Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 May 2014

The desecration of French cellular is our future

WiFi offload is a bit like global warming. People want to argue that it is not happening until it is too late. In France it is starting to look like it’s too late. This week regulator Arcep showed that cellular revenues had fallen 27.2% in metropolitan areas of France, with retail payments down 14% in 2012, but the unravelling of France Telecom payments from Orange added a further 13% to that, given that now they are fully merged, there is no artificial wholesale payment from one to the other. In 2012 the price fall was 11.4% for metropolitan residential mobile revenue.

The entire process comes at a time when demand for both data and voice are escalating and is caused directly by the arrival of Free into the mobile market, which offers pricing as low as a few Euros a month for a new mobile connection, and has used this pricing to amass over 7 million customers in just a few years. Free can only afford this by seamlessly offloading over 70% of all data traffic to its Homespot network of 5 million WiFi homes.

For anyone that wants to continue to ignore the effect of offload, then by all means please bury your head in the sand right now. Cellular operators are among these, continuing to spend on conventional 3GPP solutions, which limit hardware and software spend among a small group of specialists players such as Ericsson, Alcatel Lucent, Nokia Siemens Networks and Huawei. It is this activity that is driving up capex at a time when revenues are either already in free fall or about to enter free fall.

Some more details from the French experience give us some idea of what the rest of the world has ahead of it. A real income decline over two years of 25.4% in metropolitan areas (the effects of the wholesale pricing change at Orange being ignored); a fall in employment from 156,000 in 1998 in the mobile industry to 125,000 now; fixed telephone traffic fell 10% in 2013, SMS rose by 10 billion messages and data by 63% and mobile calls rose by 18 billion minutes in 2013.

Arcep talked about the total amount of internet traffic going up slightly, but it is sliding from fixed lines to mobile as internet lines grew to 24.9 million of which 22.5 million were ADSL with the number of subscriptions in VDSL2 up by 450,000 a 27.9 % rise and fiber subscriptions up 72.2% adding 234,000 additional fiber subscriptions.

But of course the more fixed lines there are, the more potential for more access points and each of these fixed lines is likely to be terminated in WiFi, and where an operator provides this, they are likely now to offer a second SSID to make each one a Homespot. And the more Homespots there are in France, the more data that phones and tablets can use, without touching the cellular network.

There was an overall increase in mobile phone accounts of 5% and a 4% increase in both broadband and superfast broadband subscriptions.

The change in mobile revenue across all of France, not just the metropolitan regions were rises of 1.3% in 2009 and 2.9% in 2010, followed by falls of 2.6%, 7.6% and 14% since, so some 24% off its high in 2010, so you can see that the last two years have seen massive acceleration.

What each market needs in order to experience the same amount of disruption is one or more fixed line operators embracing Homespots and coming out with a WiFi first cellular service. This is happening across the US, in the Netherlands, and Belgium, and is likely to extend to Germany, Spain and the UK shortly, with other European countries likely to follow, but which have not yet announced clear moves.

As soon as a household name operator offers such a service, cellular prices will fall and the entire cellular eco-system will suffer a prolonged and immediate Capex challenge. Initially mobile operators will respond by committing to more capex, as happened in France during 2012, but as it becomes obvious that this has too little effect, cellular operators will mimic the WiFi offload practices of the leading disruptor. It is this emulation of Free’s strategy that has led to the massive market falls in France.

This is why we felt in Faultline that the French regulator would have no problem allowing the reduction of the number of mobile operator networks from 4 to 3, when Bouygues offered to merge with SFR and sell its network to Free. Vivendi, SFR’s owner had other ideas, but the regulator would have perhaps sighed with relief at such a move.

Revenue for the entire French market for electronic communications operators’ wholesale and retail was €46.6 billion in 2013, just 6.4% less than in 2012. You have to remember this is while there are more fixed line and more mobile sub scribers, who are all increasing their usage considerably. The retail market represented €38 billion of that €46.6 billion.

Operator spending in 2013 was €7.2 billion, and excluding payments for spectrum investment, levels have been consistently above €7 billion for the past three years. Operators’ mobile business accounts for around a third of their capital expenditures, with spending on new generation high-speed mobile (3G and 4G) systems in 2013 estimated at around €1.7 billion.