Video games have evolved from the experimental hijinks of academics with access to exorbitantly expensive computers in universities, to the highly personal ubiquitous games found today on smartphones. Since the first video games on oscilloscopes in the 50s, the gaming experience has moved in line with hardware costs, becoming a very accessible industry – worth tens of billions of dollars, and growing every year.
In the early days of video games, public arcades meant that hundreds of people could play for the cost of a few coins on a machine that would cost the equivalent of several months’ worth of the average household wage. Multiple machines meant that gamers had an entire library to choose from, and it was in the industry’s interest to keep updating the arcades with the newest titles. The public setting also allowed a competitive edge to evolve, with players competing to leave their high score on the home screen for all to see.
But as the cost of computing power decreased the distribution model shifted to a more personal experience, on dedicated gaming machinery which is end user owned. This gave rise to the consoles of the 80s that have persisted to the present day, as well as video games on PCs. These pre-broadband consoles moved from the gladiatorial and high score focused games (perfect for the public arena) into story-driven and narrative video games, with the Super Mario and Zelda Series being perhaps the most notable examples of this period in video game history, before consoles utilized home broadband connections.
While Microsoft’s Xbox and Sony’s PlayStation 2 had a few titles near the end of their lives that could allow gamers to play against other players in online arenas, it was the following generation of the Xbox 360 and the PlayStation 3 that really embraced online multiplayer. In a similar time frame, around 2006, social media websites began adopting browser-based Flash games as significant page view generators, and as smartphones emerged into mass market devices, these sorts of Flash games migrated across from PC web browsers to smart phone apps.
It was only when smartphone hardware had caught up with PCs and older generation consoles that gaming could become a prominent experience on mobile – years ahead of the old Tetris and Snake games that were found on handsets such as the Nokia 3310.
Games on mobile phones were initially only meant to kill time, as they couldn’t be the engaging experience of arcades or consoles due to the constraints of the input mechanisms (keypads vs. joysticks and buttons), or immersion (large screens, substantial sound systems, mechanical feedback). The restrictions of internal storage also meant that a mobile game couldn’t rely on being story-driven to engage the player, as a lengthy narrative arc would chew up too much storage space.
And strangely, this trend has continued despite rapid improvements in the gaming capabilities of mobile hardware in recent years. The flagship handsets of today are more powerful than the Xbox 360 and PS3, but mobile has not taken off as a ‘serious’ gaming platform – a realm still dominated by the consoles and PCs. This is largely due to the constraints put on a handset by its battery life, as processor-intensive tasks like gaming will drain a battery very quickly. This results in mobile users treating mobile gaming as a ‘killing time’ task for queues or commutes rather than a ‘sit down’ experience such as consoles.
But despite this, mobile gaming’s revenues are on the up across the board, despite being a fairly radical departure from the other video game industry business models. Games of the Nokia 3310 era were bundled on the phone by the manufacturer, not quite as an afterthought, but definitely not a key feature or unique selling point. In fact, adding games to the phone once bought was quite difficult on most feature phones, largely based around SMS deals and subsequent data download links. Some networks slowly embraced games via their own web portals, with downloads possible on the later models, but again these were comparatively exorbitant compared to the mobile games of today.
This is because in the smartphone and app store era, most games on handsets are offered for free and hope to convince players to spend small amounts of cash in game on virtual bonuses. These micro-transactions are a core part of the Freemium business model, which hopes to entice gamers through the door with no upfront charge and then make a few dollars here and there as players are subjected to the increasing difficulty or longer waiting times to replenish either abilities or lives/credits (‘cool downs’) that are inherently built into the games to encourage micro-transactions. The Freemium approach has also been found on console and PC gaming, especially in the world of ‘free-to-play’ (F2P) massively multiplayer online games (MMOs) which are frequently criticized as being ‘pay-to-win’ (P2W) rather than F2P thanks to the advantages given to players who use micro-transactions to purchase better in-game items and abilities.
The other approach to game design is to charge nothing for the game but to insert advertising into the experience, usually in the form of banner ads at the bottom of the screen (conveniently near to key buttons to encourage accidental click-throughs, some would say) or to put adverts on loading screens. Viral sensation Flappy Bird cost nothing for gamers to download but was so popular that the single hobbyist developer was reportedly making tens of thousands of dollars each month in ad revenue before he pulled the game from the app stores due to the overwhelming response. iPhones with the app installed were selling for thousands of dollars after the app was no longer available, and really it all got a bit weird. Flappy Bird is now set to return as an Amazon Fire TV app, which is something of a win for Amazon in terms of exclusivity but perhaps a little late given that viral sensations have incredibly short shelf lives.
Nonetheless, mobile gaming is currently a huge market. Figures from a CyberZ report on mobile gaming in Japan, China, South Korea, Taiwan and Hong Kong showed 2013 revenue doubled in a year to reach $8.9 billion, with the report forecasting 2014 revenues at $12.1 billion and 2017 at $21.1 billion – all this on games that are designed to be addictive and encourage micro-transactions to receive that fix. There’s a reason why Candy Crush requires you to beg your Facebook friends for credits or why Farmville tries to get players to post activity or requests to their public profiles. In the Freemium model, the player is not the customer, for they are not paying. Instead, they are almost entirely a product for advertisers.
