Canadian fabless semiconductor company ViXS has filed a patent dispute against several set top suppliers with the US International Trade Commission. Entropic and its customers are the main target of the complaint that was filed on April 17th. ViXS will also seek damages through the federal court.
The companies filed against include Entropic, DirecTV, Wistron Corporation, Wistron NeWeb Corporation and CyberTAN. ViXS named Entropic as the main respondent with the other companies cited for using Entropic components in their products.
The news comes as tiny ViXS posted its Q4 and full year results for the period ending January 31st, in which it made a comprehensive $7.5 million loss on revenues of $7 million in Q4, with full year revenues of $30.4 million with a comprehensive loss of $32.6 million.
The complaint aims to stop the import and sale of a range of products which contain Entropic MoCA chips and other Entropic SoCs. The ITC complaint lists several DirecTV set tops that contain MoCA chips.
ViXS alleges that the companies have ‘engaged in unfair trade practices by the importation, sale for importation, and sale after importation of certain set-top boxes, gateways, bridges, switches, and adapters and components thereof that infringe one or more claims of United States Patents 7,301,900, 7,099,951, 7,200,855 and 7,406,598.’
The ITC complaint document outlines the main ViXS assertion that ‘the patents at issue cover technologies used by such devices to provide associated client devices (mobile devices, TVs, PCs) access to external network sources (internet, satellite TV) and to recorded content from a hard drive.’
Last year Entropic alleged that ViXS infringed on two of its ‘core home networking patents for coaxial broadband networks using multi-carrier modulation and common bit-loading.’ The two patents concerned are numbered 7,295,518 and 7,889,759.
ViXS asserts that Entropic sued for patent infringement while simultaneously claiming that its MoCA patents were essential. ViXS counterclaimed for breach of contract, interference with business relations and unfair competition. It launched a retaliation after Entropic filed suit right in the middle of ViXS’s IPO.
‘With no prior notice from Entropic on this matter, we find the timing of this lawsuit questionable,’ said Sally Daub, President and CEO of ViXS in 2013. ‘We are confident in our technology and will respond with a robust position.’
Evidently, the robust position is this latest ITC complaint, which suggests that Entropic is not playing ball with MoCA despite its assurances that it would license MoCA on FRAND terms ‘ something contradicted by the lawsuits which look like an attempt to keep and assert MoCA as Entropic’s intellectual property.
“We filed our complaint with the US International Trade Commission to stop Entropic from continuing to use our proprietary technology,” said Daub. “We now look forward to presenting our case to the Commission and plan to vigorously pursue the substantial remedies the Commission may issue.”
The Entropic lawsuit reads like an attempt by Entropic to control the MoCA market by pressuring the smaller players with litigation. Entropic has not gone anywhere near Broadcom in case the retaliation saw the chip-giant pressure Entopic with its much larger patent portfolio. STMicro is another large chip vendor that has not been served with MoCA papers by Entropic and put out a release in 2011 that its chips are now MoCA compliant.
ViXS says it has 437 patents issued and pending and that it has shipped over 30 million media processors to date. The most recent product it has launched is the XCodePro 300 family which it claims is ideal for 4K and HEVC content when paired with its XCode 6000 SoC family.
The ViXS XCode6400 SoC, which supports 4K HEVC, 10-bit encoding and RDK compatibility will be demonstrated at next week’s Cable Show in Los Angeles. ViXS has said that it began shipping the SoC in January, which features in Panasonic and NTT-Plala 4K TVs.
That month also saw ViXS partner with Intel to match Intel’s Puma 6 DOCSIS 3.0 gateway chips with the XCode 5106 transcoder. The RDK partnership will also see a reference design that integrates the Puma 6 cable modem with ViXS MoCA 2.0 chips. Intel currently enjoys nearly half the market share for DOCSIS 3.0 gateways.