Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 May 2014

Spanish DTT bloodbath caused by government incompetence

Spain is the latest European country to witness DTT channel closures, although in this case caused as much by governmental blunders as by having to pay digital dividends to mobile operators. Pay TV operators are hovering like vultures with enticing multi-play budget offers aimed at hovering up disgruntled DTT customers.

Nine Spanish DTT channels closed down on May 6, Nitro, Xplora , laSexta 3, La 7, La 9, Net TV, Veo TV, AXN and Marca TV, as a result of ineptitude by the government in awarding licenses to these broadcasters four years ago. The decision was enforced by Spain’s Constitutional Court, which ruled that the last bid for DTT licenses in 2010 did not follow correct procedures or competition rules.

The main point was that the spectrum awarded to the broadcasters in 2010 had already been allocated for the country’s spectrum auction for mobile services to be held the following year in July 2011. The government is now obligated to hand this spectrum in the 790 to 862 MHz band covered by the so called first digital dividend to the three successful bidders, Telefonica, Orange and Vodafone, in that auction by 1 January 2015 and faces payments to each of them of around €100,000 a day if it fails to do so.

The government was therefore determined to kick the DTT channels off the airwaves. However the channels are not taking this lying down and have filed an appeal through the broadcasters’ association, UTECA, to be heard in the Constitutional Court later this year. UTECA is arguing that the TV industry has been seriously affected by the collapse of the advertising market due to the economic crisis, with revenues estimated to have fallen by about a third between 2010 and 2013, from €2.47 billion €1.63 billion.

If that appeal is successful, the government could end up being forced to compensate mobile operators, at least until the conclusion of further legal action to clear the spectrum. The reason the DTT channels have stayed on air until now as little as 7 months before the mobile operators were due to take over the airwaves, is the result of a decision by the current Spanish government, elected in November 2011, to stop fully funding the process of clearing the digital dividend frequencies, citing the deepening economic crisis as the reason.

Meanwhile Spanish broadcasters face yet more erosion of their DTT spectrum following the likely decision at the forthcoming WRC (World Radio Conference) 2015 to award a second digital dividend in the 700 MHz band (694 to 806 MHz). The upshot will be confusion for viewers and disruption to the country’s broadcasting market at a time when it is already on the rack, even if there are now signs of a tentative economic recovery.

At the end of 2013, DTT was still the dominant TV platform in Spain accessed by about 75% of primary TV sets, according to research firm IHS, despite closure or switchover to another platform of 10 DTT channels since analog switch-off in April 2010.

The situation is therefore worse for DTT than in Germany, where the platform has never taken hold and accounts for only about 11% of primary TV set viewing. In some respects it is a peculiarly Spanish case, but does also reflect a turning of the tide against DTT in a number of European countries in the face of the mobile onslaught, coupled with a growing conviction that broadcast distribution will all end up over the Internet anyway.

This has prompted the Dutch government to review its DTT strategy, while France is engaged in a joint consultation between its communications ministry DGMIC and media regulator CSA over the future of DTT after a probable reallocation of spectrum in the 700MHz band to mobile operators.
The agencies did stress that DTT would continue to play an important role in French broadcasting, but the consultation was an admission that future services would have to exist in a smaller spectral band than had previously been anticipated. This has led broadcasters TF1 and M6 to shut down TF6, the pair’s joint venture channel on the DTT platform. The DTT bouquet of which this channel is a part only has about 400,000 subscribers, while costing about €4 million to distribute, highlighting the economic challenge for DTT in distributing less popular channels.

Meanwhile back in Spain, just about all the pay TV operators, including Canal Plus, Movistar TV, Orange TV and ONO, have launched competitively priced multiplay offers including TV to capture DTT subscribers. Telefonica is offering its Movistar Fusion IPTV package with broadband Internet access, telephony and 80 TV channels thrown in for €60 a month. These operators see the DTT closures as good news since pay TV penetration is much lower in Spain at 23%, than most other European countries and there is scope for gains despite the poor state of the economy, at the right prices.
The nine DTT channels just closed accounted for an average audience of 6.7% between them, which is about 1.1 million households.