Netflix filed a 28-page document to the FCC on the last day of comment period for the FCC’s proposed new Internet rules that would allow ISPs (which are also pay TV providers) to make direct connection deals with online companies in exchange for fees paid to the ISP.
Netflix, which is opposed to such dealings because it has had to enter into a few in the US, said the Internet will turn into a closed system, much like pay TV, if the FCC allows ISPs to charge for access to their networks.
‘By endorsing the concept of paid prioritization, as well as ambiguous enforcement standards and processes, the Commission’s proposed rules arguably turn the objective of Internet openness on its head ‘ allowing the Internet to look more like a closed platform, such as a cable television service, rather than an open and innovative platform driven by consumers,’ Netflix said in its filing.
‘Given this, no FCC rules would be preferable to rules endorsing paid priority deals on the Internet.’
Netflix CEO Reed Hastings said such ‘paid prioritization’ schemes might leave subscribers unable to access some content online due to their ISP’s dealings with the Internet company. ‘In the cable industry, there has been constant conflict between the networks and the cable distributors leading to black outs and brown outs trying to figure out pricing,’ Hastings said at the company’s recent earnings call. ‘We would hate to see ISPs brownout or blackout certain Internet sites while they tried to extract payments. That just ruins the consumer experience.’
Netflix’s main argument is that last-mile protections ‘ the so-called net neutrality rules ‘ aren’t effective if ISPs can simply push their discrimination of data upstream to the interconnection points with Internet companies, rather than at the last segment of pipe to the user’s home.
‘Putting in last-mile protections while leaving interconnections exposed to abuse will do nothing about congestion at the front entrance to a terminating ISP’s network,’ Netflix said. ‘Instead, it will create a perverse incentive for the ISP to leave interconnection points congested, even in the face of growing data requests from its customers, in order to try to extract fees from online content providers to buy their way out of congestion.’
Netflix proposed that ISPs face penalties if their customers cannot receive third-party data at or near the speed to which they have subscribed. It also called for transparency in congestion issues on networks.
During the earnings call, Hastings was asked if Netflix may one day charge ISPs to carry its content, the way HBO charges pay TV providers to air its shows.
Hastings said when consumers sign up for the Internet they sign up to access anything and everything on the Internet. ‘I think the Internet really has this different, much more open architecture than classic cable,’ he said. ‘We meet in the middle: we bring the bits to where they [ISPs] want, we don’t charge them, they don’t charge us. It’s an open structure. I think then you get more competitors for Netflix, frankly.’