Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

3 July 2014

Aereo cannot take TV to the internet, but perhaps you can

People have all begun worrying this week if perhaps the move put on Aereo last week by the Supreme Court could turn out to be a huge mistake. The logic seems to go that if it is deemed to be a public performance when an antenna takes a legitimate signal, but sends it via the internet, then surely it is also a public performance when a set top takes a legitimate signal and sends it around a home, or when a place shifting device like the Sling Box takes a signal and sends it around the home or to another home.

If you eradicate place shifting and multi-room DVRs from the existing pay TV world it would be a very different place indeed, and the major pay TV operators would be at war with the networks. But remember that most of those changes have been carried out with the agreement of the cable networks, because they have no other existence outside of the pay TV networks.

Can you imagine a discussion with Comcast-TWC or AT&T-DirecTV and a lowly cable network, about not letting them send the signal around their home? All Comcast executives would have to do is say ‘Okay if you won’t let us do that, then we won’t carry it at all’ and the network’s world would cave in.

But with free to air national broadcast TV, that has had an uneasy alliance with cable since the dawn of ‘ well the dawn of cable, it is different. FTA TV has a life of its own, and it has been protected by a variety of rulings which have meant that in the US, and the US alone, pay TV companies spend money with the FTA broadcasters to get their content on their networks, instead of the other way around. It’s funny but for the US, which always collectively chases ‘the least interference from government possible,’ it has had the most interference in protecting its broadcasters.

We might argue that this ruling from the US Supreme Court is another such interference, but we’d like to offer a slightly different take on this. It is not the particular use of technology that makes the Aereo case a matter of a public performance. Instead it is the fact that someone inserts themselves into the delivery equation and makes money from it.

Public performance is just that, taking a legitimate broadcast that is free, but playing it in a public place and charging for it. And in order to do that you must negotiate a license. That public place for Aereo is the internet. We do not think that the US Supreme Court could have found any individual guilty of doing this, if it was done for their own consumption ‘ in other words if you or I took the antenna signal from our TV, and sent it over the internet to ourselves, then how can it be a public performance, since no-one else is involved and no money is made. It is much more similar to the use of a Betamax or VHS tape, you are making a copy, even if it is in real time, and yet you are the person consuming that copy, much like on a VHS tape.

However the VHS tape only got through the Supreme Court on the basis that it had ‘other non-infringing uses,’ when the broadcasters called for the device itself to be banned. And we imagine that a placeshifting device and a whole home DVR like the Hopper and the Joey in the Dish product lineup, also have other, non-infringing uses, not the least of which is the fact that some cable networks have licensed their content precisely for this use.

In placeshifting you are buying a box to perform the same duty ‘ take a signal from an antenna and change it so it can be sent to you over the internet. As long as the device has other non-infringing uses then the device itself cannot be banned. And since the consumer has the right to make copies for his or her own consumption, then who can aruge. That’s what the Sony Betamax decision brought us.

The other test that we are sure made the Supreme Court wary was another unspoken one, which it may or may not have applied on the Beta Max case 30 years ago, which is ‘Will allowing this innovation bankrupt the Broadcasters?’ Whether considered formally or not, it is a huge consideration, because without the broadcasters there is little or nothing to copy.

In the Betamax case the answer was ‘We’re fairly sure it won’t bankrupt them, but it may do harm,’ although in the long run it turned out to be one of the biggest boons to the broadcasting industry in DVD sales.

In this recent Aereo case there was surely even less potential harm about to befall the broadcasters, at least directly. What stood in the way was a consequential outcome, and it all goes back to the Government interference that was initially placed on the broadcast industry back in 1976.

It was at this time that Congress created its compulsory licensing concept, which it amended in 1992. The idea was the local TV companies can have their signal (programming) re-broadcast for nothing by a cable TV company, a move that was later extended to satellite, and that distant free to air broadcasters could have their signal re-transmitted for a regulated royalty fee.

In 1992 this was changed to allow broadcasting companies a chance to negotiate retransmission agreements if they preferred it, something called retransmission consent.

But this left the old laws (Section 111 of the Copyright Act of 1976) in place and it means that today anything defined as a cable company has to carry local stations and may adopt non-local broadcaster signals against a small, hardly meaningful statutory payment.

