Digital terrestrial broadcasting looked down and out in Germany just 8 months ago, but now it does appear to have a future, following government commitments over spectrum. The country’s leading commercial broadcaster RTL has announced it wants to maintain DTT terrestrial transmission after all and start transmitting its FTA (Free To Air) channels in HD from 2016 over a new national network using the second generation DVB-T2 technology. This came little more than a year after RTL had caused ructions by announcing it was ditching DTT transmission altogether.
RTL’s apparent U-turn is actually quite consistent with its strategy and is the direct result of German politics. There was a national German election in September 2013 and although Chancellor Angela Merkel won an unprecedented 48% of the vote with her centre-right conservative party, she still needed to enter a coalition to form a majority government. After three months of wrangling she finally entered a partnership with the Social Democrats (SPD), but this required several concessions. The headline concession was agreement to instigate a minimum wage of €8.50 an hour starting 2015, but less well reported was a notice of intention to preserve frequencies in the 700 MHz band for broadcast usage during the transition to DVB-T2 from the first generation DVB-T technology.
This made all the difference according to RTL, which immediately announced its attention to reconsider its earlier decision to pull out of DTT broadcasting, followed now almost six months later by the provisional commitment to transmit FTA channels over the medium from 2016.
It all looked very different at the start of 2013 when RTL announced in January that it would cease broadcasting its four currently-available programs via DVB-T from 1 January 2015 at the latest. RTL cited two reasons for this decision, firstly that the commercial viability of classical terrestrial broadcast no longer existed and secondly the fear that in Germany the long-term availability of spectrum was not guaranteed.
The key point is that following the newly elected German’s government’s announcement both those factors have changed. At the time the EBU (European Broadcasting Union) also took a gloomy view of DTT’s future in Germany, with a statement that DVB-T2 was now unlikely to be introduced in Germany and that eventually digital terrestrial would be switched off altogether.
Further negative developments came in Germany, with a presentation in March 2013 from Ulrich Reimers, a leading broadcasting expert and author from the Technical University in Braunschweig. Reimers endorsed RTL’s view that a transition to DVB-T2, which in Germany would not take place until at least 2016, would not make sense, given that consumers would have to purchase new reception devices at a time when they would be obtaining HD quality programming over the Internet. Addressing DVB World, the annual gathering of the DVB standards body, Reimers said it was unlikely that Germany would adopt DVB-T2, the second generation of its digital terrestrial standard, in its present form.
Reimers was supported by MABB, the local media authority of the German federal states Berlin and Brandenburg, in arguing that the Internet would become the most suitable TV distribution platform for Germany. MABB noted that although public broadcaster ARD had earlier committed to DVB-T2 it was already streaming its full 24-hour channels via the Internet at sufficient quality for large TV screens, at least for the growing number of subscribers with adequate broadband connections.
At Faultline we still feel that this underlying trend, where people watch more On Demand content OTT, and where the economic benefits of internet delivery outweigh those of broadcast, will still eventually lead to many broadcasters stopping delivery over the airwaves, but this step means that Germany is now aligned with its surrounding partner countries in Western Europe, rather than leading the charge.
This assumption that DTT broadcasting would cease in Germany had consequences for the development of mobile broadcast distribution in Germany, given that the plan had been to use new features of DVB-T2 for this (DVB-T2 Lite). It meant that the only way of distributing video content to portable and mobile devices would be either through WiFi, 4G cellular networks, or some as yet-to-be-developed technology. Germany appeared to be veering towards the third way with a new technology called Tower Overlay, which operates on top of LTE in effect a way of recreating digital terrestrial transmission, but integrated with unicast cellular delivery.
The story of Tower Overlay is interesting in its own right, having been developed, with Reimers himself playing a key role, at the Technical University in Braunschweig’s Institute for Communications Technology, on the basis that DTT was on the way out, but also reflecting lack of faith in emerging mobile alternatives such as LTE Broadcast. Intriguingly Reimers wrote in a document on Tower Overlay, ‘If Live TV to Tablet PCs and similar devices will be an issue in an era in which classical terrestrial TV no longer exists, we have no technology that has proven that it can take over.’
