Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 May 2014

FCC net neutrality rules divides US freedom advocates

The net neutrality proposals released by the FCC for four months of public comment have been compared unfavourably by Internet freedom advocates with similar rules issued last month by the European Parliament. Yet both appear to offer some wriggle room to ISPs, although in different ways. Only two years ago the US was heralded as the champion of a free and open Internet, while Europe was accused of dragging its feet, but superficially at least the roles have been reversed. The key differences are in the realm of traffic management and specialized services, with Europe offering concessions for the latter and the FCC for the former.

There is now universal agreement that ISPs should be prohibited from selectively blocking traffic for commercial reasons, for example to hold back a specific service such as a messaging app or OTT video, that competes with one provided by the ISP itself or an affiliate. But the FCC is proposing that broadband operators should be allowed to engage in ‘commercially reasonable traffic management.’ This was seized on by privacy advocates as being too open ended, since ‘commercially reasonable’ could be deemed to include some throttling say of a third party app that appeared to be hogging too much bandwidth to the detriment of other services.

The EU had taken a tougher line here by appearing to outlaw traffic engineering altogether in its legislation that is further down the road than the US equivalent, awaiting final approval from the European Parliament this summer. But some regulators of individual EU member states have adopted the FCC line, with the UK’s Ofcom going further still by urging the EU to think again and definitely allow ISPs to engage in traffic management when this might benefit the end user, rather than just inviting comment. Ofcom’s Chief Executive Ed Richards even argued that such prohibition of traffic management would be self-defeating and end up having the opposite of the desired effect, by encouraging “the pursuit of time-consuming and self-interested litigation” on the part of service providers and content owners, rather than the intended goal of ‘exercising reasonable, objective judgement.’

It looks like what Richards has in mind is the ability to prioritize real time traffic such as video where appropriate, while perhaps holding back messaging apps or email, which would not contravene the spirit of net neutrality. This echoes very much the US debate, which is pitting economic against civil libertarians. Economic libertarians, which tend to hail from the Republican right wing in the US, contend that any government interference regulating the Internet would be counterproductive and dampen innovation, opposing the free spirit of commercial enterprise. Civil libertarians counter that the spirit of the free Internet can be upheld only by regulating ISPs like utilities, holding them to account as gatekeepers of everyone’s equal portal to the web.

Both positions in their pure form are unattainable, since for example ISPs are not delivering a single utility like a unit of energy. Data is more like the molecules from which the utility is made rather than the utility itself, since it can constitute video or a text email message, which are totally different. This has been tacitly acknowledged in the European proposals, which allow for provision of specialized services that do not interfere with general Internet access. There is a precedent here in services such as Virgin Media’s Tivo offering in the UK, which combines broadcast channels with access to selected OTT content such as YouTube via a ring fenced portion of the broadband access circuit, so that it does not contend with general Internet access for a given household. The term ‘through the middle’ was coined to describe such services that go over portioned broadband bandwidth, in contrast with over the top when they contend with other Internet traffic over somebody else’s network.

In a strict sense this is splitting hairs, since by reserving bandwidth for a specialized service there is, by definition, less to go around for the rest. The emerging principle seems to be that it is OK to reserve bandwidth for a specialized service, providing all other services suffer equally and also providing there is still plenty of capacity to go round. This holds for Virgin Media, which recently overtook BT to regain the country’s number one spot for average access bit rate, but is not always the case.

In this case though the reserved bandwidth is being apportioned to a range of OTT services and so has not provoked controversy. The concept of ring fencing bandwidth becomes contentious when applied to a specific third party that is actually paying money for the privilege. The elephant in the room here are the recent interconnection agreements between Netflix and both Comcast and Verizon. Under these deals Netflix pays for a direct connection to the relevant access networks. These do not directly contravene net neutrality because Netflix traffic is not prioritized over the ISPs’ connections to consumers’ homes. However they do allow Netflix traffic to bypass congestion at the interconnection points between ISPs and CDN or transit providers such as Cogent and Level 3.

The message here is that the net neutrality issue is not just about the access network, but percolates right back to the Internet core. Increasingly OTT providers like Netflix will not have to worry about access bandwidth, at least over fixed broadband, with the bottleneck retreating upstream to network peering points. After all Netflix said its average bit rate to Comcast customers increased by 65% to 2.5 Mbps as a result of that interconnection agreement.

This is interesting in that Netflix is now biting the mouth it is feeding, by criticising its agreement with Comcast and arguing that the FCC should step in to ban the very payments it is making to such ISPs. But this would involve the FCC stepping in to regulate not just ISPs but the whole CDN and peering market involved in end to end Internet connectivity. This could be the logical end game for net neutrality and may be the only way to resolve the contradictions and inconsistencies currently blocking the road to a free and open Internet.