Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 May 2014

Belgian court throws doubt on Telenet 800k sub deal for Interkabel

The Belgian Council of State, more or less the Supreme Court for Belgium for administrative Justice, has rejected the procedure in which Interkabel transferred around 800,000 TV subscribers to Telenet back in 2008.

This is a particularly disruptive intervention that may shoot something of a hole in Liberty Global’s plans for Belgium.

The move places in doubt the eventual ownership of 800,000 out of almost 2.1 million cable homes that are owned by Liberty Global there. It also makes a big difference to the takeover talks that are being pursued by Liberty Global for the remaining part of Telenet it doesn’t own. That transaction foundered on a precise pricing formula and such a formula would be thrown into complete confusion by the current decision.

As of now this does not mean that the merger has to be unraveled. What happened is that quite reasonably by 2008 standards a cluster of municipalities which operated together as Interkabel, began negotiating exclusively with Liberty Global. Belgacom asserted at the time that this was illegal given that they were publicly owned and therefore should have gone out to open tender. At the time Liberty Global’s Telenet was the only other cable company around, and back then it would be unlikely that the only other cable operator, Voo, would have been in a fit enough state to match the asking price, so an open tender would probably have resulted in the same outcome.

But five years on people are aware of the value of broadband connectivity, especially when it is fronted by WiFi, and how cellular, telcos and cable companies are now all seen as equivalents and are being merged together (for instance Vodafone in its dealings across Europe). Given that Liberty Global and Voo are in the middle of rolling out a collective of 1 million homespots, which might front a WiFi first mobile service, Belgacom could easily be induced to bid for these assets, if they were to go back to a tender, in order to minimize the potential erosion to Belgacom.

It is now down to Belgacom, the original complainant, to take further civil proceedings that could result in the deal being annulled, it would also be able to claim damages to its own business, and potentially offset those damages against any bid it might make. Telenet’s mobile operations were at the heart of its disagreement of its value with Liberty Global, and since it has introduced a service called Triiing, an App which charges your WiFi made calls at the same rate as your landline and puts them on your landline bill. Many of these calls are then free depending upon which package you are on. It is the equivalent of Skype, but controlled by Telenet.

If you add to that the idea of Homespots which is very advanced in Belgium, and began at Telenet, where home WiFi on its 1.5 million broadband lines is in the process of being converted into about 600,000 hotspots, then suddenly most cellular calls in Belgium could be made over WiFi. That gives Telenet an extremely disruptive mobile phone strategy that may cost callers virtually nothing in monthly charges. Not only would it pick up all the new customers, but it would force churn at other cellular operators. Belgacom is the market leader with its Optimus cellular operation with about a 45% market share and will be heavily disrupted by such a service. Last quarter Optimus lost 12% in cellular revenues and its profits went down. The other cellular operators in that market are owned by Orange and KPN.

Telenet and Liberty Global recently got into a spat about how much it should cost for Liberty to buy the rest of the company. It refused to lift its price beyond €35 and ended up just gaining a few percent, and it now owns 58.4% of Telenet. Funnily enough the disagreement was over the value of its fledgling cellular customer base which has now risen to 779,000 subscribers, up 25% on the year and adding 29,300 subscribers during the latest quarter.