Dish has submitted an official ex parte presentation to the FCC expressing its concerns over the Comcast-TWC and the AT&T-DirecTV mergers. It believes they represent ‘serious competitive concerns for the broadband and video marketplaces and therefore should be denied.’ Dish also announced its intention to bid in the upcoming spectrum auctions.
The satellite TV company is actively citing net neutrality concerns as reasons to oppose the Comcast-TWC merger, in saying ‘there do not appear to be any conditions that would remedy the harms that would result from the merger. Among other things, the combined company would have an increased incentive and ability to leverage its control over the broadband pipe to undermine OTT services.’
In terms of the network architecture, Dish notes that ‘Comcast/TWC will have at least three ‘choke points’ in the broadband pipe where it can harm competing video services: the last mile ‘public internet’ channel to the consumer; the interconnection point; and any managed or specialized service channels which can act as high speed lanes and squeeze the capacity of the public internet portion of the pipe.’
This is a sentiment also expressed by Netflix, one of the OTT services that Dish is referring to. Dish says that ‘each choke point provides the ability for the combined company to foreclose the online video offerings of its competitors,’ which we have seen the signs of through the deals Netflix has cut with both Comcast and Verizon.
Comcast and Verizon refused to use Netflix’s own Open Connect CDN despite it being free of charge, unlike rival ISPs Cablevision, Clearwire and Google Fiber ‘ all of which have enjoyed improved average stream speeds according to Netflix’s monthly reports. In contrast, Verizon, Comcast and AT&T’s average Netflix streaming speed all sharply declined in October 2013. What gives the throttling rumors credence is the fact that immediately after signing the interconnection agreement with Netflix in February, Comcast’s average stream speed shot up. We suspect that the recent Netflix-Verizon cease and desist fiasco was an attempt by Netflix to get Verizon’s speeds to do the same, ensuring that Verizon’s end of the grubby deal was upheld.
But while Dish is painting itself as a net neutrality advocate and stalwart of the open internet, we suspect that its main concerns regarding the merger are simply due to the threat that such a large company poses to its content deal negotiating power ‘ as shown by the later sections of the FCC filing.
Dish writes that a combined Comcast/TWC would be able to exercise its enormous size to leverage programming content in anti-competitive ways, forcing the smaller providers such as Dish to pay more for content licensing, as Dish believes this will force the programmers to charge the smaller operators more to make up for the revenue lost due to the bulk negotiating power of Comcast/TWC. Dish holds the same fear for the AT&T and DirecTV merger ‘ and despite SEC filings proving that Dish was preparing to acquire DirecTV itself, we suspect it would not be making the same complaints about scale if AT&T had not beaten it to the punch.
However, the main thrust of Dish’s FCC filing was a complaint to the regulator regarding the upcoming AWS-3 spectrum auction, in which Dish argues that the FCC should allow separate parties to bid on each of the three blocks separately ‘ something that the FCC is currently blocking as it thinks that the spectrum blocks are complementary. Dish argues that this is not the case and that as the blocks are not interchangeable ‘there is no legitimate pro-competitive reason for the Commission to combine bidding eligibility, activity waivers and auction stopping rules.’
Dish’s spectrum ambitions are still unknown. It surely is wise enough not to try and build a national cellular network on its own, so partnerships seem like the most likely outcome. A deal with Sprint or T-Mobile, or even T-Sprint if the two end up merging, seems probable, but Dish may just be hunting down spectrum as a long term investment and waiting to offload it for the right price ‘ as we keep hearing that cellular spectrum is a finite resource and therefore worth a lot to the right buyer.