There is that great promotional line in the first season of Game of Thrones which goes, ‘In the game of thrones, you either win or you die,’ and never was a truer word said, had it been aimed at the stakes in the converging US telecommunications and network market.
With the news this week leaking out that Softbank has more or less agreed the purchase of T-Mobile, not only will the US mobile market be going through dramatic shape changes , but the entire shape of the digital communications landscape will change, taking in fixed cable and telcos, ISPs and potentially broadcasters and studios.
The drift is towards the converged operator ‘ a large national player that has a wireless network, a fixed network, a national footprint for both large and small video services (4K and portable) and which has a secondary wireless network in WiFi, as well as one that has sufficient scale to acquire both original TV content and sports rights. The race is on to become the first to achieve all of this.
By looking at what each of the surviving operators have to do to achieve this we can perhaps glimpse the future shape of the US digital communications map.
If Comcast is really allowed to close its deal with TWC, the buying power of two major pay TV players will be merged into one, and the same thing will happen with the merger of AT&T and DirecTV, dramatically cutting down the number of options studios have when they look for a home for a TV series or channel. In the US, at least for a while, it will be become a buyers’ market.
This will make for a powerful set of buyers in the sports market too, challenging the traditional pre-eminence of US broadcasters like ESPN, CBS and Fox to gain exclusive access to key sports events. Elsewhere in the world cable and DTH have taken over from broadcasters already, so this is overdue.
Without control over sports rights, broadcast TV channels will lose their edge in content negotiations with pay TV operators, and an inevitable slide could ensue, resulting over time in national broadcasters becoming part of the consolidation picture in the US. Comcast has already acquired NBC, so why would Time Warner, CBS, Disney and Viacom or part of either of them, come into the consolidation picture. Disney owns ESPN and ABC, CBS is a loner cast adrift by Viacom, while Paramount is one of the key assets inside Viacom. There are multiple regional broadcast players too.
At the same time the gap between low end pay TV operators and their larger counterparts will begin to tell, simply because the gap is too large. The larger ones will have the scale to get in first bids for all content, and the muscle to dictate pricing, while the smaller, less leveraged players will get fleeced on price and be left with slim pickings.
The first likely ‘victim’ in this scenario is Dish Networks, which has no partner in the US for a return path for telephony and broadband, and too few assets outside the country (Mexico only) to force its growth to be mainly international. It clearly has spectrum assets, but is not dumb enough to go it alone in building out a national wireless network.
It can launch OTT video services, but is prone to being slowed or taxed at the peering level and potentially squeezed at the access delivery point. Without a fixed line network or access to fixed wireless networks like TD-LTE for instance the Clearwire network that Sprint owns, it can only dream of an LTE Advanced network on its spectrum with the starting price being in the order of $8 billion or $9 billion to get it off the ground and even then with no guarantees of success.
Its proposition is straightforward ‘ it wants to offer the spectrum it holds to someone that already owns a wireless network in the US, and get back privileged rights immediately. Verizon is not offering it a deal and says it does not want to buy it, while AT&T has already chosen its rival DirecTV to do this with. The only remaining games in town have just agreed to merge, so this is now a deal that can only be made at the behest of one man, Masayoshi Son the CEO of Softbank. Dish chairman Charlie Ergen has already tried to end run, and failed at Clearwire and Sprint, as he ‘chanced his arm’ to acquire them from under Masayoshi Son’s nose.
There is a saying in negotiations, ‘The first man to speak, loses,’ and Ergen here has given away how keen he was to partner with Clearwire, and now Masayoshi Son can likely dictate terms. We have no idea of why the Dish share price has remained so buoyant in spite of this obvious position.
The other potential victims of the sudden size advantages of the two merged behemoths are the newly create Spin Co, Charter itself, Cox, and Cablevision, and Brighthouse Networks. A content owner will find itself made when it signs up either Comcast TWC or AT&T DirecTV, and so needs these other smaller deals far less, and can make the negotiations hell and profitable enough to make up for the negotiating leverage that Comcast and AT&T have. Renew a Comcast content deal for 20% less per home, and you simply ask all the others for 20% more.
One of the worst things is that AT&T now has a national Pay TV footprint in DirecTV, which matches its cellular footprint, and extends way beyond its fixed line reach. So it competes with every single one of these tiddlers in pay TV.
Now where it has broadband, or better still U-Verse, as well, AT&T can bundle four services in a fairly irresistible Quad play. Outside of its fixed line footprint it can only bundle mobile and pay TV, unless it partners for WiFi or broadband reach with these other players, or WiFi aggregators like Boingo, or builds out its 2.3 GHz holdings using TD-LTE, to create a cheaper version of Clearwire, with a better brand. That way it could extend a quad play to the entire US footprint, although that would take time and would probably only yield a relatively slow line, perhaps 10 Mbps or so. It could also do this with a variety of spectrum using carrier aggregation in LTE, but it amounts to much the same thing.
The only service offerings right now that can beat this, come from Verizon using FiOS lines or from the incumbent cable player, which has far better DOCSIS 3.0 broadband. But right now in the US Games of Network Thrones, what cable operator really has a proper quad play with a cellular option?
This is like cutting between the scenes in the HBO epic with one woman with dragons on one side of the sea, and a bunch of wildlings North of the Wall, on the other side of the Game of Thrones maps. If they knew and trusted one another, they would be irresistible, but they don’t. And this is true of the new combined Sprint-T-Mobile (Or T-Sprint or whatever you’d call it) and the cable companies. They have tried to partner in the past and nothing much has come of it. In fact, cable has tried to partner with Clearwire on its own, with Sprint on its own, with both of them together and with Verizon, and it’s running out of options.
