Bloomberg this week claims to have two insiders telling it that Liberty Global has more or less agreed concessions that have convinced the European Commission that its deal to buy Ziggo should get approval. Long term followers of European Union dominant mergers and anti-trust cases will know that the European Commission never leaks, and that the only source of these rumors can be Liberty Global.
The truth is likely to be that Liberty Global thinks it can affect the outcome by putting media pressure on the Commission, but here at Faultline we are largely unconvinced by the Bloomberg story. However the headlines this week have it that Liberty Global is about to win its cause, and complete a deal that will see the creation of a single dominant triple play supplier within the Netherlands, to the detriment of the incumbent telco.
The resulting merger will give it overnight 60% of the pay TV market by number of homes, more like 70% by value, and just under 3 million broadband lines. It would immediately take it beyond the incumbent Telco KPN, which has only 2.7 million domestic broadband lines and 1.9 million TV customers. On top of this, the combination of Liberty Global and Ziggo would dwarf the number of hotspots that KPN owns, given that they have just created 1.5 million homespot based commercial hotspots during 2013 in the Netherlands, while KPN has rushed to roll out its own 500,000 using FON, during 2014.
Even telephony lines are a match, with the two cable companies owning 2.5 million or 48% of the market, while KPN, which was once the incumbent, control the rest.
This is straightforward. Never in the history of mergers has a single company been created with a dominant share in three major, healthy markets. Mergers which target 30% of a market, where that shareholder is the market leader, have been virtually forbidden in the last 50 years throughout the civilized world. If the European Commission did agree such a deal, it would be the end of its influence and allow monopolies across Europe in every walk of life. It would create economic carnage for the private citizen with prices spiraling out of control.
Consequently the Netherlands Competition Commission, the NMa, would try to intercede, KPN would go to war in court and potentially the Netherlands government would secede from the European Union. So we wonder at the publications that blithely repeat such a rumor when such a decision would be monumental and massively disruptive. They should at least announce it along with the end of the world as we know it.
Back in May there was a Reuters story that the European Commission had decided to move the deal to a phase two investigation and when the original August deadline was extended to October, and now we are being told nby Liberty Global that it must extend its offer for Ziggo shares into November because that’s when the Commission will report. Delay in these matters usually means their refusal, it is rarely a process of negotiation, at least in Europe, although this is more common in the US.
So to us every indicator is that the deal will be blocked, and that this is the last throw of the dice by a desperate Liberty Global management team that wants to bring media pressure onto the Commission.
The idea that this is the Commission’s decision and its alone, and not the local regulator, comes from the idea that where two companies are above a certain stature ‘ for instance the core condition is the two companies have a combined turnover above €5 billion or they have EU revenues above €250 million. But this is done when the local regulator won’t have enough perspective and won’t be able to muster a defense against a determined and litigious multinational with most operations outside its footprint. But the merger is entirely within the Netherlands and so it has to obey Netherlands version of the merger laws. As far as we can see, it doesn’t.
There is an erroneous view of things here, which goes something like this ‘ If the EU takes on the merger, then the country merger authority has lost control and if the EU decides that the merger is okay in European terms ‘ in other words it does not distort markets on an EU-wide basis, then there is nothing that the local merger authority can do and it doesn’t matter if it distorts markets on a local basis. On that understanding there are many mergers which would never have been allowed, which have in fact been historically turned down.
The rumors suggest that simply by selling the company’s premium movie channel and undertaking promises to allow access for OTT operators like Netflix (sure just like Comcast, Verizon and AT&T have ‘ for cash), that the deal is okay. Telephony, broadband and pay TV pricing would go off the chart and KPN would have gone from incumbent to also ran in a single transaction. Ask yourself, if you were the Netherlands, would you stand for that?