint consultation between its communications ministry DGMIC and media regulator CSA over the future of DTT after a probable reallocation of spectrum in the 700MHz band to mobile operators. The agencies did stress that DTT would continue to play an important role in French broadcasting, but the consultation was an admission that future services would have to exist in a smaller spectral band than had previously been anticipated.

The Netherlands is the latest European country to debate the future of DTT.

KPN confirmed it will continue to offer Digitenne until at least January 31 2017, the date its spectrum licenses expire, with no decision yet taken on the period thereafter. KPN is currently selling Digitenne as an addition to its IPTV service, delivering a bouquet of channels including the main commercial Dutch broadcasters as well as a selection of international content, including VRT, BBC 1 and BBC2, for a monthly subscription of €12.50.

DTT has at least received stronger backing from some other European countries, such as the UK, where the DVB-T2 platform is accessed by more than 3.5 million households as their primary source of TV content, available in HD free to air, with almost total national coverage reached in October 2012. In the Nordic countries several operators still offer pay-DTT services and have helped migrate national DTT platforms from the first-generation DVB-T standard to DVB-T2.

For the next few years at least then DTT will continue to be a major player for TV distribution in Europe. After that it remains to be seen the extent to which DTT will service at least as part of a mix of delivery methods, sustained perhaps by HbbTV which allows it to be integrated with OTT.

Currently HbbTV allows broadcasters and operators to synchronize TV content with informational services and graphics on the screen. There is the potential to go further by enabling full interworking between broadband networks and broadcast transmission, including satellite, cable and IPTV, so that in effect they become interchangeable. This concept has been developed in several projects, such as Dynamic Broadcasting at the University of Braunschweig in Germany. This was developed for DTT, with the idea that content would be delivered via the most suitable medium according to criteria specified by the broadcaster.

It could be that live content watched by many viewers would be delivered via the terrestrial platform, while catch up content could be sent to the user’s local DVR, if there is one, for later viewing in non-real time, or alternatively could be streamed directly via broadband. The broadband connection can also be used to gather data for analytics applications and for access to dynamic service guides responding in real time to user preferences, rights and availability. Dynamic Broadcasting has gained some momentum, so it would be ironic if Germany, the European country least enthusiastic about DTT, actually helped engineer its revival.