Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

31 July 2014

TV Upfront market falls, has the time come for online video?

The Wall Street Journal this week kicked off the idea that US TV Upfronts were both down, something that was also carried in the advertising specialist press, the Hollywood Reporter and Variety. The implications are that this year there will be lower TV ad sales in the US.

And yet recent reports, one in particular from eMarketer, would have us believe that this year advertising is on the rise after two years of being more or less flat, expected to grow around 5.8% globally, a bit less in the US.

So how can we picture an up advertising market after the US broadcast and cable Upfronts are significantly down, roughly 3% and 5% respectively.

There is a lot going on in advertising and it is worth pausing for a moment to try to work through it and see the implications for online video.

Here goes ‘ we think the Upfront (a discounted negotiation ahead of the release of a new season of shows ‘ one for broadcasters and another for cable dedicated channels) is down because scatter prior to them was down. Scatter is the ad hoc purchase of TV advertising.

Scatter was down for three reasons, the Upfronts were flat last year, so there was more money in the ’til for the big advertisers like Procter & Gamble and General Motors which should have been used up later. But instead that money has tended to be used to experiment with more and more online advertising, much of that around online digital video. Now advertisers have stumbled upon the idea that original content is attracting huge viewing numbers and are instead looking to divert at least a chunk of their TV revenue.

There was evidence of this during the Newfronts, the upfronts held at the end of April which drive online video content advertising sales, and online video players have organized themselves into a credible event, which runs ahead of the existing broadcast and cable upfronts, rather than mopping up what’s left.

One survey conducted at the time, of buy-side executives, showed nearly two-thirds of advertisers saying they plan to spend more on digital video advertising, which they would take from the TV advertising budget. More than half said that their actual spend would indeed go up, and so that’s the reason that we have this contradictory evidence ‘ both cases might be true ‘ TV advertising may well fall, while ad spend rises.

And it is always the really big advertisers like Procter & Gamble, Walmart, Diageo, Kellogg’s and General Motors who try these experiments first, because they have the resources to discover and research these changes.

This is turn will make original digital online video content more prosperous, and that will attract existing studios to buy into it, and we have already seen that happening. More and more, if a property got big in online digital video, it will shift to an OTT proposition and that will drive further user interest in OTT video, and so on.

All of that continues to undermine free to air TV, and the consolidation in pay TV operators undermines cable networks, and so does this shift in advertising. If digital video properties are NOT successful, then that money will return to TV next year, but if it IS successful, then even more will depart next year until that rule of thumb that TV makes up around 41% of advertising, moves until it is 39% and going lower.

Some of this of course is negotiation and most of the people in the advertising community said that if the Upfronts were down (for only the second time ever so no-one knows for sure) then the scatter would be up. But if the upfronts were down because there was less demand in the first half scatter market, then the difference between the price you pay in the upfronts and what you pay in spot advertising, gets smaller. So why would any advertiser commit for the coming season in advance, if they gained nothing for it ‘ they want the flexibility of changing their minds and dumping new TV programs that don’t pick up the audience they expect. And we think that a market with no upfront discount incentive, is a down market.