A decade ago, Google was vocal in the thinking that Wi-Fi hotspots, meshed into dense urban networks, could be a viable alternative to cellular (for data at least ‘ even now, mobile voice really is a step too far). The business case for the much-vaunted ‘muni WiFi’ didn’t really work out, and despite its own build-outs in Silicon Valley, Google did not emerge as a mass-scale hotspot deployer and slayer of cellcos.
But that doesn’t mean it left its old visions behind. The search giant is investing heavily in building networks, mainly in the US and some emerging markets, using fiber, balloons and unlicensed wireless. It does not want to be a traditional network operator, but to showcase a new model which could, it believes, bring ubiquitous broadband access to the world’s population more quickly, and with lower usage fees, than the old cellular approach.
Because it controls the platforms, it can use them as it wishes, showing off ideas such as supporting hundreds of small service providers on an on-demand basis, rather than with static MVNO deals. This is not about broadband revenues for Google, but about encouraging a wireless model that will make its web services available and affordable to everybody, expand its ecosystem, and so drive its core business. Cellular networks will still be important, but increasingly, these new-style systems will be a complement and a spur for changes in regulatory and carrier behavior.
After the muni WiFi bubble burst, WiFi seemed to play a smaller role in Google’s networking initiatives, though it continued to be a powerful lobbyist for new WiFi spectrum such as the TV white spaces. But the WiFi technology has moved on, and is now far better equipped to be part of the alternative network. It has got faster, with the 11ac and 11ad extensions; and it supports seamless integration with cellular networks via Hotspot 2.0, Passpoint and NGH (Next Generation Hotspot). The latter developments help cellcos harness WiFi for themselves, of course, but it also makes it more practical for WiFi-only, or WiFi-first, models to thrive (since any service claiming ubiquity must, at least sometimes, hand off to cellular).
And in many areas, despite the importance of WiFi offload to mobile carriers, it is the non-cellcos which are deploying new generation WiFi to greatest effect. One of the turning points has been the emergence of the homespot, as pioneered by FON. This is a WiFi home router which has two SSIDs, one left open for passers-by to use for broadband access (consumers who agree to this get an incentive such as lower rates or free content). The homespots are a very low cost way for broadband providers to create clouds of coverage and capacity, especially in residential areas where the hotspot model might not make sense. They are being used disruptively by some of the most threatening (to the cellco) providers, such as Comcast in the US ‘ leader of the huge CableWiFi hotspot alliance ‘ Free in France, and many wireline providers like BT in the UK. Some of the homespot enthusiasts, like Deutsche Telekom, Telstra and Free itself, have mobile arms too, but recognize that they can bolster their fixed broadband propositions, and move more cheaply to quad play, if they bet heavily on WiFi.
Building a huge network by offering cheap gear to residents and cheap access to travellers has been proven in the consumer space, as a low cost way to achieve wide area coverage. Google is now reportedly putting a twist on that concept and addressing businesses, offering subsidized WiFi routers in order to create a US network of hundreds of thousands of nodes, which it will manage from the cloud. They will also get low cost or free access provided they join Google’s public network ‘ another example of how the search giant will make its money back via a bigger network for its adverts and applications, not via access fees as in the traditional operator model.
According to GigaOM, Google will use Ruckus’s newly announced cloud-based WLAN controller system (see separate item) to help scale up its business WiFi network quickly. The idea is to build a platform to which any business nationwide (and perhaps beyond the US in future) could connect its WiFi routers, gaining easy deployment and management, and low cost equipment. In effect this would add the small and medium businesses, which are the main target, to the clouds of residential WiFi already being created via the homespot roll-outs, and to public hotspot systems like CableWiFi.
Ruckus’s virtualized system can connect tens of thousands of access points to the same virtual network, which will save Google the complexity of managing many local business WLANs individually. It can also use the platform to deliver cloud-based applications such as advertising and point-of-sale payments in a centralized way, to all the connected access points; and it can sell services such as analytics to the participants. Sources said Google was only working with Ruckus, though other WiFi companies such as Cisco, Ericsson/BelAir, Aerohive and Cloud4Wi also provide cloud-based management (though none of these systems is interoperable). The service will rely heavily on Hotspot 2.0 so that users can log in automatically to any Google access point and can hand off to cellular networks if WiFi is unavailable.
This is just one way that Google hopes to push WiFi to its limits in terms of supporting its core businesses. It is already working in a more traditional way in WiFi service provision, and has replaced AT&T as the WISP for Starbucks coffee shops in the US. It is building free WiFi zones in US public parks and in white spaces spectrum in Africa. It is also active in evolving the technology itself, so that it is able to take advantage of any new unlicensed spectrum which comes available, such as 60GHz ‘ the firm has an experimental licence to test emerging gigabit WiFi and HetNet/small cell technologies on its Mountain View campus, for instance.
Google may have played nice with the cellcos for the past few years, in order to get Android out on the cellular networks and ensure a strong platform for its mobile services. But it clearly still believes it could make even faster progress with a new, open approach to wireless broadband, one which will be driven by web giants like itself, Facebook and Amazon. This is not about killing the cellco, but rather about supplementing their networks, and eventually making them irrelevant.