Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

31 July 2014

Long road ahead for LTE in shared spectrum bands

Operators are starting to implement carrier aggregation to increase capacity and make better use of disparate frequencies. However, they are also looking for additional spectrum, usually in bands where LTE will need to share with other technologies. Two particularly contentious options are 5GHz, where Qualcomm is pushing an LTE-Unlicensed option in WiFi’s traditional band; and 3.5GHz, which in the US would involve sharing with federal agencies, and could provide a blueprint for dynamic spectrum access (DSA) in other bands.

Qualcomm spearheaded the LTE-U proposal, which effectively uses 5GHz licence-exempt spectrum for supplemental downlink (SDL), adding capacity to a primary cell in a licensed band. Similar SDL techniques have been pioneered in other bands ‘ for instance, Qualcomm tested SDL with AT&T, using 700MHz unpaired frequencies, and Orange has trialled the approach using mobile satellite spectrum in 2GHz to add downlink capacity to LTE.

However, the 5GHz approach has greater complexities, and greater political sensitivity, because the band is unlicensed and the main area where WiFi has been expanding in capacity and capability. The current gigabit standard, 802.11ac, is mainly focused on 5GHz, as is the future 802.11ax (see separate item) for ultra-dense deployments. All this has made 5GHz the flagship band for those who campaign for more unlicensed spectrum and, more importantly, open technologies to harness it. Shortages in wireless broadband capacity can then be addressed by a wide range of service providers with flexible models and affordable prices, not a small group of carriers with closed networks.

Qualcomm, the great flagwaver for the cellular status quo, hits directly at this argument by proposing LTE-U, which give mobile operators more spectrum capacity, for free, while maintaining their control in a way that WiFi offload does not. LTE-U might be running in unlicensed frequencies, but because it acts as a secondary system under the control of the primary network controller, it is still fully within the carrier’s walls.

There are all kinds of barriers in the way, however, not least that LTE-U is now part of the 3GPP Release 13 work, and so will not be fully standardized until early 2016. By that time, the build-out of advanced WiFi, and the power of the WiFi lobby worldwide, will be even greater than now. Indeed, advances by the WiFi sector will help make LTE-U less appealing to cellcos. Technologies which allow WiFi hotspots to be managed from their mobile cores address some of the issues of bringing non-3GPP technologies into their mix ‘ offloading low value traffic is fine, but carriers fear losing the ability to monitor and monetize their subscribers once they roam into the unlicensed wilderness. That is starting to be addressed by common management and single sign-off techniques, such as Hotspot 2.0, Next Generation Hotspot and 3GPP work.

These developments indicate how most mobile operators acknowledge that they need WiFi, and would be shooting themselves in the foot if they compromised its performance. Coexistence between two technologies which work completely differently is hard, and LTE-U, while it may be part of the long LTE-Advanced menu of features, is very much the newcomer and could be left on the shelf.

There are echoes of the difficulties WiMAX faced in its 5GHz implementation, and even in the technology’s heyday, that band went largely ignored in favor of licensed 2.5GHz and 3.5GHz. Like WiMAX, LTE transmissions are scheduled by the base station, while WiFi implements ‘listen before talk’ (carrier sense multiple access) to support sharing between different users.

That has led to opposition, even within the 3GPP, on the basis that LTE-U would interfere with or even block WiFi transmissions (other objections revolved around different regulatory requirements in different regions for 5GHz). But Qualcomm argues that it will be simpler for cellcos to manage a 5GHz extension of their main network, rather than a separate WiFi system, and claims its simulations have shown LTE-U delivering twice the performance of a similar network of WiFi access point in 5GHz.

The company has acknowledged the interference fears though, and has updated its proposal with several coexistence features, designed to reduce the risk to WiFi, particularly in China, Korea and the US, whose regulations make conflict particularly concerning.

The other topical area of spectrum for potential LTE expansion is 3.5GHz. This is already allocated for broadband wireless in many countries, though some have not yet added a mobility aspect, and there are even some deployments, such as UK Broadband’s in London. However, in the US, this spectrum is occupied by various government agencies, and so the FCC has outlined proposals to allow sharing via dynamic spectrum access (DSA). By contrast with previous FCC suggestions, new chair Tom Wheeler is not proposing to divide the band, but to unleash a full 100MHz (3550MHz-3650MHz, and possible expansion to 3700MHz), with flexible usage. However, it would be subject to three-tiered access prioritization for federal and non-federal incumbent users, priority access licensees (PALs) and the general public. A centralized Spectrum Access System (SAS) would assign channels dynamically between the PALs.

However, there is plenty of opposition to these plans too.

Some are on the basis that access will be too restricted. In responses to the proposals this month, Google and many others said the exclusion zones, designed to protect incumbent government users, were “improperly conceived” and would deny access to more than half of the US population. Google also objected to a plan to base priority licences on census tracts, arguing that a carrier would often not be able to deploy a small cell network within a single tract.

Others, particularly cellcos, are more worried the SAS, and broader moves away from the traditional forms of licensing. They have always argued that long term static licensing gives operators the guarantees to make major investments in infrastructure and services, which dynamic access does not.

AT&T supported the idea of an SAS in principle, but said it must make static, not dynamic, spectrum assignments for priority licensees. “In the case of PALs, real time or near-real time interference management is not practical between PAL users due to stringent interference reporting requirements that will be difficult to be met by the proposed SAS architecture and also due to the disparity of technologies that can be used by PAL users,” AT&T said.

T-Mobile wanted the SAS to have authority only over general access segments of spectrum and also called on the FCC to issue licences to PALs using more traditional mechanisms, such as using areas larger than census tracts, at fixed frequencies, and for terms greater than one year. In other words, the operators have adjusted to the wild west of licensing and regulation in unlicensed bands, because they have had to harness WiFi, but they do not want those practices creeping into licensed spectrum.

While many, including Google, support the three-tiered structure, Qualcomm is particularly strong in opposition to it, because it would be unique in the world, and so could see delays in obtaining supporting technology. Outside the US, it noted in its filing, ETSI is working on a two-tiered spectrum sharing framework called ASA (authorized shared access), for use initially in the European Union’s 2.3GHz band. That would be more likely to be emulated worldwide, and so attract vendors, operators and equipment, than the FCC’s pattern. Qualcomm said that approach, with its “ultra-small geographic areas with ultra-short licences” would delay development of small cells in 3.5GHz, which some see as a potential global roaming band for these base stations.