Pace has reinforced its global number one position in set tops and gateways after starting deliveries to several major new customers in the first half of 2014, putting the Saltaire, UK, company well ahead of forecasts for both profit and revenue. Even so it is overblown to talk about a Lazarus style return from the dead as some analysts have done, or even to say that the recovery is complete when H1 revenues were still down 13.6% year-on-year at $1.139 billion.
Pace’s case hardly merits comparison with Apple, since it was never out of the top two or three for set tops while the latter had become almost a marginal player in desk top computing in the late 1990s with the Mac until Steve Jobs engineered the recovery with iTunes. Pace’s case is more like IBM’s in the early 1990s when the company posted a $5 billion loss but remained the leading supplier of mainframe computers, which served as the platform for recovery.
Likewise Pace’s recovery has been engineered by good old fashioned cost cutting measures, combined with diversification in the supply chain and a refocus on high end boxes incorporating gateway and media server functionality, as well as expansion into software, infrastructure and services. The nosedive began early in 2011 after Pace had scaled the set top box summit to become number one in revenue, instigated by supply chain problems caused by monsoon floods in northern Thailand, which damaged the factories of its two biggest hard drive makers.
This knocked $77 million off H1 revenues for 2011 and slashed profits. As a result Pace issued three consecutive profit warnings that year, whose cumulative effect was to destroy market confidence and pull the share price down from 230p to 50p. The chairman, chief executive and finance director all departed, with Mike Pulli, formerly head of Pace’s American division for eight years, instilled as CEO. Pulli immediately embarked on cost cutting and set up a strategic review culminating in the push for high end boxes and media servers to increase margins, along with a long overdue overhaul of the supply chain.
The impact was almost immediate, with Pace almost exactly two years ago in July 2012 raising its revenue forecast for that full year, aided by a recovery in supply of hard drives, enabling outstanding orders to be fulfilled. Shares jumped 15% on that news and since then have continued to recover strongly, peaking at around 480p in May 2014, although subsiding below 400p in recent weeks, partly attributable to a worldwide stock slide over the last couple of months.
Pace’s vital economic statistics have improved steadily under Pulli’s reign, with operating margin before amortization (accounting for various intangible assets) up at 7.8% in 2013 from 6.6% in 2012 and forecast to reach 8.5% this year. The share price is now trading at 15 times forward earnings, which reflects greater confidence in the company than its rivals Cisco and Arris can boast. In fact one reason for Pace’s recovery is uncertainty around the strategy of key rivals, at any rate Cisco, in the face of the OTT revolution.
Unlike Cisco, Pace’s faith in its cable and satellite box markets has been unwavering and it has even benefited from the rise in OTT streaming though sales of high end hybrid boxes to existing customers. The greatest cause of optimism has been the new customer wins this year, including Sky Italia, Oi and GVT in Brazil, and North American sports network BeIn Sports. Sky Italia was the most significant win, especially in the light of BSkyB’s subsequent decision to buy the operation from Rupert Murdoch’s 21st Century Fox, along with the latter’s 54.5% share in Sky Deutschland, for £5 billion ($8.5 billion). This will create a European DTH power house to rival Liberty Global’s largely cable operation, with Pace well placed as it now supplies all three constituent companies, BSkyB, Sky Deutschland and Sky Italia.
Partly as a result of starting shipping to these new companies, Pace’s post tax profit was up 9.3% to $55.4 million over the full year to H1 2014. Pace has also benefited from riding the wave towards high end video gateways for the key satellite and cable markets. While the global market for set tops is flat, sales of high end gateways are rising fast, and this is reflected in Pace’s own figures. Revenues from set tops and media servers combined were $893.9 million in H1 2014, down from $1.07 billion a year earlier, while gateway revenues soared from $77.1 million to $190.3 million over the same period.
Drilling down into Pace’s figures and associated causal factors reveals that there are still some significant challenges. There are even signs that Pace is still vulnerable to supply chain issues, as happened in the case of one of its most important customers, Comcast, late 2013. Pace was one of two suppliers of Comcast’s cloud based set top X1, which became a victim of its own popularity with users. As a result demand from Comcast’s customers outstripped Pace’s ability to supply them, leading the operator in October 2013 to revert to an earlier plan to restrict allocations to new Triple Play customers. This annoyed existing customers who felt they should be rewarded for loyalty, leading Comcast to apologize publicly and state that it was working to ease the supply logjam.
Unfortunately for Pace this meant placing orders with the alternative X1 supplier Arris. It also led to Comcast delaying release of the software upgrade, called X2, enabling more advanced features including network DVR functionality. These have now been introduced but Pace has definitely lost out on sales that would have improved its North American performance. While North America remained Pace’s most lucrative market in H1, revenues of $699 million were well down on the $838 million a year earlier.
The Comcast debacle highlighted one structural weakness in Pace’s position, its continuing reliance on a relatively small number of major operators, with AT&T and DirecTV being other big customers in the US. The recent wins are welcome in that regard, but Pace will need to accelerate its diversification if it is to build on this recovery and develop a stable position less vulnerable to short term fluctuations in the market.
A very different sign of lingering turbulence was the sudden resignation this week of Roddy Murray, who has been Pace’s CFO for the past two years of recovery under Pulli. The reasons are not quite clear with Pace merely issuing a brief statement that these were personal and confidential. It did force the company to bring forward its results by 24 hours to pre-empt any significant disruption to the share price resulting from speculation that the resignation reflected bad news. Pace was only partly successful here, since the share price did slip by 13.4p or 4% on the news.
Although Murray was well regarded his departure is only really a temporary blip, since Pace’s future depends now on developing the right products and strategy to steer it through the continuing upheavals in the pay TV industry. Murray has at least bequeathed a sound financial base for his successor, former financial controller Belinda Ellis.