If you cast the Cable industry collectively as the Daenerys Stormbringer of the story, then WiFi is like her dragons. We know that they will be decisive in the coming battle, but no-one is quite sure how to use them, or that they won’t bite/burn their masters
So Cable seems to have settled for WiFi First as its weapon of choice but it still needs an MNO partner to keep the service fully mobile allowing it to roam outside of a WiFi footprint.
To us it looks like cable will collectively and separately have first dibs at a relationship with Sprint-T-Mobile not because it is more likely to reach an agreement this time around, but because in the long run, Sprint-T-Mobile will at some stage find itself challenged to match WiFi held by both AT&T and Verizon.
At some stage these conservative US telcos will decide to take a rest from heavy capex outlays for cellular, and instead drive prices right down using whatever WiFi they have to hand, offloading mobile to it instead of building further cellular base stations. At that point they can target Sprint-T-Mobile on its own terms, that of price, and go for the jugular.
In our opinion there is little need to do that as yet. AT&T and Verizon still have a few subscriptions to mop up for a few years yet, after which the US market will be saturated. It is generally accepted that a cellular market is not saturated when 100% of its citizens have a mobile phone, but when each citizen has between 1.2 and 1.3 phones. In the US there are just over 327 million phones, in a population approaching 318 million, which means there are another 66 million phone contracts to sell in the US. However once a country gets over 100%, progress slows, which we are now witnessing in the US.
If Sprint-T-Mobile HAS to partner with someone, its new Softbank owners will want to know which partner it will need. On the one hand with cable companies, it has great WiFi coverage for offload, while on the other, Cable doesn’t want an open MVNO, but one where WiFi is the first option, and LTE just fills in the ever decreasing gaps. In that instance Sprint-T-Mobile gets very little of the subscription revenue.
If it was to partner Dish to give it a return path, it could have a far deeper relationship. In the past cable would have said to Sprint-T-Mobile that it was a closer partnership and it would have to be exclusive. In this future scenario, we can’t see how cable can say this. The company it will be dealing with is being asked for far less, and offered far less, and yet that company is suddenly much larger.
Instead the merged entity would likely sweep up any wholesale deals going and cable cannot come along and say ‘We would deal a deal with you, but not if you are planning to do one with Dish,’ which has prevented it in the past.
But if Sprint-T-Mobile is faced with having to find content partners as well, given its weak video offerings in the past, it is better off going to a more sheepish, and disadvantaged Dish and leverage everything it can. In fact a merger would make more sense, because then it could have even more spectrum (it doesn’t need it) and full control of the content business. Given that Dish is controlled by one man, we cannot see this deal being an easy one, and Charlie Ergen is likely to perhaps be his own worst enemy and be unable to swallow the right terms.
Obviously if Sprint-T-Mobile cozys’ up too close to Dish or merges with it, it likely means it would no longer be attractive to cable companies as a partner.
You have to go back to 2007 when the rumor that AT&T would buy DirecTV first emerged, almost before John Malone had got his hands on control of it. And about the same time Clearwire was thought to be destined to partner Dish and possibly DirecTV as well, providing them both with full broadband capacity. At the time cable came along and cut a deal with Sprint for a joint venture called Pivot, and Sprint in turn took control at Clearwire and none of those other deals could happen. Later the Sprint Cable relationship also foundered. So we are still waiting for this cluster of deals to be done some 7 years on. It’s a bit like world war one, when everyone knew who their friends were and who they didn’t like, but were waiting for someone to blow up Duke Ferdinand, before declaring war.
In all of this there is one potential King who is likely to emerge here at some point, and that’s John Malone. It was he that built up TCI Communications which he sold to AT&T, which two years later was sold to Comcast, to create the biggest US gorilla on the cable block. Now he seems to be cashing out once again taking 49% of the payment that AT&T will pay for DirecTV, some $24 billion, and able to re-invest that in making the right kind of deal happen. Perhaps he seems more the Machiavellian Prince than a likely King.
Already he is thought of as the King of content through his Liberty Media holdings, and he controls the second largest cable company in the world in Liberty Global, with most of its operations in Europe, but which might wish to join in on a US Malone adventure, despite not being part of the same organization any longer.
Malone is universally known as Darth Vader, nicknamed that way by Al Gore, for his blunt negotiation skills when he tried to defeat the must carry rules for cable. He is 73 and you’d think that he has enough money, but it is characters like him the have the audacity to think the unthinkable. Not sure how the Darth Vader character fits in with the games of thrones analogy however, perhaps as Tywin Lannister.
If you had to pick out an audacious plan Malone might buy the spectrum from Dish for a premium, use it to leverage a deal at Sprint-T-Mobile, and use his partial ownership at Charter and the money from DirecTV, to round up a few more cable companies to add to Spin Co, which he would acquire too, and then parley all of that into a fixed WiFi network which roams for free with the Comcast TWC WiFi, to support Sprint-T-Mobile. Why not throw in the idea of buying Netflix or better still Hulu, to go OTT. So as we said, he’d be the equivalent off betting on Tywin Lannister in the Game of Thrones. Perhaps a little too obvious.
Throughout this all the usual suspects run – Google Apple, Microsoft, Facebook – but the only one that has shown that it has tendencies to want to own networks is Google. And Google universally wants its technology to make a difference and it would never want to inherit the kind of service culture that bedevils AT&T, or a cable company.