Reimers then alluded to Cisco’s VNI Mobile study 2013, predicting that in 2017 46% of mobile traffic would be offloaded to WiFi or femtocells. But Reimers was not reassured, expressing his fear that once WiFi offload became widespread congestion, would become an issue there too, especially in the absence of multicast. This led to the Tower Overlay proposal over LTE-A, in which DVB-T2 technology is used, but as a carrier over LTE Networks for delivery of broadcast services. In contrast to LTE Broadcast using eMBMS, which is based on the dense cellular infrastructure, broadcast services would be provided on a dedicated carrier via a tower overlay. ‘The overlay becomes part of the LTE-A network by means of LTE-A carrier aggregation to ensure simultaneous reception of unicast and broadcast services,’ said Reimers.
This was all before the German government’s reaffirmation of support for DVB-T2, which could change everything, although with the caveat that it is not yet a finished deal. The current situation is that RTL’s DTT contract with transmitter network operator Media Broadcast, which would have expired at the end of 2014, has been extended by two years. This means VOX, Super RTL and RTL II as well as n-tv in Berlin will continue to be available via DVB-T in standard definition until the end of 2016.
The key move is that Media Broadcast is now planning to build a nationwide DVB-T2 platform to succeed from the existing first generation infrastructure in 2016 and as a result RTL for the first time believes there is a continuing viable business model for DTT. RTL’s aim is to offer its advertising-funded channels encrypted in HD quality to DTT households over that new DVB-T2 platform.
But the German government has yet to solidify its support for DTT and absolutely guarantee that the spectrum will be available and so RTL is still seeking conditions being met before making a binding commitment.
Similarly commercial TV broadcaster ProSiebenSat.1 has asked for clear political commitment regarding the preservation of the frequencies for broadcast usage rather than handing them over to mobile network operators. However, like public broadcasters ARD and ZDF, ProSiebenSat.1 never followed RTL’s lead and maintained an open stance towards DTT throughout 2013.
In fact if this national DTT network does go ahead it could mean that more Germans will be viewing over DTT than ever before, given that deployment has lagged behind other countries for historical reasons. This dates back to German unification over two decades ago, which resulted in the 18 million people of the former East Germany, the ironically named German Democratic Republic, wanting West-Fernsehen (western television) immediately. Satellite was the only way of making this happen quickly.
As a result satellite and cable between them now serve most of the population with FTA, while DVB-T has not proved cost effective for commercial broadcasters. The upshot is that currently only about 9% of households access broadcasting via DTT in Germany, compared with a European average of 40%, while it is 60% in France and 88% in Italy, according to Digitag, the Digital Terrestrial Television Action Group.
This lack of penetration partly explained RTL’s earlier decision to pull out, but the continuing advance of DVB-T2 elsewhere is one factor behind the change of heart by the government, which now sees DTT as having an important role to play fulfilling obligations for universal access and also perhaps in broadcast to tablets. DVB-T2 increases capacity by 60% through improved statistical multiplexing and Forward Error Correction (FEC), while also mandating use of H.264/MPEG4 and with a roadmap towards the latest generation HEVC (High Efficiency Coding).
This raises another issue, since some countries, including Italy, want to postpone migration to DVB-T2 until the HEVC codec is available. The Italian DGTVi Association for promotion of terrestrial TV in Italy has recommended this, pointing out that it would be much easier and less costly to have a big hit and deploy DVB-T2 and HEVC at the same time, rather than disrupting the market and consumers twice. It is quite likely a similar course will be taken in Germany, assuming the new national DVB-T2 network does go ahead.
Meanwhile, ironically, interest in Tower Overlay is growing elsewhere at a time when it may be subsiding in Germany. The technology was demonstrated at the recent NAB Show 2014 by GatesAir, a provider of digital terrestrial broadcast solutions.