French encoder maker Ateme has been known for so long as a contribution encoder designer, that its gradual switch to playout encoding has almost been missed by us. But it is one of the few companies that has been able to keep up with the pace set by the software based market leaders Elemental and Envivio, which have done so well in the multiscreen age.
So at Anga last week when we bumped into one of the founders General Manager, Dominique Edelin, we asked how the new direction was working out for Ateme. ‘We grew 50% in 2012, which was exceptional and 20% in 2013. Our growth in 2014 will be well above 20%,’ he said. The company remains under $30 million in revenues, but while it is private and does not give out figures Edelin said, ‘About the same size as Elemental.’
Contracts announced over the past few weeks would suggest he’s right. Ateme has won contracts to provide leading Middle East pay TV provider OSN in Dubai City with a Titan transcoding system for a new VoD service, last week it announced a contribution deal for Satcom’s European fleet of mobile news production vehicles, and N24, a German subsidiary of Axel Springer, said it would be using the system. In April, it has used its Titan encoders to power the first HEVC channel in Korea with Homechoice’s UMAX UHD channel, which goes straight to a smart TV and requires no set top for decoding. Ateme is also demonstrating live tennis in HEVC at the French Tennis Open Championship at Roland Garros with Eutelsat.
In the past Ateme has concluded deals with Directv, BSkyB and Orange in France for OTT encoders.
We ask Edelin about his rivalry with Elemental. ‘We do not have a cloud offer as yet, we are working on it. We have a configuration for live TV, but it cannot yet be deployed in the cloud.’ That presents the company with a problem because some encoder makers have had cloud offerings since 2012 (Media Excel), and Elemental has been keen to show off its new partnership with Ericsson, which now has a cloud controller for encoding, and allows partner encoders to be used alongside its own brand. So while Ericsson is bringing Elemental deals, they can’t yet go to Ateme.
But when we asked how Ateme can keep up with Elemental’s GPU encoding Edelin surprised us, ‘Did you know that Elemental is telling customers that want high quality not to use the GPU implementation. The GPU is great for lots of small calculations, but you have to put the results into memory. As clients move up to HEVC they find there is not enough memory to hold into the reference image, to do calculations like motion estimation. We have decided not to use it.’
Strangely we had just been talking to Greg Zwart, the VP of global services at Elemental and he had mentioned that some clients did not use GPUs in their systems, and we had been confused about why. So perhaps Edelin has a point. Zwart was keen to point out that the companies that went into HEVC first would have an R&D advantage anyway without the need for the GPU power.
Amazon and other cloud services offer GPUs and CPUs separately priced, so there is no need to pay for a GPU and not use it in the cloud.
If that is the case then both Envivio and Ateme, which use general purpose Intel processor, with their current generations based on Ivybridge servers, would be able to fight toe to toe with Elemental, on the CPU.
‘It is all about 4K and HEVC right now in encoders,’ said Edelin, ‘Live 4K is a reality in software only. There are companies that may come out with a 4K capable HEVC ASIC, such as Magnum or Ambarella, and I think NEC might be working on one. The Ericsson chip was really just an FPGA with a sticker on it. But general purpose servers are already doing it and as we move to the cloud, these ASICS will have little traction.’
‘But we are still growing in contribution as well, and we are doing 4K contribution feeds from the World Cup in H.264 in 60 Gbps for broadcasters,’ said Edelin.