The concern over Aereo was that retransmission consent agreements would fall to zero, taking about $3 billion out of the annual revenues statements of the large broadcasters. Why should cable companies pay high prices to retransmit the best broadcast channels, when Aereo could re-transmit them for nothing? All that was needed was to agree that the internet was just the same, technically speaking, as a cable TV system, and in this the US Supreme Court has duly obliged, effectively re-classifying internet delivery as a cable service.

We don’t think this is about unintended consequences ‘ and the Supreme Court simply weighed the two options ‘ allow Aereo and the US broadcast industry would be depleted of funds and might eventually die, or don’t allow it and then push the problem back to Congress ‘ if you want to have everyone on the internet pay the statutory copyright fees and re-transmit broadcast content, then leave Section 111 alone, or if you don’t want that to happen, then repeal it. Your choice.

This has immediately triggered a shift by FilmOn and its owner Alki David to declare that it would go down this route. It has already tried this but been prevented on the grounds ‘you are not a cable company’ but now the argument that has sunk Aereo has been that it’s just using a different technology from cable, but to all intents and purposes it IS a cable company. And since FilmOn has more or less the same technology as Aereo, then it too must be a cable company and can pay minimal royalties to distant broadcasters like NBC, Fox, CBS and ABC, and has a must carry obligation to local companies. If Aereo wants to go down this route, it could also choose to, the statutory royalties are not prohibitive.

Could the broadcasters force such companies to adopt retransmission consent? That depends, distant signals cannot be sent out for a statutory royalty if the same programs are available in the local market. So some remote signals could be adopted cheaply, others would need a local tretransmission agreement.

If Aereo and FilmOn get into a fight over re-transmission consent, you might get companies like Comcast insisting that they have the cheapest price of anyone, on either a per home basis or a flat fee basis. And they would insist that if they are going to carry the content, then newcomers (who bring the broadcaster less) should pay an arm and a leg to carry it. FilmOn and Aereo could not survive a retransmission negotiation. But if they want local content, they would have to. But it would make their services about the same price as cable anyway, so defeat the object.

Presumably anyway, the broadcasters will now go to court saying that FilmOn is NOT a cable company, having argued that it and Aereo were the same as cable in one court, they will argue the opposite in another and see no conflict in that.

And we could see this argument rise once again up through the courts all the way to the Supreme Court. We do not think anyone is going to admit that all those years ago the US government should have left well alone and let broadcasters sell what it wants by negotiation and let broadcasters decide who can carry their content, by negotiation and wish they had not interfered. It has put the country out of alignment with the rest of the world, to the advantage of the US broadcasters, which remain powerful forces. On the other hand if it had not happened, US broadcasters may well be moribund by now.

We know that in a few years this argument simply evaporates, a little like the broadcasters who turned ‘en masse’ towards the DVD, having gone to the Supreme Court to kill it. As more and more video is consumed on the tablet and smartphone, everyone will look for help putting their programming on these devices. If the US broadcasters do not make that move, then viewing habits will change, in that they will stop watching what is broadcast and watch something else. As we have said in the past, by partnering only the pay TV companies, broadcasters have made it so that they are bound to the multiscreen strategies of those pay TV players, which may be to their detriment. It is like signing a deal that says that only Sony can put us onto DVDs.

The fact that each retransmission agreement signed this past two years was fractious, involving brinkmanship, suggests that the broadcasters were keeping back the option of being allowed to partner with whomever they liked for over the internet content, so perhaps we will see a change of strategy here.

Repeal of section 111 has been put by a collection of powerful politicians as well as the US Copyright Office in the past ‘ it was created to align the interests of broadcasters and pay TV companies and prevent a war between them some 38 years ago. But we think that it would be a huge undertaking for the US legislature and it has many opponents and it would take more than a few years and a new President to get it through, by which time tablets will have taken over TV almost entirely.

While companies like Fox may reopen cases against Dish Network for things like the Hopper and Joey, we think this will gain short shrift in courts, and the status quo is likely to remain unresolved until tablets make a huge dent in TV viewing, to the point where broadcasters will be knocking on the doors of companies like Aereo and FilmOn saying, would you please help us to market with our own internet TV, by which time it will almost certainly be too late for those smaller companies, but a who raft of new ones will emerge only too willing to help.