Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 June 2014

Google unveils Android TV net top, admits defeat for Chromecast?

Google unveiled its Android TV software on a reference design net top at its developer conference this week. With a gaming controller in the mix too, the net top closely resembles Amazon’s new Fire TV. We reported on leaked images and documents that confirmed the Android TV net top back in April and not much has changed in the interim.

The CD-case sized net top is a hybrid device which combines live TV from a DVB-C, DVB-S and DTT broadcast with OTT delivery and the Android apps and Google Play store offerings. Its familiar UI is designed to let users see and choose the content they want to watch. As speed is a priority, predictive software will also move recommendations to the home screen to accelerate this process.

Search features are also prominent, with users being able to put queries to the machine as complex as ‘show me all Oscar-nominated movies from 2002.’ Voice inputs are taken from a phone, as the net top lacks a microphone itself. In a similar manner, the user’s phone is used as the remote control for Android TV, although a dedicated gaming controller can also be used.

The net top also features a prominent focus on gaming, much like Amazon’s Fire TV net top ‘ leaving the Apple TV even more out on a limb in this respect. Android TV has a gaming controller, which closely resembles the scrapped OnLive controller sans media buttons, it was announced that Google Play games will be available on the net top.

We still aren’t convinced that gaming on net tops is going to be a major purchasing decision for consumers except perhaps for Sony, which has the PlayStation games franchise. Google Play games are predominantly casual games, and are hardly the same class as PlayStation, while Amazon at least launched its own gaming studio.

Those who are interested in gaming will for the most part seek dedicated platforms in the guise of consoles or PCs, which also handle OTT content admirably these days, and casual gamers appear to be perfectly happy with apps on their mobile devices.

Of all the recent OTT net top announcements to feature gaming capability prominently, only Sony’s PlayStation TV seems to be a compelling offer for gamers thanks to its extensive catalog of PS1, PS2 and some PS3 games ‘ and that’s only because Sony has done such a poor job of letting gamers play their old games on its newer consoles.

In terms of the hardware, Google said it is working with Sony, TPVision, Phillips and Sharp to design TVs that support Android TV, set to appear in 2015. Gaming peripheral and laptop manufacturer Razer, as well as electronics giant Asus, will develop the net tops with a focus on gaming. This already hints at the problems ahead for Google.

Without a unified deployment Google won’t have complete say over the implementation of Android TV. As the TV partnerships suggest, Android TV is perfectly capable of existing as software only, and as we’ve already noted we don’t see gaming as being a feature that draws people to the ecosystem with any great success. In that light, shifting the burden of hardware costs and sales to companies like Asus and Razer is a smart business move from Google if gaming proves to be a business disaster, but with the platform appearing on so many different pieces of hardware Google runs the risk of diluting the brand or losing control of the software environment.

A criticism often leveled against the Android experience on mobile devices is that there is not a universal Android experience available across all devices. This is largely due to mobile carriers being unwilling to support and push the newest versions of Android, and as Google has not announced anything to suggest that this won’t be an issue with the multitude of vendors associated with Android TV, we think this will be a problem that persists in Android TV as it has in mobile.

And the fractured Google television ecosystem is only further complicated by Chromecast. The support of Android TV and the waning sales figures of Chromecast (which drew no response from Google) are a tacit admission that Google now recognizes Chromecast for what it really is: something of a stocking-filler, a cool and occasionally handy pocket-sized piece of kit for those moments when it was handy to be able to push content to a TV from the Chrome browser or a small number of compatible Android apps.

Here we see Google confirming that Chromecast is categorically not a complete TV offering. How long until it tries to roll the Chromecast functionality into a software-only package and shipping it to OEMs, just as it is with Android TV.