Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 June 2014

French game of Tr’nes almost over

Last week we paralleled the state of the US operator market to the HBO classic TV series, Game of Thrones, but the state of French operators are converging faster even than those in the US, and we are getting close to the cleanup after the war.

Iliad last week was understood to have informally bid for Bouygues, certainly the weakest of the other three cellular players, although still larger than Free and with a better network. Iliad is the owner of Free, which caused most of the French market damage, in that when it got the fourth 4G license it launched a strategy based on WiFi offload that ate 7 million customer contracts in two years, and left holes below the waterline in both Bouygues and SFR, resulting in Vivendi selling control of SFR to cable group Numericable.

So far the bidding for Bouygues is a joke, with Free only interested if it can get it for a song and now Bouygues has reacted in a manner designed to make it clear that it has a plan B, under which it will continue to run its network, and that plan is to lay off over 1,500 staff, in a transformation that is supposed to secure it an independent future.

Prior to the SFR merger with Numericable, the Bouygues management offered to sell its network to Free, if it could buy SFR, effectively crushing the number of cellular operators in France to three, from four. The French government was understood to have told the operators that a drop to three groups was something it could accept. IN the end Vivendi preferred to sell it to Numericable’s investors.

Bouygues Telecom made a loss in the last published quarter, and says the transformation is about developing new uses for the mobile internet, read M2M and IoT; cutting costs so that it can launch aggressively priced packages, all the while strengthening service commitment.

The company has a reputation for service quality, but has no-one ever told it that service quality is at one end of the service scale, and cheap packages are at the other, and the two are more or less incompatible. No-one says that Free has a great network, but with its cheapest packages being €2 a month, not many care.

It says that the first wave will be voluntary redundancies and internal transfers inside the Bouygues group to other companies. Press sources in France have suggested the IT department will lose 33% of its staff, middle management will be thinned out and marketing will lose 65% of its workforce, but there will be no let-up in network investment or retail operations.

Bouygues Telecom has 11 million mobile customers and just 2.1 million fixed broadband customers, mostly businesses, and its network covers 99% of the population of France.

In May Bouygues Telecom lost prepaid and basic plan customers but grew value-added plans driven by 4G. During the past quarter it lost 79,000 customers. But it grew fixed line customers faster than any other operator in France, but then again it has less fixed line customers than anyone the other 3 telcos.

Bouygues therefore has less WiFi installed than any other operator and so cannot use as much WiFi offload in its network as say Free and SFR. There is a cellular networking sharing agreement in prospect between SFR and Bouygues, but every chance that it would be blocked by rivals through the regulator and anyway never come about in the event of a sale. It would be better off doing a WiFi roaming deal with SFR and/or Orange.