Comcast and EA are working on a service to allow X1 users to buy and play EA games through the set top, according to reports. There has been no confirmation of whether the set top will render the game locally or if the service will be cloud-rendered and streamed to the set top, but both options are possible on the X1 platform.
While the X1 is regarded by many to be one of the most powerful set tops available at the moment, it is a long way away from rivalling the current generation of consoles. As such, the games will have to be developed to match the hardware capabilities of the X1 platform, or it will be a cloud-gaming service, much like Gaikai or OnLive, to be able to play the latest and most demanding games.
The Comcast system has been in development for two years and would bring flagship titles like FIFA (soccer) and Madden (American Football) as well as more casual affairs like Monopoly and Plants vs. Zombies into many of Comcast’s 22 million cable homes. It is believed that Comcast and EA will start with these casual games before moving towards more involved action titles.
The deal looks like a play against Sony and Microsoft’s entrenched positions in the games console markets and the living room, but also as a value-add service to retain or attract pay TV customers. It also parallels Amazon’s decisions to emphasize the gaming power of its Fire TV net top as a selling point at launch.
EA already has its Origin store and DRM system in place for Comcast to use, and Comcast has a lot of experience in turning set tops into storefronts. Expanding the existing video purchasing systems to cater for the games should only require a software update ‘ and Comcast is already in the process of remotely upgrading X1 boxes to a new version of its full screen UI. A gaming update would be supplied in the same fashion.
The current games available on the X1 set top can be controlled using the remote control or via an iOS app and touchscreen. The controller functionality is already used by EA to let users play EA’s iOS games on the set top, with the picture displayed on the television, the set top acting as a console, and the iOS device acting as the controller. The key difference with the new deal will see the set top act as a store and library rather than the iOS device.
Pace was the initial supplier of the XG1 Xfinity set tops, with Arris-Motorola becoming the second supplier. Under the bonnet, the X1 set tops and XG1 gateways can’t match the likes of the PS4 and the Xbox One. Both companies supply the set tops to Comcast as white label products.
The XG1 uses an Intel Puma 6 for its DOCSIS needs and an Atom CE 4200 SoC. When launched, it represented an industry leading 3000+ DMIPS processor supported by 256MB of Flash and 1GB of SDRAM.
Both the PS4 and Xbox One use variants of an 8-core AMD Jaguar APU paired with 8GBs of RAM ‘ a much more powerful system. The Atom is a low-power chip designed for devices that need long battery lives, and it can’t go toe to toe with the newest consoles.
But the platform could be used for playing last generation titles and other mobile games on the set top. In fact, the argument can be made that anyone with a serious interest in gaming would already have a dedicated system to play on and would not be interested in using a set top as their main gaming device. Therefore the X1 would only need to be able to run the less rigorous demands of the more casual titles, as it would inherently be a casual platform.
This is also going to factor into Comcast’s decision about supplying a controller for the set top or continuing to use the touchscreen of a mobile device for input. Touchscreens don’t lend themselves to accuracy, which is very important for fast-paced gaming. If we see a Comcast controller announcement, we anticipate a move from simple and locally hosted casual games to cloud-rendered and cloud-streamed contemporary and flagship videogames that would directly rival the consoles. If a controller is launched, it will signal a serious play by the cableco, as you don’t need dedicated controllers to play Plants vs. Zombies ‘ but you do for the best-selling fast-paced shooters such as Call of Duty and Halo.
If Comcast can successfully implement a cloud-gaming system, much like OnLive or the Gaikai system that Sony purchased, Comcast’s X1 could become the biggest deployed gaming platform overnight. The PS4 has sold over 7 million units worldwide, while Microsoft will only confirm that 5 million Xbox Ones have been shipped to retailers. Each console has a US deployment somewhere between 1 and 2 million units.
Games Industry International predicts that Sony will sell 51 million units globally by 2015, with Microsoft potentially unbundling the Kinect unit from the system to compete at Sony’s $100 cheaper price point.
Both consoles and set tops appear to be converging. Gone are the days where a games console was exclusively used to play video games. Now they are frequently used to consume OTT content, with the PS3 being the device responsible for serving the most Netflix viewers globally and the Xbox One launched and marketed as a capable home media center.
Set tops have not had the expensive gaming hardware built into them in the past because they significantly increase the bill of materials. Sony and Microsoft have sold their consoles below-cost and recoup the losses through sales of games. This has not been an option for the pay TV operators, but it looks like this could be slowly changing if the Comcast experiment is successful. Cloud gaming shifts the hardware expense from the premises to the data center, which is a more manageable implementation.
However, if Comcast and EA are looking to process and stream games to set tops from the cloud, it would require a massive amount of infrastructure investment in order to cater for the potential demand. This expense is dependent on the hardware requirements of the video games, with newer titles being the most potentially processor intensive games to run in cloud instances.
Given Comcast’s reluctance to invest in the last mile upgrades that could significantly increase its customers internet connection speeds and latency, it seems unlikely that Comcast is aiming to provide the bleeding edge of gaming to its customers, due to the cost of buying and running the servers needed to power the service and the need to guarantee extremely low latency connections to make the games playable. This is the company that publicly blames Netflix for crippling its broadband network at peak times (and then signs a cash deal to make the problem go away overnight).
As the largest pay TV operator in America and the largest video game publisher have each held the Consumerist’s Worst Company in America award for the past 3 years, they will have to overcome a lot of engrained consumer hostility in launching this service.
The gaming press will be quick to pour scorn over the duo if the service is expensive, slow or unplayable due to high latency connections. If Comcast wants to supply blockbuster gaming titles to its customers, it must be able to provide ultra-low latency connections to the cloud-servers that the games are run on or enough power on the set top box, so they do not appear slow.
Comcast has never been loved by the American public, but EA has drawn a lot of criticism in recent years for mothballing popular developer studios and forcing unpopular micro transactions into games. It’s bungled and unapologetic launch of SimCity combined always-on DRM and mandatory internet connection requirements, and was seen by many to be the final straw in EA’s slowly worsening public relations.
A successful deployment of a rival gaming service to the consoles could be extremely popular and could win over the younger generations of consumers who have never bought a pay TV subscription. Comcast might be able to reverse its falling pay TV subscriber numbers without fudging the numbers, as we saw last week.