But it’s a business model that shows no real signs of slowing. Strategy Analytics reports that global video game spending will grow 10% to $62 billion in 2014. The new consoles will drive disk sales up 16% to $25.5 billion, online gaming will grow 7% to $19.4 billion, and mobile games will increase 6% to $17.3 billion. While online and mobile gaming have increased in market share, disk-based game sales have fallen from 68% of all revenue five years ago to 41% of the market.
So a predicted global worth of $17.3 billion for mobile games that predominantly are Freemium models shows the scale of the mobile market that accounts for 28% of the total. Strategy Analytics notes that mobile gaming is more popular in Asia, and that console and PC spending in Europe and America is roughly twice that of Asia. The report notes the growth in mobile gamers, with the number growing 14% in 2014 to 1.7 billion and crossing the 2 billion mark in 2016.
That’s a huge number, and means that each mobile gamer in 2014 is worth around $10 to the gaming industry each year – predominantly on the back of micro-transactions and advertising given that paid downloads are vastly outnumbered in app store downloads by free versions of paid games or completely free games.
Eric Smith of the firm says ‘while there are some structural concerns around the over-supply of cheap to free games – particularly on smartphones and tablets – the games industry remains in rude health. Humans have always played games, it’s up to the industry to provide the outlets which best match contemporary habits. Given the breadth of innovation set to hit the market over the next few years ‘ whether Oculus Rift VR, Steamboxes or the lively Android-based micro-console scene, there has never been a better time to love playing video games.’
There are a few issues with Smith’s optimism here, or at least in the examples he gives. Mobile gaming, as we’ve discussed earlier is not typically viewed by its participants as serious gaming. Sure, it’s fun and often addictive, but it isn’t sit down marathon gaming for entire Sundays ‘ like the binge-viewing equivalent to Netflix. Until mobile games start innovating instead of endlessly imitating, they aren’t particularly exciting and certainly can’t be thought of as the future of gaming even though they are collectively a big earner for the industry.
As such, the main issue with Smith’s outlook is that he cites concerns with the issue of oversupply of freemium games, while remaining optimistic about the ‘breadth of innovation set to hit the market over the next few years.’ We’re sorry for using Flappy Bird as a constant example, but in the wake of its emergence and subsequent disappearance, the Android and iOS app stores were flooded with thousands of imitations hoping for downloads ‘ shamelessly ripping off what was objectively a lag-filled, repetitive, and most importantly, completely free game. The app stores boast about having over a million apps, but never publish figures that show what percentage of apps are imitations or flagrant copies of more popular programs.
Smith is almost certainly aware of the issue, being only a few words away from saying it explicitly, but one of the reasons why mobile gaming remains a low margin experience for developers and a time-killing activity for gamers is that there are so many free to download mobile games on the market that gamers don’t have to pay a penny to kill time for a few minutes each day. It’s simply a matter of downloading the next app when you get tired of your current one. There’s almost no customer loyalty to brands, and most games submitted to the stores never turn a profit. Many are never even downloaded.
But there is another issue in Smith’s closing statement, and that is his optimism, which appears to be industry-wide, that new hardware will spur the industry to new heights. We aren’t as confident that devices like Oculus Rift will dramatically boost revenue simply due to the fact that it’s expensive. While photorealistic virtual reality headsets will no doubt enjoy more success than Nintendo’s forays into the field with its 1995 Virtual Boy, which cost $180 and was discontinued after 9 months, they are still a gaming accessory ‘ and accessories never sell as well as the fundamentally required hardware and disks.
Gamers, and often their parents, want to spend as little as possible to receive the core experience. It’s hard to justify a $400 VR headset when the console costs the same amount. The Rift project has just been acquired by Facebook for $2 billion, but there is still no product launch date some 5 years into serious development. It may be technologically impressive, but it’s hard to see it being a mass market device.
Similarly, Smith points to Steamboxes, the DIY or OEM way to get a PC in the living room running the Steam OS. Steam is the largest games portal and distribution service in the world and lets users download a client through which they can buy and launch games. Steam provides the DRM and automatic download and update managers, and users are able to play their Steam purchases from any computer they log in from.
The official Steamboxes were due to launch this year but were postponed until 2015 at the earliest. OEM launches are going ahead this year, as planned. But the Steambox concept is also a strange one given that it is a PC in a console form factor ‘ which begs the questions; if you want a console-sized box to play games on why not just buy a console, and if you want a PC in the living room why not just put your PC in the living room? The answer is that Steam has a much greater library of games than consoles, but that’s a fact that doesn’t seem to be deterring the sales of the Xbox One or PS4 currently.
But Smith is right in saying ‘there has never been a better time to love playing video games,’ as access to games in general has never been easier. Every mobile device has the ability to play some very compelling and enjoyable games if you can wade through the torrent of titles vying for your attention in the app stores, and the PC and console game developing incumbents are being shaken up by crowdfunded ventures and a resurgence in the popularity of low-budget independent developer games.
Next week we will dive further into the breakdowns of the demographics of each gaming sector, to look at who’s spending what and where, as well as looking to future developments in technology that could seriously impact the industry as a whole.