Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 June 2014

Aereo crushed by Court verdict ‘ Broadcasters plan next moves

In a fairly straightforward decision, the Supreme Court ruled this week with a 6 to 3 vote, that Aereo does in fact breach TV broadcasters’ copyright, because regardless of the technology it uses to collect and re-distribute those TV channels, it is seen as a public performance. So just like a hotel or bar that puts TV on for the public, it has to pay a license.

Whatever opportunities the precise judgment gives as get outs for Aereo, the idea of using the internet as a rather elongated antenna connection as a way of NOT paying a license, is now dead and buried and will not be revisited in the US.

This is a strange case because outside the US so many countries have high quality broadcasting from their public broadcasters, usually fully or partially government owned. In those countries it has been common practice to put all of their broadcasts on the internet but geo-block them to other countries, and other free to air broadcasters have followed suit, so as to not lose market share, and this has opened up new advertising markets. But the so far resilient US broadcasters have never felt they need to go down this route and have made partial content their preferred option on the internet, and as yet few operations, with the notable exception being Hulu, which broadcasters owned, have been able to license popular full free to air TV channels.

In particular no-one has licensed the more popular TV channels which gain the 4 national broadcasters ‘ ABC, NBC, Fox and CBS ‘ their considerable retransmission fees from the cable TV industry, estimated at $3 billion a year and rising.

This is clearly a setback for both the broadcasters, although they don’t seem to know it, and internet video, but it does not have to be a terminal setback. Each of these broadcasters will perhaps now feel they are more in control of what is placed on the internet and what is not, and they will not feel that their retrans fees are no longer jeopardized.

They may choose to put more of their channels into Apps for viewing over the internet on portable devices, but we would suspect that this will not happen imminently. However failure to do that will leave delivery to the internet of these channels in the hands of those licensees, the major US pay TV organizations.

It has long been a bone of contention and the retransmission fee renegotiations with pay TV players have been spiky to say the least. Broadcasters want to allow internet deliver to their pay TV customers, but not exclusively. Pay TV customer have said fine, license content to Netflix, but not entire TV channels. The reason none of this has happened in other countries is because the US is almost the only country in the world where free to air channels are paid to go on pay TV service, not the other way around.

Video content is going to be consumed over the internet, and by slowing down or rationing the amount of content that broadcasters allow to go that route, they think they are preventing loss of the status quo and keep their options open to charge more to pay TV players. We think that if this had happened 10 years ago, the US public would have left free to air broadcasting in droves, with the exception of local content. Instead there has been something of a renaissance in US broadcast TV, created by a radical change in Hollywood, which has ejected sophisticated writing and US superstars in favor of animated movies with a global appeal. Those writers and stars have migrated to US TV and considerably strengthened free to air TV, pay TV and OTT original content.

But as TV devices begin to be pushed out by tablets, this puts one part of the US TV landscape in danger of missing the OTT boat. Cable and pay TV are making the transition, and so are SVOD services over OTT, but broadcasters no longer have any direct route to multiscreen, except through pay TV operators who pay the retransmission fees or through their in-house Apps, which always offer you partial content and drag you back to the TV.

Expect some changes on the back of this win for broadcasters, as broadcasters digest the win and start to wonder if perhaps they would have preferred a different outcome.