At the WiFi Offload Forum this week in Palo Alto California, many of the presentations were focused not on the issue of WiFi Offload, but more on what you can do with WiFi, that you cannot do with Cellular, and much of that focused on monetization of what is often a free service.
Far from being a slow backwater, the idea of somehow offering WiFi for free in a retail environment has really taken off as a key differentiator for US retail establishments, a shift that has also been happening across Europe, although there it is not so advanced or as intense. And the cluster of companies, from Euclid Analytics, AirTight Networks, Purple WiFi, Wavespot, Cloud4Wi and AisleLabs are all focused on this segment, monetizing WiFi and using it to improve customer engagement.
With perhaps 100 major retail chains in the US and one assessment that only 3 or 4 of them ‘do this right,’ it is not a small opportunity.
One push, by start-up Socifi related to making money out of advertising in return for free wifi and Dusan Zabrodsky, Biz Dev for the company told us that this was a $30 billion opportunity. The idea seems to be that if a retailer wants free WiFi, it installs it and can get back much of what it has spent on it by advertising. But the argument to us was unconvincing, and the rhetoric from the others was more to our liking, focused on improving the business of retailers or site owners with promotions, intelligence and a better customer understanding.
The truth is that cellular operators are too large and cumbersome to care what any individual retailer wants, and we have never come across any instances where analytics data, such as customer routes taken around a store was offered back to a retailer from cellular location data. In fact even where they also offer WiFi and build out WiFi for a store chain, they end up advertising their own brand on your store WiFi and nevere letting you have control of the splash page.
All of which is why Apple has focused on the idea with iBeacons, and in the process has deliberately damaged this small community by preventing stores following iPhone users around a store by using WiFi.
At the launch of iOS 8, Apple said that under the guise of protecting its customers, it would prevent retailers from being able to track iOS users around a store by using their MAC address. In effect it would randomize the address. Of course Apple doesn’t do this to be nice to its customers but to steal the entire business away from anyone else, and so it introduced iBeacons. But far from this meaning that Apple has deliberately ‘knee-capped’ this fledgling industry, it is just another obstacle to get around.
In the end this is a marketing play by Apple. At some point in the process of logging in on existing WiFi systems, authentication has to happen, and at that point an identity can be attached to the session and often that can be traced back to previous sessions. You CAN find out if this person is a regular visitor to the store and you can help them buy more effectively, you just have to jump through hoops to do it.
Some of the analytics data that retailers want is how often individuals visit a store, how frequently they buy when in the store, and anything that influences that decision, like the amount of time they spend in the store. You can get this from the access point identification process and then track behavior. In some instances you can track people right back to their social media and their email address and find what they say they like, and Apple may have a point that this data needs to be anonymized. And anyway a MAC address used to be issued by a phone even when the person has no intention of using WiFi in a store, so perhaps Apple’s interference is warranted.
But already when we spoke to AisleLabs it was already focused on getting to market rapidly with an iBeacons implementation, so it could continue to track iOS devices. Other’s such as Cloud4Wi said that there were plenty of other ways to engage with in-store prospects that randomizing the MAC address does not prevent.
‘The big worry is when the splash page goes away from WiFi, and that’s with the arrival of Hotspot 2.0 networks. Of course companies don’t have to get rid of the splash page, just that it doesn’t have to be there or the consumer,’ said Brodie Kirkeby, VP sales for Cloud4Wi.
And he went on to explain how the sign up page has become the best place currently for retailers to sell their services and communicate with visitors, and how his company leverages that. If you believe that idea of seamless offload which comes with both Hotspot 2.0 and with cellular offload, you would never again have to log into WiFi. And for this fledgling group of cloud software start-ups, that might prove insurmountable .
It all depends on what you believe is happening with WiFi. One speaker at the conference, iPass CEO Evan Kaplan, treated the audience to his vision, a world where even the lowliest hotel can install WiFi and own part of the largest network in the world. We argued about whether there were more cellular modems or more WiFi chips in the world, and Kaplan began saying it was 20 to 1 in favor of WiFi, while we thought it was closer to parity, but when you weigh the evidence the answer is somewhere between the two and WiFi definitely has the edge. We can see that there may be 15 devices in the US home that have WiFi in them, but perhaps 4 smartphones with LTE in them plus perhaps one or two laptop dongles, and this might be the same in Europe, while in India where there is little point in putting a WiFi chip into most phones (because of a lack of broadband) there are perhaps 1 billion cellular modems, and perhaps 100 million WiFi chips.
Whatever the precise truth, in most parts of the world WiFi is the growing network and it’s all around us and consumers are aware of that and need the edges of WifI experience smoothed over. Each hotel has perhaps 80 Access Points, whereas once it may have had just one in the lobby. So the WiFi opportunity is growing and whether or not it is about offload and seamless activity, or WiFi first phone services, it is coming and these smaller cloud based software companies have their place, and may even be the pioneers of what will become a highly rewarding network world.