There is nothing like a crisis to bring out the best in a team, and Time Warner Cable, threatened by the CBS blackout, which in turn dragged down its previous quarter and drove it in to the arms of at first Charter and then Comcast as merger partners, did not want to contemplate another weak quarter.
But essentially despite all the back patting that the quarterly announcement goes in for, it is more or less that same kind of quarter that it had last time, revenues are up 2% instead of 1.7% over this time last year, and TV customers fell 176,000 over this time last year, when last quarter it was 151,000. But Time Warner Cable execs sold that as a win, as the fall from the immediate last quarter was less, 34,000 instead of a decline of 217,000.
In fact the team tried to sell this as lots of wins, best residential subscriber performance in five years with net additions of 148,000; triple play additions of 82,000 the most in 8 quarters and high-speed data net additions of 269,000 best in 5 years.
Interestingly Time Warner Cable now has more broadband lines at 11,358,000 than TV customers now down to 11,163,000. Video revenue has fallen 6.6%, while broadband revenue has risen 10.8% and voice revenue has fallen despite adding 107,000 customers during the period. In all residential service revenue has fallen 1.8%. And net income has fallen from $540 million to $479 million from last quarter to the one immediately past that was seen as so disastrous.
At best we can say that TWC is improving its enterprise residential mix, just in time for it to make a difference to its figures, but again, far too late really.
In its last ‘horrible’ quarter TWC residential revenues fell just 1.2%, while in both quarters business revenue was surging. It looks to us that TWC is being taken over just in time.
By contrast Charter, the ‘minnow’ that was hunting Time Warner Cable before it ran into the arms of big brother Comcast, has video revenues for its quarter up 13.8% to $1.09 billion, and broadband up by 23% to $616 million. Overall revenues are up 14.9%, and with a significant rise in capex led to a minor £37 million net loss, but it still generated $74 million in free cash flow.
It has to be said that these numbers do not include a pro forma calculation given that Charter has acquired Cablevision’s Bresnan Broadband Holdings, but even with that factored in revenues are up 7.5%, with video up 6.3% and broadband up 15.4%. We know which set of management we would want to run any company we had shares in.
We are so used to thinking of the incumbent telcos as badly run, and old, but the Verizon Wireline numbers can be compared directly to these with revenues up (out just after we closed last week) by 6.2% in consumer retail to $3.84 billion on the quarter.
It added 57,000 TV customers in the quarter, way down on last year’s 169,000; and 98,000 FiOS internet customers compared to 188,000 this time last year. Total broadband connections just remained positive for the quarter a little bit similar to AT&T (but with far smaller numbers), with 16,000 net additions, meaning that while 98,000 bought FiOS broadband, some 82,000 cancelled ADSL lines, combining for that 16k increase.
Consumer ARPU jumped considerably to over $120 from $108, on FiOS customers, although this is mostly importing those ADSL broadband lines into the slightly more expensive FiOS fold. Revenues were up 15.5% on FiOS to over $3 billion, making up almost all of the wireline revenue.
As usual the big news was in wireless, which lagged AT&T in net additions significantly and led to a bit of a run on Verizon shares as the results came out, which have since rallied this week.
You get a feeling that the FiOS plan has now played out and that Verizon will need some new initiative, perhaps around vectoring or some other access technology like G.Fast or G.hn, to convert the remainder of its fixed phone lines.