Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 May 2014

Operators support UHD but will viewers spot the difference?

The number of pay TV operators putting their full weight behind UHD continues to grow, with Netflix now streaming the second season of its original drama House of Cards and several nature films in the format, while Sky Deutschland has just carried out a test transmission of a Bundesliga football match in UHD over satellite. Both operators contend that widespread commercial UHD services will follow within a few years.

‘By successfully broadcasting a complete Bundesliga match live in what was a true end-to-end test of the full Ultra HD production chain, it is clear that the day is getting closer when it will be possible to bring a top quality Ultra HD live sports production into consumers’ living rooms,’ said Sky Deutschland’s CEO Brian Sullivan.

Sky Deutschland broadcast the Bundesliga match, between Bayern Munich and Werder Bremen, via an Astra satellite at 50 fps using the High Efficiency Video Codec (HEVC) compression algorithm. Six UHD cameras were used and another four HDTV cameras had their signals upconverted to UHD.

Netflix is transmitting its UHD content at the even higher frame rate of 60 per second, along with 10 bit color, having decided that these are both essential requirements for delivering the full quality. The result is that Netflix recommends a minimum bit rate of 15.6 Mbps to provide sufficient headroom, which is more than many broadband services can yet deliver. For that reason, as well as because it will take some time for the ecosystem to evolve sufficiently, Netflix predicts it will be five years before UHD transmission becomes mainstream.

It is likely that the required bit rate for UHD will come down considerably, to around 11 Mbps, with growing experience tweaking HEVC. On the other hand some broadcasters believe that still higher frame rates will be required for faster moving sports action, perhaps 120 fps, and that will bring the minimum bit rate back up again.

There is also the question of whether viewers will notice the difference compared with full HD at 1080p when watching TV in their living rooms, as opposed to demonstrations at exhibitions. This is because viewers will have to be uncomfortably close to big screens for full HD to start looking noticeably inferior to UHD. The point is that viewers have to be ever closer to the screen relative to its size as the resolution increases in order for perceived quality to start deteriorating.

At standard definition it is about seven times further from the TV than its screen height, but this comes down to three times for full HD and only 1.5 times for UHD, which is means that any closer and it becomes like sitting in the front row of a cinema. Following the action across the screen then becomes uncomfortable, relying increasingly on peripheral vision, which defeats the object of having high quality. For this reason it may still be that full HD, allied to higher frame rates and greater color depth, will deliver as good a viewing quality as anybody wants, irrespective of the screen size. On that basis there would be no justification at all for going further to 8K to double the number of pixels in each direction yet again, unless new use cases emerge, such as zooming in on selected portions of the picture.