Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 May 2014

Movie pirates are richer and open to persuasion

People who illegally download movies are more open to paying for legal alternatives than their music counterparts and more susceptible to persuasion that their activities harm the media content industry.

This has emerged from a survey of consumer attitudes to consumption of pirated music and movie content conducted at Portsmouth University in the UK and published in the Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics. The study found that consumers of pirated movie content were willing to pay for premium material or early release movies and also were likely to attend cinemas. This highlights the importance of protecting premium high resolution content, particularly as OTT operators such as Netflix start distributing increasingly in UHD with correspondingly greater scope for copying and redistribution of high quality material. The study also noted that access to early release material was also a motive for movie pirates.

The research will be studied with interest within the media production and security industry because it is the first substantial one to compare and contrast consumer attitudes between movie and music piracy. This comes at a time when the cost of movie piracy has overtaken that of music piracy, in the US at least, according to many counts. Estimates vary wildly, but a consensus figure is that movie piracy costs around $20 billion annually in lost sales in the US, compared with $12.5 billion for music. It may well be that the figures even out in the rest of the world, where there is less consumption of Hollywood blockbusters.

The piracy study does have some flaws, the biggest being that it was conducted only in Finland, where attitudes may not be representative even of the rest of Europe. It was based on data available from the Helsinki Institute of Information Technology from a sample of over 6000 people aged seven to 84, examining attitudes to movie and music pirates and piracy. This comes to the second flaw, which is that there was not a clear distinction between those who had engaged only in music downloading, those who had only pirated movies and those doing both. This makes it hard to assert whether movie and music pirates are a different breed, as the authors have suggested, or merely whether we are talking about the same people having different attitudes to each.

One of the co-authors, Professor Alan Collins, an economist at Portsmouth university, confirmed that the sample included people who downloaded both pirated movies and music and that it was evident their attitudes to each were different. This seemed to reflect a general distinction between music and movie piracy, with many people regarding the former as fair game but with some concern that the latter could jeopardize the continued production of high quality or high budget movies. The other author Joe Cox, also from Portsmouth University, added that the analysis controlled for the fact some had pirated nothing at all, some had pirated only music or movies and some had pirated both types of media. But the results would have been more valuable if these four categories were broken out separately within the analysis.

It is also misleading to suggest that because movie pirates tend to go to the cinema they are spending more than their music counterparts, because it ignores attendance at live music concerts. When online music piracy first emerged to threaten the long established recording industry in the late 1990s, one of the benefits touted was that it would force musicians to do more tours and live performances in order to earn a living and there is no doubt this has happened. A notable example was that of Canadian folk singer/songwriter Leonard Cohen, who was forced back onto the road for a world tour between 2008 and 2010 after having been defrauded of $5 million by his former partner. A decade earlier it might have been easier to make the money by recording a new album of songs.

Be that as it may, the Portsmouth University study does contain some valuable insights, the principle one being that movie piracy is a more complex and nuanced issue, with quality of content playing a bigger role than in the case of music. The study found that those who illegally download large quantities of movie files are richer than their music counterparts on average and less likely to cut back their spending on legal movies compared to those who steal music. They are more likely to be male and less likely to think they will be caught. The authors also claim that the study confirms that piracy is not limited to the US and UK markets and that behaviors and attitudes are similar worldwide, presumably taking account of previous research, although it would have been better of the survey had been internationally based before drawing this conclusion.

The finding that heavy movie downloaders are more willing to pay for legal alternatives and are deterred to a greater extent by an awareness of negative effects of piracy upon the movie industry does provide some hope for the content industry. There is also a lesson here from the music business, which was fatally slow to come up with online legal alternatives, for despite the success of iTunes it came along too late to prevent the decimation of the recording industry as it had existed for over half a century.

In the case of video there is scope for tiered quality levels, for as the Portsmouth University study indicates, the same people who download illegal movies are also willing to pay for even earlier release and higher resolutions, as well as attending cinemas. This highlights the need for a new generation of content protection mechanisms to tackle redistribution of high resolution content, with a refocusing away from traditional encryption based Conditional Access to protect revenues by preventing unauthorized access, to being able to take rapid action against pirated streams.

Digital watermarking and fingerprinting are widely considered to provide the basis for tackling content redistribution by providing the means to identify where streams originated at various stages of distribution, but on their own they are merely promising technologies. The requirement will be for intelligent analysis based on data analytics operating in near real time to enable streams to be identified and then almost immediately shut down where they are illegal. The basis for such identification will either be information gained about a particular stream, or most likely pattern analysis to unearth unusual activity indicating that a fraud has taken place. This could for example be a particular device locked permanently into a specific premium sports channel say, which would hardly be typical viewing behavior.