It is hard to read too much into a handful of results, but in Europe it looks like pay TV is holding up the best, out of the four quad play components, with voice continuing to slide and mobile revenues under pressure, while fixed broadband competition is intensifying. These trends are all evident at Orange, formerly France Telecom, as a quad play operator, with its IPTV subs base continuing to grow and declining mobile performance contributing to overall losses.
Clutching at straws perhaps Orange suggested that the worst of the mobile price war that has been raging in France for about two years is over, as indicated by stabilizing profit margins after steady decline since early 2012. Total revenue for Q1 2014 was down 3.8% year-on-year at €9.8 billion, while operating margin was now steady at 30.8%. In France, revenue decline slowed from 6.2% in Q4 2013 to 4.9% in Q1 2014.
The major challenge is strengthening competition in both fixed and mobile broadband in its domestic market, in common with former incumbents in other European countries but particularly so in France. The strategy is surely right, involving quite rapid build out of fiber to underpin fixed broadband and IPTV, coupled with heavy promotion of its LTE plans under the Orange Origami and Sosh brands, folding into a strong multi-play offering combining home broadband with TV and mobile. Orange says its LTE network now covers 58% of the home population, while the number of households covered by its fiber network increased by 47% over the year ending March 31st 2014 to 2.7 million.
In Spain, Orange has 50% of the population covered by LTE and in Poland 29%. In those countries a major challenge lies in building out fixed networks to underpin mobile and TV services, with Orange now seeking a quick fix in Spain to acquire its own capacity, with triple play operator Jazztel a possible target. Orange, along with Vodafone, already has an agreement with Telefonica to access its fiber network, currently reaching 2 million homes, for providing broadband services at wholesale prices set by the regulator CMT. This is actually a reciprocal agreement for mutual access to each other’s networks, but currently favors Orange and Vodafone as they have far less fiber installed. However Vodafone and Orange are collaborating over fiber build out, aiming to pass 6 million buildings by the end of 2017, so it is possible they will both deem no quick fix is needed after all.
Back in France Orange is facing stronger competition in both fixed and mobile services after the merger between SFR and Numericable, but it has a window to consolidate its position before this enlarged company starts firing on all cylinders.
When it comes to pay TV, Orange has been reporting consistent growth in France, with 5.463 million IPTV and satellite customers at the end Q3 2013, up 141,000 on the previous quarter and up by 581,000 on the same period for the prior year. This rose further to 5.619 million by the end of 2013 and on to around 5.7 million now.
In the Netherlands incumbent KPN is also enjoying continued IPTV subs growth, up 62,000 to 1.424 million over Q1 2014, but offset in this case, as in recent quarters, by a decline in its paid DTT service Digitenne, by 35,000 to 556,000. The cause of Digitenne is not helped by KPN raising doubts over its long term future, given a likely continued swing to IPTV. The operator’s total number of TV subscribers across both IPTV and DTT rose 27,000 to 1.98 million during Q1, representing a significant slowdown with the Dutch pay TV market close to saturation, but an increase in pay TV market share from 24% to 26%.
Like Orange the pay TV gains failed to offset declining mobile service revenues, down so steeply that overall net profits slumped 98% year on year to just €3 million in Q1 2014. This mobile malaise is reflected in the lackluster results of Ericsson, whose worse than expected Q1 2014 results was attributed to sluggish performances of the company’s two major mobile broadband coverage projects in North America. Revenues in the quarter declined 9% year over year and 29% over the previous quarter to $7.35 billion.
On the TV front, Ericsson has been engaged in digesting its Mediaroom IPTV platform it acquired from Microsoft and restaging it for OTT. This has involved significant investment given that the software had almost been mothballed during years of stagnation, as Microsoft refocused its TV strategy on its Xbox platform.
In the UK interest has turned to BSkyB amid speculation that its phenomenal run of about 60 consecutive quarters of subs growth might come to an end in its third quarter ending March 31 2014, due to be reported next week. BSkyB has been hiding the tail off in subs growth for its traditional satellite pay TV package by bundling the numbers in with customers of its cheaper online service Now TV, and this will probably save the day for this quarter. It looks like its total subs base will be up around 50,000, but lurking beneath this headline figure will be the first actual loss in satellite TV subs, likely to be something around 10,000. Watch this space, although it may decide not to answer analyst questions on the subject.
Sky is also being squeezed in broadband, where it suffers from the traditional satellite operator’s problem of lacking its own infrastructure and so having to rely on the incumbent, in this case arch rival BT. Sky actually has plenty of its own infrastructure in unbundled DSLAMs of its own, but also takes BT lines on a wholesale basis. Sky actually blamed poor weather for failure to sustain broadband subs growth over the last winter, a sure sign that it is feeling the heat. To make matters worse, there are signs of broadband churn to BT on the back of its enticing sports bundle including the free BT Sport channel to broadband subscribers.